Updated 20 Minutes Ago
Location
91 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA|Bay Shore
Tour 91 S Penataquit Ave
Contact
Eric G. Ramsay Jr. Associate LLC
Nearby rentals
Property management
Apartments for rent New YorkApartments for rent Financial DistrictApartments for rent Upper West SideApartments for rent ChelseaApartments for rent Hell's KitchenApartments for rent Upper East SideApartments for rent East VillageApartments for rent Midtown EastApartments for rent Battery Park CityApartments for rent Murray HillApartments for rent Downtown BrooklynApartments for rent West VillageApartments for rent WilliamsburgApartments for rent Long Island CityApartments for rent GreenpointApartments Near Me
Houses for rent New YorkHouses for rent Long BranchHouses for rent StamfordHouses for rent North BergenHouses for rent HobokenHouses for rent Long BeachHouses for rent Asbury ParkHouses for rent BridgeportHouses for rent Westhampton BeachHouses for rent HackensackHouses for rent West New YorkHouses for rent Fort LeeHouses for rent New HavenHouses for rent EdgewaterHouses for rent BogotaHouses for rent near me
Property Overview
This summary uses Zumper’s proprietary data. “Things you’ll love” and “Great for” are based on our internal analyses of market trends and renter insights.
Things you’ll love
More space- Dishwasher
- Images available
Great for
Pet owners
Amenities for 91 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore
Features
| Ceiling Fan | Central Air |
| Furnished | Hardwood Floor |
| Natural Gas |
Appliances
| Dishwasher | In-Unit Laundry |
Community
| Exterior Type: Frame |
Grounds
| Outdoor Space | Swimming Pool |
Other
| Architecture Style: Ranch | Seven Rooms |
Units, floor plans, amenities, dimensions, details, availability, and prices may be approximate and subject to change. Please contact a community representative for more information.
Policies and fees
Applicants
Applicants
One-time.
Contact Property
REQUIRED FEES
Security Deposit
One-time. Refundable.
Contact Property
Advertisement
About 91 S Penataquit Ave
Property Status: Active Vacation year round. Professional designed. Built in 2025!! One of a kind property 300' off the road . A fenced acre w/ pool and an organic vegetable garden. furnished or unfurnished. Surrounded by Forest yet half a mile from South Shore University Hospital/southside and downtown Bayshore. Excellent school district. It's three bedrooms and the office doubles as a guest bedroom. Background check, proof of income references, etc., furnished with extremely expensive furniture mostly from restoration hardware. The property is completely fenced with a dog door. Pets are more than welcome. very long driveway with plenty of parking . Dock space for rent three houses away. Utilities not included. Office Phone: (631) 336-9563 Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Property highlights
We compared every listing in the surrounding area to determine which amenities are most common. If a building lacks an amenity that most others in the area have, it is a con. If a building has an amenity most others in the area do not, it is a pro. Similarly, price, schools, and size are calculated relative to the size, price, and distance to schools of the other properties nearby.How 91 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA compares to other nearby properties.
Positives
- More space
- The 4-bedroom is 938 sqft larger than other listings nearby
- Dishwasher
- Kitchens at this address include dishwashers
- Images available
- There are at least 10 photos of this address
- Pet friendly
- Rentals at this address allow pets
Address details
| Neighborhood | Bay Shore |
|---|---|
| Zip code | 11706 |
| Type | House for rent |
Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere
Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.
Rent trends in Bay Shore
4-bedroom apartments at 91 S Penataquit Ave cost about 35% more than the average rent price for 4-bedroom apartments in Bay Shore.
Median rents as of May 9 2026.
Bay Shore
Bay Shore
| Month | Median Rent |
|---|---|
| August 2025 | $5,000 |
| September 2025 | $5,000 |
| October 2025 | $4,800 |
| November 2025 | $4,300 |
| December 2025 | $4,200 |
| January 2026 | $4,321 |
| February 2026 | $4,650 |
| March 2026 | $4,387 |
| April 2026 | $4,462 |
| May 2026 | $5,000 |
| Month | Median Rent |
|---|---|
| August 2025 | $5,000 |
| September 2025 | $5,000 |
| October 2025 | $4,800 |
| November 2025 | $4,300 |
| January 2026 | $4,370 |
| February 2026 | $4,650 |
| March 2026 | $4,387 |
| April 2026 | $4,283 |
Affordability calculator
Can I afford to live at 91 S Penataquit Ave?
Bedrooms
4+ bedroomsRent-to-income ratio
30%
Slide to adjust the percentage of your monthly income you are willing to spend on rent.
The general rule of thumb is to spend around 30% or less of your income on rent.
Recommended income
$230,000/yr
With your selected rent-to-income ratio, you'd ideally want to make $230,000 annually to afford this 4-bedrooms monthly rent price of $5,750.
For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator.
Rent history
The increase or decrease in monthly rent compared to the previous listing price.| Bath | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 months ago | $6,800 | 4 bed | 2.5 bath | ||
| 5 years ago | $3,985 | Studio | 0 bath | ||
| 7 years ago | $1,100 | Studio | 1 bath |
Schools near 91 S Penataquit Ave
Fire Island School (Woodhull School)
750 surf road
corneille estates, NY, 11770
PK, K-6Public
Brook Avenue Elementary School
45 brook ave
bay shore, NY, 11706
K-2Public
A
South Country School
885 hampshire rd
bay shore, NY, 11706
3-5Public
B
Western Suffolk BOCES
507 deer park rd
dix hills, NY, 11746
K-12Public
Eastern Suffolk BOCES
201 sunrise hwy
patchogue, NY, 11772
K-12Public
Advertisement
Internet available near 91 S Penataquit Ave
Neighborhood
Bay Shore | Bay Shore, NY
Getting around Bay Shore near 91 S Penataquit Ave
Walking
5/10
Some shops and stores are within a few minutes.
Driving
8/10
This area is close to freeways and has adequate parking options.
Cycling
4/10
This is semi-bikeable, but you’ll need another way of getting around.
Transit
2/10
FYI, there are little to no public transit options within walking distance.
Points of interest for 91 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore
Groceries
6/10
Wide variety of groceries within a short drive, including some within walking distance
Shopping
5/10
Variety of shops within a short drive
Cafes
4/10
Variety of cafés within a short drive
Restaurants
7/10
Wide variety of restaurants within a short drive, including some within walking distance
Primary schools
2/10
At least one elementary school within a 30-minute walk
High schools
2/10
At least one high school within a 30-minute walk
Nightlife
6/10
Wide variety of bars within a short drive, including some within walking distance
Explore the area around 91 S Penataquit Ave
Frank & Marie Itialian Market
10 W Main St
Stop & Shop Supermarket
533 E Main St
ALDI
1851 Sunrise Hwy
ShopRite of Bay Shore
1905 Sunrise Hwy
Lins Food Court
1701 Sunrise Hwy
Donna's Nimble Thimble Inc
17 Burnett Ave
Bridal Suite of Bay Shore
7 W Main St
Alpha 1 Active Apparel LLC
31 1st Ave
Pixie Dust
125 W Main St
RSVP Formal Wear
131 W Main St
Starbucks
430 E Main St
Bayshore Bean
47 E Main St
Dunkin'
529 E Main St
Toast Coffeehouse
9 S Park Ave
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
567 E Main St
Qdoba Mexican Eats
331 E Main St
Napper Tandy's Bay Shore
60 E Main St
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
11 Maple Ave
Tap Room
44 E Main St
Coastal Kitchen
12 E Main St
Great South Bay Seafood Co LLC
122 Ocean Ave
Deans Seafood
19 Degnon Blvd
The Vitamin Shoppe
1701 Sunrise Hwy
Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery
547 Main St
Islip Meat Market
551 Main St
Homan Avenue Dock
Watchogue Creek Park
Bay Shore Marina Park
Garden
Benjamin's Memorial Beach
Nicky's Clam Bar
99 Maple Ave
Restaurant
135 Maple Ave
The Lakehouse
135 Maple Ave
Chowder Bar
123 Maple Ave
Whalers
124 Maple Ave
Montauk Hwy/S Penataquit Ave
Amityville Long Island Railroad Station to Patchogue Long Island Railroad Station (via Montauk Highway)
Montauk Hwy/Penataquit Ave
Amityville Long Island Railroad Station to Patchogue Long Island Railroad Station (via Montauk Highway)
Montauk Hwy/Montgomery Ave
Amityville Long Island Railroad Station to Patchogue Long Island Railroad Station (via Montauk Highway), Bay Shore to Hauppauge
Montauk Hwy/Mowbray Pl
Amityville Long Island Railroad Station to Patchogue Long Island Railroad Station (via Montauk Highway), Bay Shore to Hauppauge
Montauk Hwy/Brentwood Rd
Amityville Long Island Railroad Station to Patchogue Long Island Railroad Station (via Montauk Highway)
Bay Shore
Montauk Branch, Montauk Branch
Bay Shore
Montauk Branch
Islip
Montauk Branch
Islip
Montauk Branch, Montauk Branch
Great River
Montauk Branch, Montauk Branch
Other units at this address
91 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY
91 S Penataquit Ave Bay Shore, NY
Occupied
NA
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
$6,800
Furnished • Outdoor Space • Balcony • Assigned Parking • Deck • In-Unit Laundry
Compare similar properties nearby
Avalon Huntington Station
Our team has verified this companyHuntington Station • 1700 E 5th St
3 Beds
$4,332–$4,352
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
100 Court North Drive
Our team has verified this companyMelville • 100 Court North Dr #1247A
3 Beds
$5,690
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
313 Avalon Cir #3611A, Nesconset, NY, 11787
Our team has verified this companyNesconset • 313 Avalon Cir #3611A
3 Beds
$5,330
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
Avalon Huntington Station
Our team has verified this companyHuntington Station • 1700 E 5th St
3 Beds
$4,332–$4,352
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
100 Court North Drive
Our team has verified this companyMelville • 100 Court North Dr #1247A
3 Beds
$5,690
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
313 Avalon Cir #3611A, Nesconset, NY, 11787
Our team has verified this companyNesconset • 313 Avalon Cir #3611A
3 Beds
$5,330
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
- in-unit laundry
- dogs and cats ok
- dishwasher
Check availability
Advertisement