Zumper

Alert me when this rental is available.

modified
Updated 5+ Days Ago

Highlights

  • Fully renovated
  • All other utilities included
  • Brand new stainless steel appliances

Location

Bay Shore #5A, NY 11706, USA|Bay Shore

Available rentals nearby

featured image of 61 W Main St

Bay Shore • 61 W Main St

2 Beds

$2,950

featured image of 35 Penataquit Ave

Bay Shore • 35 Penataquit Ave

2 Beds

$2,615–$2,990

featured image of 1721 N Gardiner Dr

North Bay Shore • 1721 N Gardiner Dr

2 Beds

$2,500–$2,695

featured image of 67 Prospect St

Babylon • 67 Prospect St

2 Beds

$2,600

featured image of 124 10th Ave

Brentwood • 124 10th Ave

2 Beds

$2,900

featured image of 99 Washington St

East Islip • 99 Washington St

2 Beds

$3,000

featured image of 7A Hemlock Dr ##65

North Bay Shore • 7A Hemlock Dr ##65

2 Beds

$2,500

featured image of 255 Smith St

Central Islip • 255 Smith St

2 Beds

$2,300

featured image of 61 W Main St

Bay Shore • 61 W Main St

2 Beds

$2,950

featured image of 35 Penataquit Ave

Bay Shore • 35 Penataquit Ave

2 Beds

$2,615–$2,990

featured image of 1721 N Gardiner Dr

North Bay Shore • 1721 N Gardiner Dr

2 Beds

$2,500–$2,695

featured image of 67 Prospect St

Babylon • 67 Prospect St

2 Beds

$2,600

featured image of 124 10th Ave

Brentwood • 124 10th Ave

2 Beds

$2,900

featured image of 99 Washington St

East Islip • 99 Washington St

2 Beds

$3,000

featured image of 7A Hemlock Dr ##65

North Bay Shore • 7A Hemlock Dr ##65

2 Beds

$2,500

featured image of 255 Smith St

Central Islip • 255 Smith St

2 Beds

$2,300

Rent trends in Bay Shore

2-bedroom apartments at 1731 NORTH GARDINER DRIVE-5A #5A cost about 14% less than the average rent price for 2-bedroom apartments in Bay Shore.

Median rents as of Aug 15 2026.
Bay Shore
Bay Shore
A table of 2-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Bay Shore
MonthMedian Rent
August 2024$3,038
September 2024$3,128
October 2024$3,090
November 2024$3,075
December 2024$3,050
January 2025$3,028
February 2025$3,034
March 2025$3,061
April 2025$3,053
May 2025$3,130
June 2025$3,184
July 2025$3,094
August 2025$2,930
September 2025$2,847
October 2025$2,826
November 2025$2,844
December 2025$3,112
January 2026$3,158
February 2026$3,155
March 2026$2,979
April 2026$2,760
May 2026$2,927
June 2026$3,095
July 2026$3,132
August 2026$3,135
A table of 2-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Bay Shore
MonthMedian Rent
August 2024$3,038
September 2024$3,128
October 2024$3,090
November 2024$3,075
December 2024$3,050
January 2025$3,028
February 2025$3,034
March 2025$3,061
April 2025$3,053
May 2025$3,130
June 2025$3,184
July 2025$3,094
August 2025$2,930
September 2025$2,847
October 2025$2,826
November 2025$2,844
December 2025$3,112
January 2026$3,158
February 2026$3,155
March 2026$2,979
April 2026$2,760
May 2026$2,927
June 2026$3,095
July 2026$3,132
August 2026$3,135

Schools near 1731 NORTH GARDINER DRIVE-5A #5A

Fifth Avenue School

217 5th ave

bay shore, NY, 11706

K-2Public
A-

Gardiner Manor School

125 wohseepee dr

bay shore, NY, 11706

3-5Public
B

Fire Island School (Woodhull School)

750 surf road

corneille estates, NY, 11770

PK, K-6Public

Western Suffolk BOCES

507 deer park rd

dix hills, NY, 11746

K-12Public

P.S. 256Q

525 convent rd

syosset, NY, 11791

PK, K-12Public
Powered byniche.com
Advertisement

Internet available near 1731 NORTH GARDINER DRIVE-5A #5A

Getting around NY 11706 near Bay Shore #5A

Walking

6/10
Some shops and stores are within a few minutes.

Driving

6/10
This area is accessible to thoroughfares and has ample parking options.

Cycling

3/10
This is semi-bikeable, but you’ll need another way of getting around.

Transit

4/10
There are a few mass transit options within the area.

Points of interest for Bay Shore #5A, NY 11706

Groceries

7/10
Wide variety of groceries within a short drive, including some within walking distance

Shopping

6/10
Wide variety of shops within a short drive, including some within walking distance

Cafes

5/10
Variety of cafés within a short drive

Restaurants

7/10
Wide variety of restaurants within a short drive, including some within walking distance

Primary schools

9/10
At least one elementary school within a 10-minute walk

High schools

10/10
At least one high school within a 5-minute walk

Nightlife

6/10
Wide variety of bars within a short drive, including some within walking distance

Notify me

We’ll let you know when this property is available and send you similar listings.

Full name*
Move-in date*
By sending this inquiry, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values. By providing my phone number, I consent (not a condition of purchase) to be called and texted by Bay Shore #5A, NY 11706, USA.