Zumper
modified
13 Hours Ago

Highlights

  • Dishwasher
  • Quiet neighborhood
  • Finished basement
  • Laundry
  • Storage
  • Living area

Location

1126 Mccarley Dr W, Columbus, OH 43228, USA|Holly Hill
Hi! Let’s figure out if this property is right for you.

Powered by Zumper AI

Tour 1126 McCarley

Contact

Management

NCJC Housing & Development Foundation

Leasing office

(844) 294-7576 ext. 9156

Property Overview

1126 McCarley features a strong Zumper Expert Rating of 8.2 out of 10, emphasizing its appeal to renters. The property excels in amenities and location, earning ratings of 9 each, alongside a competitive price rating of 8, reflecting its value. Notable features include a finished basement, dishwasher, and proximity to top-rated schools, complemented by a trustworthy management description and ample photos that enhance transparency and understanding for potential renters.

This summary uses Zumper’s proprietary data. “Zumper Expert Ratings” and “Things you’ll love” are based on our internal analyses of market trends and renter insights.

Zumper Expert Rating

8.2
Very Good
With a solid 8.2 out of 10 overall, 1126 McCarley is a great option for renters. While some aspects, like Trustworthiness, might not be as distinguished as other properties nearby, 1126 McCarley has a number of attractive features—namely its Amenities— so you can be assured your rent will come with a high standard of living.

Things you’ll love

  • High school nearby
  • Middle school nearby
  • Less expensive

Floor plans

1126 McCarley - 11262 bed1 bath950 sqft$1,200 /mo1 unit availableWalk through available 8/6/25 between 12pm-2pm open house style This apartment unit includes hardwood bedrooms. The open-concept living area flows from the living room to a dining and kitchen combo equipped with a dishwasher, and Formica countertops. The Finished Basement includes plenty of room for storage, laundry, and living space. The building is located minutes from Franklin Heights High School, Wedgewood Middle School, West Franklin and Georgian Heights Elementary School. This unit is tucked away in a quiet neighborhood that is positioned squarely between 270 and 62 providing great commuting access.

Let's explore this property.

Policies and fees

Contact for more information on pet policy.

Required one-time fees

Security Deposit$0
Building details

Property details

Units1
Advertisement

About 1126 McCarley

HomeApartments in ColumbusHolly Hill 1126 McCarley

Walk through available 8/6/25 between 12pm-2pm open house style This apartment unit includes hardwood bedrooms. The open-concept living area flows from the living room to a dining and kitchen combo equipped with a dishwasher, and Formica countertops. The Finished Basement includes plenty of room for storage, laundry, and living space. The building is located minutes from Franklin Heights High School, Wedgewood Middle School, West Franklin and Georgian Heights Elementary School. This unit is tucked away in a quiet neighborhood that is positioned squarely between 270 and 62 providing great commuting access.


Zumper Expert Rating

Our expert rating is based on a weighted average score of property attributes that renters care about most: price, amenities, location, quality, and trust.
8.2
/10
Very Good
With a solid 8.2 out of 10 overall, 1126 McCarley is a great option for renters. While some aspects, like Trustworthiness, might not be as distinguished as other properties nearby, 1126 McCarley has a number of attractive features—namely its Amenities— so you can be assured your rent will come with a high standard of living.
How we rated 1126 McCarley
Price·8A score that weighs the cost and location of the property, which we calculate by comparing rent prices of recent units to the median price of nearby rentals, adjusting for overall quality and features.
Scoring a 8/10, 1126 McCarley is a great option for renters looking for apartments in Holly Hill. The rent is significantly lower than the median rent for the area, therefore this property is competitively priced for its location and its features. Residents here will find a home that meets their needs with few trade-offs.
Amenities·9A score based on the amenities offered at this property compared to other rentals in the area. We consider the quantity, quality, and popularity of features both on site and within the units.
1126 McCarley goes above and beyond to provide sought-after conveniences and desirable perks, including building or unit level amenities. Renters looking for popular or luxurious features will find them here—and for that reason, 1126 McCarley receives one of the highest amenities scores.
Location·9A score based on proximity and ease of access to shops, restaurants, schools, and public transportation while considering the desirability of the area.
1126 McCarley is exceptional when it comes to location and conveniences. Communication with management or leasing staff is usually quick and easy and they often use advanced scheduling and communication tools to streamline the process. The location of this property offers easy access to popular points of interest in the area and options for getting around.
Quality·7A score based on what makes the property stand out, such as luxury features, unique offerings, age of the building, and our ability to verify the accuracy of these details.
While it may not have as many distinctive features as similar properties in the surrounding area, renters can trust 1126 McCarley to provide reasonable accomodations and accurate details about its community.
Trustworthiness·7A score based on the accuracy, completeness, recency, and usefulness of the information provided by this property, so you can trust that what you see is what you get.
1126 McCarley provides some information about the features available in the community and its apartments, making it a reliable option for prospective renters. Renters should ask additional questions about amenities and non-negotiable items they are looking for.

Property highlights

We compared every listing in the surrounding area to determine which amenities are most common. If a building lacks an amenity that most others in the area have, it is a con. If a building has an amenity most others in the area do not, it is a pro. Similarly, price, schools, and size are calculated relative to the size, price, and distance to schools of the other properties nearby.

How 1126 McCarley compares to other nearby properties.

Positives

High school nearby
There is a high school 0.4 mile away
Middle school nearby
There is a middle school 0.4 mile away
Less expensive
The 2-bedrooms are cheaper than other similar listings nearby
Elementary school nearby
There is an elementary school 0.3 mile away
Images Available
There are at least 10 photos of this address
Laundry available on site
Washers and dryers are available in-building or in-unit

Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere

Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.
Email*
By clicking submit, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values.

Rent trends in Holly Hill

2-bedroom apartments at 1126 McCarley cost about 20% more than the average rent price for 2-bedroom apartments in Holly Hill.

Median rents as of Sep 6 2025.
Holly Hill
Columbus
A table of 1-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Columbus
MonthMedian Rent
September 2023$1,211
October 2023$1,193
November 2023$1,180
December 2023$1,072
January 2024$1,074
February 2024$1,129
March 2024$1,208
April 2024$1,236
May 2024$1,250
June 2024$1,245
July 2024$1,273
August 2024$1,249
September 2024$1,230
October 2024$1,212
November 2024$1,200
December 2024$1,192
January 2025$1,197
February 2025$1,210
March 2025$1,200
April 2025$1,168
May 2025$1,173
June 2025$1,191
July 2025$1,211
August 2025$1,224
September 2025$1,225
A table of 1-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Holly Hill
MonthMedian Rent
November 2023$750
December 2023$750
January 2024$750

Affordability calculator

Can I afford to live at 1126 Mccarley Dr W?

Bedrooms

2 bedrooms

Rent-to-income ratio

30%

Slide to adjust the percentage of your monthly income you are willing to spend on rent.
The general rule of thumb is to spend around 30% or less of your income on rent.
Recommended income

$48,000/yr

With your selected rent-to-income ratio, you'd ideally want to make $48,000 annually to afford this 2-bedrooms monthly rent price of $1,200.
For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator.

Schools near 1126 McCarley

West Franklin Elementary School

3501 briggs rd

columbus, OH, 43204

K-4Public
C+

The Bostic Head Start Center

2975 kingston ave

grove city, OH, 43123

PKPublic

South-Western Preschool Center

4324 haughn rd

grove city, OH, 43123

PKPublic
Powered byniche.com
Advertisement

Internet available near 1126 McCarley

Neighborhood

Holly Hill | Columbus, OH

NEIGHBORHOOD VIBE
Peaceful and quiet
Noise-canceling headphones not required in this mostly noise free area.

Getting around Columbus near 1126 Mccarley Dr W

Walking

4/10
Some shops and stores are within a few minutes.

Driving

9/10
Commuting is easy with multiple accessible routes and plenty of parking.

Cycling

3/10
This is semi-bikeable, but you’ll need another way of getting around.

Transit

3/10
There are a few mass transit options within the area.

Points of interest for 1126 Mccarley Dr W, Columbus

Groceries

4/10
At least one grocery store within a 30-minute walk

Shopping

4/10
Some shops within walking distance

Cafes

2/10
Few or no cafés within walking distance

Restaurants

4/10
Some restaurants within walking distance

Primary schools

8/10
At least one elementary school within a 10-minute walk

High schools

7/10
At least one high school within a 20-minute walk

Parks

8/10
Large amount of park space nearby

Nightlife

2/10
Few or no bars within walking distance

Compare similar properties nearby

featured image of 1655 Gilmore Park Avenue

Addison Woods

Our team has verified this company

Scioto Woods • 1655 Gilmore Park Avenue

2 Beds

$1,295

dogs ok
No
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 4314 Dresden St

The Trails at Arbor Court

Our team has verified this company

Maize-Morse • 4314 Dresden St

1–3 Beds

$999–$1,496

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
No
balcony
Yes
featured image of 3058 Allegheny Ave

Townhomes at Bexley Creek

Our team has verified this company

Broadleigh • 3058 Allegheny Ave

1–2 Beds

$1,099–$1,149

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
No
balcony
No
featured image of 250 Liberty St

Liberty Place Apartments

Our team has verified this company

Brewery District • 250 Liberty St

1 Bed

$1,225–$1,520

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
No
featured image of 2201 Collier Crst

Collier Park Apartments

Our team has verified this company

Stonebridge • 2201 Collier Crst

1–2 Beds

$1,249–$2,380

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 4500 4455 Condor Dr

Tempo

Our team has verified this company

4500 4455 Condor Dr

1 Bed

$1,397–$1,769

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 1820 Holt Rd

Avalon Oaks Apartments

Our team has verified this company

Holt-Alkire • 1820 Holt Rd

1–2 Beds

$1,063–$2,802

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 2898 Parlin Dr

Regency Arms

Our team has verified this company

2898 Parlin Dr

1–2 Beds

$1,030–$2,000

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
No
featured image of 1655 Gilmore Park Avenue

Addison Woods

Our team has verified this company

Scioto Woods • 1655 Gilmore Park Avenue

2 Beds

$1,295

dogs ok
No
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 4314 Dresden St

The Trails at Arbor Court

Our team has verified this company

Maize-Morse • 4314 Dresden St

1–3 Beds

$999–$1,496

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
No
balcony
Yes
featured image of 3058 Allegheny Ave

Townhomes at Bexley Creek

Our team has verified this company

Broadleigh • 3058 Allegheny Ave

1–2 Beds

$1,099–$1,149

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
No
balcony
No
featured image of 250 Liberty St

Liberty Place Apartments

Our team has verified this company

Brewery District • 250 Liberty St

1 Bed

$1,225–$1,520

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
No
featured image of 2201 Collier Crst

Collier Park Apartments

Our team has verified this company

Stonebridge • 2201 Collier Crst

1–2 Beds

$1,249–$2,380

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 4500 4455 Condor Dr

Tempo

Our team has verified this company

4500 4455 Condor Dr

1 Bed

$1,397–$1,769

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 1820 Holt Rd

Avalon Oaks Apartments

Our team has verified this company

Holt-Alkire • 1820 Holt Rd

1–2 Beds

$1,063–$2,802

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
Yes
featured image of 2898 Parlin Dr

Regency Arms

Our team has verified this company

2898 Parlin Dr

1–2 Beds

$1,030–$2,000

dogs ok
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
balcony
No

Check availability

Full name*
Move-in date
Floor plan
By sending this inquiry, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values. By providing my phone number, I consent (not a condition of purchase) to be called and texted by 1126 McCarley.