Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Set in Bay Shore, this ranch-style 5-bed, 3-bath house sits on a large double lot in the exclusive Summer Club community. The 2,185 sqft open-concept layout features central air, in-unit laundry, and an oversized deck for entertaining. Pool installation completes for 2026, plus access to private beachfront, bayfront beach with Great South Bay sunsets, clubhouse, gym, and tennis courts.

Quietly set in Bay Shore, this 4-bed, 2-bath house offers weekly rentals at $5,000 for Fire Island vacations. The newly renovated kitchen opens to a large deck with ocean and bay views, plus hardwood floors, central air, in-unit laundry, and dishwasher across two floors. Top-rated elementary school just 0.2 miles away.

Located in Bay Shore, this 3-bed, 1.5-bath cottage-style house offers magnificent sunset views and serves as a weekly vacation rental at $5,000 per week. The seven-room layout includes in-unit laundry and separate entrances, with beach chairs and umbrellas provided. Great location for watersports, fishing, and boating enthusiasts seeking Fire Island access.

Located in Bay Shore, NY, these apartments include assigned parking, onsite laundry, and essential appliances like refrigerator, range, and microwave. The community sits near numerous dining options including Toast Coffeehouse, Fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro, and Fire Island ferry access for weekend getaways.

Set in Bay Shore, these recently remodeled studio, 1, and 2-bedroom apartments feature hardwood flooring, stainless-steel appliances, and in-unit laundry. The brick community includes expansive green courtyards, playground, and storage, with top-rated schools nearby - a good fit for pet owners with outdoor space and multiple pet services in the area.

Mid Island Apartments residents consistently praise Rob, the superintendent, for his quick, reliable maintenance service and helpful attitude. The well-maintained grounds and relatively quiet location near the hospital and train are appreciated. Staff including Analia in leasing receive positive feedback for being understanding and thorough.

Residents of Eleven Maple enjoy access to a stunning roof deck and a state-of-the-art fitness center. The community features inviting outdoor spaces with BBQ grills, ensuring leisure and enjoyment for everyone. Located on various floors, each unit offers unique perspectives and comfort.

Residents of North District Lofts enjoy affordable housing with a prime focus on community living. Featuring attractive units on multiple floors with patios, this property provides essential amenities while ensuring a vibrant neighborhood atmosphere. With an income requirement ranging from $78,057 to $129,262, it offers an excellent opportunity for those seeking a home that balances affordability and accessibility.

Residents appreciate the cleanliness and responsive management at North District Lofts, particularly praising the maintenance staff. The small building atmosphere and available parking are also highlights. However, some feel the rent is too high compared to nearby suburbs and express frustration over parking challenges. A few have had negative experiences related to rental eligibility based on their profession.

Nestled in Bay Shore, Greenview Mill House offers affordable housing with an inviting atmosphere perfect for creating a home. Designed for those with a minimum household income of $69,516 and a maximum gross income of $82,000, this pet-friendly community ensures comfort and accessibility. Enjoy living in a vibrant neighborhood while making the most of your budget!

This pet-friendly 2-bed, 1-bath apartment offers 1,025 sqft of comfortable living in the vibrant Bayshore area. Featuring vaulted ceilings, sleek vinyl tiled floors, and a contemporary kitchen with stainless steel appliances and Quartz counters, it’s perfect for modern life. Generous closet space, a stylish bathroom, and on-site laundry elevate convenience. Enjoy your home on the first level with easy parking access. Special incentives available this May!