Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Located in Bay Shore, Mid Island Apartments offers remodeled homes with stainless-steel appliances and hardwood floors. This pet-friendly community features expansive green courtyards and is close to outdoor adventures, dining, and schools. Perfect for those seeking charm and convenience in a traditional setting.

Residents appreciate Mid Island Apartments for its attentive maintenance team, especially the superintendent Rob, who is praised for his reliability and helpfulness. The community is well-maintained, with efficient service from staff like Analia and Dennis. Opinions are mostly positive, highlighting the smooth living experience and convenient location, though individual preferences may vary.

Residents of Greymore Flats enjoy luxurious one and two-bedroom apartments in Bay Shore, complete with in-unit laundry and modern appliances. Convenient open parking and utilities like water, trash, and sewer included streamline living.

Residents of North District Lofts enjoy affordable housing with a prime focus on community living. Featuring attractive units on multiple floors with patios, this property provides essential amenities while ensuring a vibrant neighborhood atmosphere. With an income requirement ranging from $78,057 to $129,262, it offers an excellent opportunity for those seeking a home that balances affordability and accessibility.

Residents appreciate the cleanliness and responsive management at North District Lofts, particularly praising the maintenance staff. The small building atmosphere and available parking are also highlights. However, some feel the rent is too high compared to nearby suburbs and express frustration over parking challenges. A few have had negative experiences related to rental eligibility based on their profession.

Greenview Square offers affordable apartments designed for comfort and convenience. Each unit includes in-unit laundry with a washer and dryer, along with modern appliances like a dishwasher and refrigerator. Open parking makes access easy, providing a stress-free living experience. With an annual income requirement between $83,385 and $105,500, this community is perfect for those seeking budget-friendly options without compromising on essentials.

Experience luxury living in this stunning studio apartment featuring 771 sq. ft. of well-designed space. Part of the new "Chelsea Commons," enjoy amenities like in-unit laundry, elevator access, and assigned parking. Located minutes from shops, restaurants, beaches, and the Fire Island Ferry, this vibrant community offers convenience and a modern lifestyle. The landlord covers water, sewer, garbage, and snow removal, making for hassle-free living. Don’t miss this opportunity!

Enjoy luxury living in this stylish 1-bed, 1-bath apartment at "Chelsea Commons." Spanning 771 sq ft, this vibrant unit features in-unit laundry and P-Tac heating/cooling. With an elevator and assigned parking, both convenience and comfort are prioritized. Located just minutes from shops, restaurants, and beaches, this development offers an ideal urban lifestyle. Plus, a special 18-month lease deal is available for early signers!

This 3-bedroom, 1-bath ground floor apartment offers a modern living experience with recent renovations and new appliances. Spanning 1,100 sq ft, it features a clean interior, designated parking, and convenience just minutes from shopping and the LIRR. Ideal for those seeking a well-maintained home in a quiet area, this inviting space accommodates a maximum of four people, perfect for families or small groups. Enjoy easy living in a peaceful setting!

This newly renovated 3-bedroom, 1-bath apartment features hardwood and tile flooring throughout. With 884 sq ft of comfortable living space, convenience is key—utilities are included, making budgeting hassle-free. Located near the railroad and local amenities, this home is perfect for easy commuting and vibrant living in Bay Shore. Available for rent starting June 1, 2026.

Experience comfort and style in this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 1-bath second-floor apartment. With modern finishes throughout and a welcoming layout, this 1,200 sq. ft. Colonial is perfect for everyday living. Enjoy off-street parking and convenient in-unit laundry access. Don't miss this stylish, move-in-ready home in a pet-friendly environment!

This vibrant 3-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers a roomy 1,700 sq. ft. layout, complemented by a large finished attic ideal for a home office or playroom. Featuring washer/dryer hookups and a pet-friendly policy, this residence ensures comfort and convenience in a welcoming neighborhood. Enjoy ample living space and modern amenities while creating lasting memories in your new home!

Enjoy this fully renovated ground floor 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment featuring brand new stainless steel appliances and stylish finishes. With 625 sq. ft. of living space, this home boasts a comfortable setup including laundry hook-ups and hardwood floors. Tenants benefit from all utilities included except electric and cable, along with assigned parking for added convenience. Embrace a cozy and modern lifestyle in this vibrant Bay Shore community.

This charming pet-friendly 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment features 625 sq. ft. of well-designed space, including hardwood floors and modern appliances like a refrigerator, range, and microwave. Enjoy the comfort of central heating and the convenience of assigned parking. Perfectly positioned for easy living, making it an ideal retreat!

This fully updated colonial home features high-end finishes and a brand-new kitchen with quartz countertops and stainless steel appliances. Boasting 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full baths, this property ensures comfort and style. The lovely wrap-around porch is perfect for summer gatherings. Conveniently located near the train station for an easy commute, this charming residence combines modern living with outdoor enjoyment.

This serene second-floor apartment offers 544 sq. ft. of inviting living space, featuring a built-in queen-size bed and comfortable furnishings throughout. Enjoy a private deck overlooking a spacious backyard, along with modern conveniences like an in-unit washer and dryer. Ideal for those seeking a peaceful retreat close to Bay Shore's vibrant amenities, including restaurants and public transport. A perfect mix of comfort and accessibility awaits!

This charming 1-bedroom apartment offers 800 sq ft of comfortable living space. Located on the 2nd floor, it features central air, in-unit laundry, and a brick exterior for added appeal. Residents enjoy full responsibility for electric, cable, and internet, providing flexibility to customize services. Perfect for those seeking modern living in a welcoming community.

This expansive 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom ranch-style home offers an open-concept layout perfect for entertaining. Situated on a large double lot in a private community, it boasts air conditioning and an oversized deck. A pool is coming in time for the 2026 summer season! Enjoy access to private beachfronts and a clubhouse with amenities like a gym and tennis courts for an active lifestyle. Experience serene living near the ocean while relishing stunning sunsets over the Great South Bay.

This charming 1-bedroom, 1-bath home features a spacious living room with slider access to a private back patio. The open layout includes a dining area and a well-equipped kitchen. Enjoy in-unit laundry convenience and central air for comfort. With 900 square feet, this inviting space is ideal for those looking to settle in a cozy environment. Tenant responsibilities include electric, cable, and internet, offering a simple living experience.

This beautifully renovated 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment boasts oversized rooms and modern finishes in a thoughtful layout. With 1,500 sq ft of comfortable living space, it's ideally located near the Bay Shore train station and local amenities. Enjoy features like high ceilings and a move-in ready vibe, plus included sewer, water, landscaping, and snow removal. Perfect for those seeking style, convenience, and a welcoming community atmosphere.

Experience upscale living in this stylish 1-bedroom apartment at Chelsea Commons, featuring 738 sq. ft. of modern comfort. Enjoy in-unit laundry, elevator access, and proximity to shops, restaurants, and beaches. This pet-friendly unit includes assigned parking and essential amenities. Ideal for those seeking convenience and easy access to the Fire Island Ferry, all set in vibrant downtown Bayshore.

Experience island luxury in this stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bath home with panoramic views of Fire Island. Featuring an open-concept layout, the spacious living, dining, and kitchen areas seamlessly connect to a large wrap-around deck. Enjoy outdoor adventures with provided bicycles, beach chairs, and even a paddleboard, making it the ultimate spot for relaxation and fun. Perfectly located for easy ferry access, this home is an ideal destination for your seaside getaway.

This beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offers an open-concept living space ideal for relaxation and entertainment. Featuring a brand-new kitchen and large deck with breathtaking ocean and bay views, this rental is perfect for a luxurious weekly getaway. Enjoy modern amenities like in-unit laundry and central air, all within the sought-after Fire Island vacation destination. Perfect for those seeking a vibrant coastal experience!

Experience unparalleled beach living in this brand-new, custom-designed retreat, ideal for hosting up to 16 guests across 8 bedrooms and 4 baths. Enjoy breathtaking views of the Great South Bay and iconic landmarks from expansive living areas and sunlit decks. With room for unforgettable gatherings and modern touches throughout, this Fire Island property is the ultimate escape, just steps from the ferry and beach.

Experience tranquility in this charming cottage, perfect for a weekly rental at $5,000. With magnificent sunset views, this home is an ideal getaway for watersports and fishing enthusiasts. Features include separate entrances and amenities like beach chairs and umbrellas, making it a perfect escape for relaxation and adventure. Enjoy the natural beauty and serenity of this idyllic environment.