Nearby rentals
Renter hub
Property management
Filters
The average rent in Bay Shore, as of July 2026, is down 1.52% compared to last month and down 13.15% year-over-year.
Average rent
Track prices
Rent calculator
What can I afford?
All rentals
5d+ ago
House for rent in Bay Shore
39 39 Midway Walk, Bay Shore, NY 11706
In-unit laundry | Hardwood floor | Deck
4 beds
2 baths
$5,000
House for rent
21h ago
1–2 beds
1–2 baths
$2,800–$3,500
Apartment for rent
22h ago
Studio–1 bed
1 bath
$2,650–$2,800
Apartment for rent
1d ago
Apartment for rent in Bay Shore
87 Community Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
In-unit laundry | Air conditioning | Ceiling fan
2 beds
2 baths
$4,000
Apartment for rent
1d ago
35 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
In-unit laundry | Air conditioning | On-site laundry
Studio–2 beds
1 bath
$2,125–$2,995
Apartment for rent
1d ago
1 bed
1 bath
$2,428–$2,850
Apartment for rent
1d ago
Studio–2 beds
1 bath
$1,950–$2,875
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Bay Shore
227 4th Ave #306E, Bay Shore, NY 11706
In-unit laundry | Assigned parking | Elevator
1 bed
1 bath
$2,850
Apartment for rent
Be the first to hear about new listings matching your search.
5d+ ago
House for rent in Bay Shore
1396 Illinois Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Storage | Dishwasher | Outdoor space
3 beds
1 bath
$4,200
House for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Bay Shore
52 Garfield St #40, Bay Shore, NY 11706
In-unit laundry | On-site laundry | Hardwood floor
2 beds
1 bath
$3,100
Apartment for rent
Available Jul 15
Outdoor Space
In-Unit Laundry
Dishwasher
On-Site Laundry
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Bay Shore
1 bed
1 bath
$2,350
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Bay Shore
1 bed
1 bath
$2,200
House for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Bay Shore
3 beds
1 bath
$3,195
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Bay Shore
227 4th Ave #207F, Bay Shore, NY 11706
In-unit laundry | Assigned parking | Elevator
1 bed
1 bath
$2,950
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Bay Shore
202 N Clinton Ave #GL, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Carpet | Microwave
1 bed
1 bath
$2,000
Apartment for rent
Available Jun 1
5d+ ago
House for rent in Bay Shore
35 Sloop Walk, Bay Shore, NY 11706
In-unit laundry | Air conditioning | Swimming pool
5 beds
3 baths
$12,000
House for rent
These rentals are 10%-30% cheaper than the local average price for similar rentals.
5d+ ago
House for rent in Bay Shore
8 beds
4 baths
$16,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Bay Shore
3 beds
1.5 baths
$5,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in North Bay Shore
1741 N Gardiner Dr Apt 14b #14B, North Bay Shore, NY 11706
Balcony | Roof deck | Microwave
2 beds
1 bath
$2,695
Apartment for rent
Available May 1
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in North Bay Shore
1 Hemlock Dr #C152, North Bay Shore, NY 11706
Walk-in closets | Ceiling fan
2 beds
1 bath
$2,550
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in North Bay Shore
183 Massachusetts Ave #NA, North Bay Shore, NY 11706
Furnished | Deck | Outdoor space
1 bed
1 bath
$1,500
House for rent
Available Jun 1
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in North Bay Shore
1739 N Gardiner Dr Apt 19b #19B, North Bay Shore, NY 11706
Central heat | Hardwood floor | Ceiling fan
2 beds
1 bath
$2,750
Apartment for rent
Available May 1
2d ago
Apartment for rent in Islip
2446 Union Blvd, Islip, NY 11751
In-unit laundry | Furnished | Microwave
1 bed
1 bath
$3,500
Apartment for rent
Available Sep 6
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in West Islip
1 bed
1 bath
$2,100
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Islip
143 Church Ave, Islip, NY 11751
In-unit laundry | Assigned parking | Outdoor space
1 bed
1 bath
$2,000
Apartment for rent
Available Jul 1
Are you a rental professional?
18 rentals
3 rentals
7 rentals
4 rentals
5 rentals
13 rentals
6 rentals
10 rentals
17 rentals
3 rentals
19 rentals
3 rentals
4 rentals
5 rentals
3 rentals
13 rentals
2 rentals
6 rentals
10 rentals
3 rentals
Locals in Bay Shore, NY, appreciate the blend of suburban life and easy access to waterfront activities. The vibrant downtown area offers diverse dining options and shops, making it a lively spot for socializing. Many residents enjoy the parks and nature trails nearby, ideal for outdoor activities. However, some note concerns about rising rent prices and traffic congestion, which can impact the overall livability for renters seeking a quieter suburban lifestyle.
Bay Shore has a median rent of around $2,860 based on available data. The rental market offers a solid selection with an average of 56 listings available per month, providing options for renters seeking affordable housing in the area.
Bay Shore rentals rarely include utilities as part of the rent package. Only about 2 listings include utilities, representing less than 1% of total available properties across all bedroom types.
Bay Shore's rental market features predominantly Colonial architecture, which represents 48% of all properties in the area. This classic American architectural style dates back to the 1600s and 1700s, characterized by symmetrical facades, multi-pane windows, and central doorways that create a cohesive traditional neighborhood aesthetic.
Zumper’s proprietary rental data fuels our analysis. Rent and market trends, availability, neighborhood popularity, and lifestyle scores are all calculated using real-time and 2026 rental inventory and prices.
Our Lifestyle Categories ("great for eco-living," "great for social life," "great for pet owners," etc.) are determined by set criteria, against which we score each listing and its available features. At the neighborhood level, we calculate the listing count for each category to determine which lifestyles best fit each area.
Zumper, founded in 2012, is North America’s largest privately-owned rental platform, offering over 1 million listings across the U.S. and Canada. Stay informed on the latest trends and shifts in the rental market with our monthly National Rent Report, your go-to resource for key insights into the evolving rental landscape.
| 🔑Available apartment rentals | 25 |
|---|---|
| 💰Best rent deal | 183 Massachusetts Ave #NA |
| ✨Popular amenities | , , |
| 🍽With dishwasher | |
| 🏠With photos |