Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Quietly set in Bay Shore, this 4-bed, 2-bath house offers weekly rentals at $5,000 for Fire Island vacations. The newly renovated kitchen opens to a large deck with ocean and bay views, plus hardwood floors, central air, in-unit laundry, and dishwasher across two floors. Top-rated elementary school just 0.2 miles away.

Located in Bay Shore, these 1-2 bedroom apartments include full appliance packages with in-unit washer and dryer, dishwasher, microwave, range, and refrigerator. Units come with open parking and trash service, near dozens of restaurants including Toast Coffeehouse, Kumo Sushi, and Fire Island ferry access.

Residents of North District Lofts enjoy affordable housing with a prime focus on community living. Featuring attractive units on multiple floors with patios, this property provides essential amenities while ensuring a vibrant neighborhood atmosphere. With an income requirement ranging from $78,057 to $129,262, it offers an excellent opportunity for those seeking a home that balances affordability and accessibility.

Residents appreciate the cleanliness and responsive management at North District Lofts, particularly praising the maintenance staff. The small building atmosphere and available parking are also highlights. However, some feel the rent is too high compared to nearby suburbs and express frustration over parking challenges. A few have had negative experiences related to rental eligibility based on their profession.

Set in Bay Shore, these recently remodeled studio, 1, and 2-bedroom apartments feature hardwood flooring, stainless-steel appliances, and in-unit laundry. The brick community includes expansive green courtyards, playground, and storage, with top-rated schools nearby - a good fit for pet owners with outdoor space and multiple pet services in the area.

Mid Island Apartments residents consistently praise Rob, the superintendent, for his quick, reliable maintenance service and helpful attitude. The well-maintained grounds and relatively quiet location near the hospital and train are appreciated. Staff including Analia in leasing receive positive feedback for being understanding and thorough.

Set in Bay Shore, NY, this oversized one-bedroom apartment includes a fireplace, in-unit washer/dryer, and full appliance package with dishwasher. The unit comes with open parking and trash service, near top-rated schools within half a mile and close to Westfield South Shore Mall for shopping and dining.

Located in Bay Shore, NY, these apartments include assigned parking, onsite laundry, and essential appliances like refrigerator, range, and microwave. The community sits near numerous dining options including Toast Coffeehouse, Fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro, and Fire Island ferry access for weekend getaways.

Experience upscale living in this stylish 1-bedroom apartment within the Chelsea Commons development. Spanning 671 sq. ft., this spacious unit features an elevator, in-unit laundry, and energy-efficient P-Tac heating/cooling. Enjoy easy access to shopping, dining, and nearby beaches. With 33 parking spaces available and an appealing pet policy, this apartment is ideal for those looking for comfort and convenience in a vibrant community.

This 3-bed, 1-bath apartment in Bay Shore offers modern finishes and a bright layout across 1,200 sqft of colonial-style living. The second-floor unit includes off-street parking and basement laundry access - a fit for pet owners with grooming services, pet hospitals, and supply stores nearby. Move-in ready with thoughtful updates throughout.

Apartment with 1 bed in Bay Shore, this 771 sqft unit at Chelsea Commons includes in-unit laundry, elevator access, and assigned parking. The 1-bath layout features P-Tac heating/cooling with landlord covering water, sewer, and garbage. Located minutes from downtown Main Street shops, restaurants, and the Fire Island Ferry, with a top-rated high school just 0.2 miles away.

This 500 square-foot apartment in Bay Shore includes a 1-bed, 1-bath layout on the second floor of a shared house. Freshly painted with tile and laminate flooring, the unit comes with a full kitchen featuring refrigerator, range, and microwave. Walking distance to train, bus, and downtown makes it a fit for commuters, with top-rated schools nearby and cat-friendly policy.

Set in Bay Shore, this ranch-style 5-bed, 3-bath house sits on a large double lot in the exclusive Summer Club community. The 2,185 sqft open-concept layout features central air, in-unit laundry, and an oversized deck for entertaining. Pool installation completes for 2026, plus access to private beachfront, bayfront beach with Great South Bay sunsets, clubhouse, gym, and tennis courts.

A 8-bed, 4-bath house in Bay Shore, NY's Bay Shore neighborhood, this brand new 2023-built Fire Island retreat offers breathtaking Great South Bay views and sleeps 16 guests. The custom two-story layout features multiple indoor and outdoor living areas, in-unit laundry, and a den, just off the ferry and close to the beach. Weekly rental at $16,000 for vacation stays.

Located in Bay Shore, this 3-bed, 1.5-bath cottage-style house offers magnificent sunset views and serves as a weekly vacation rental at $5,000 per week. The seven-room layout includes in-unit laundry and separate entrances, with beach chairs and umbrellas provided. Great location for watersports, fishing, and boating enthusiasts seeking Fire Island access.