Zumper

Alert me when this rental is available.

modified
Updated 5+ Days Ago

Highlights

  • Pet Friendly
  • Huge walk-in closet
  • Large parking lot
  • Brand new stainless steel appliances
  • All new flooring
  • All new ceiling fans

Location

72 5th Ave #2f, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA|Bay Shore

Property Overview

Fresh updates and practical convenience stand out here, with a huge walk-in closet, large parking lot, brand new stainless steel appliances, new flooring, and new ceiling fans. Nearby pet services add extra appeal, while the value per square foot is above many local properties and a nearby top-rated high school plus 13 listing photos add to the overall draw.

This summary uses Zumper’s proprietary data. “Things you’ll love” and “Great for” are based on our internal analyses of market trends and renter insights.

Things you’ll love

  • High school nearby
  • Dishwasher
  • Images Available

Great for

  • Pet owners

Available rentals nearby

featured image of 35 Penataquit Ave

Bay Shore • 35 Penataquit Ave

2 Beds

$2,690–$3,180

featured image of 1721 N Gardiner Dr

North Bay Shore • 1721 N Gardiner Dr

2 Beds

$2,500–$2,950

featured image of 587 Main St #2

Islip • 587 Main St #2

2 Beds

$3,050

featured image of 61 W Main St

Bay Shore • 61 W Main St

2 Beds

$2,950

featured image of 124 10th Ave

Brentwood • 124 10th Ave

2 Beds

$2,700

featured image of 1727 N Gardiner Dr

North Bay Shore • 1727 N Gardiner Dr

2 Beds

$2,695

featured image of 1735 North Gardiner Drive N Gardiner drive #25B

Bay Shore • 1735 North Gardiner Drive N Gardiner drive #25B

2 Beds

$2,950

featured image of 67 Prospect St

Babylon • 67 Prospect St

2 Beds

$2,600

featured image of 35 Penataquit Ave

Bay Shore • 35 Penataquit Ave

2 Beds

$2,690–$3,180

featured image of 1721 N Gardiner Dr

North Bay Shore • 1721 N Gardiner Dr

2 Beds

$2,500–$2,950

featured image of 587 Main St #2

Islip • 587 Main St #2

2 Beds

$3,050

featured image of 61 W Main St

Bay Shore • 61 W Main St

2 Beds

$2,950

featured image of 124 10th Ave

Brentwood • 124 10th Ave

2 Beds

$2,700

featured image of 1727 N Gardiner Dr

North Bay Shore • 1727 N Gardiner Dr

2 Beds

$2,695

featured image of 1735 North Gardiner Drive N Gardiner drive #25B

Bay Shore • 1735 North Gardiner Drive N Gardiner drive #25B

2 Beds

$2,950

featured image of 67 Prospect St

Babylon • 67 Prospect St

2 Beds

$2,600

Rent trends in Bay Shore

2-bedroom apartments at 72 5th Ave ##2f cost about 7% less than the average rent price for 2-bedroom apartments in Bay Shore.

Median rents as of Sep 12 2026.
Bay Shore
Bay Shore
A table of 2-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Bay Shore
MonthMedian Rent
September 2024$3,225
October 2024$3,090
November 2024$3,075
December 2024$3,050
January 2025$3,028
February 2025$3,034
March 2025$3,061
April 2025$3,053
May 2025$3,130
June 2025$3,184
July 2025$3,094
August 2025$2,930
September 2025$2,847
October 2025$2,826
November 2025$2,844
December 2025$3,112
January 2026$3,158
February 2026$3,155
March 2026$2,979
April 2026$2,760
May 2026$2,927
June 2026$3,095
July 2026$3,132
August 2026$3,106
September 2026$3,025
A table of 2-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Bay Shore
MonthMedian Rent
September 2024$3,225
October 2024$3,090
November 2024$3,075
December 2024$3,050
January 2025$3,028
February 2025$3,034
March 2025$3,061
April 2025$3,053
May 2025$3,130
June 2025$3,184
July 2025$3,094
August 2025$2,930
September 2025$2,847
October 2025$2,826
November 2025$2,844
December 2025$3,112
January 2026$3,158
February 2026$3,155
March 2026$2,979
April 2026$2,760
May 2026$2,927
June 2026$3,095
July 2026$3,132
August 2026$3,106
September 2026$3,025

Rent history

The increase or decrease in monthly rent compared to the previous listing price.
Check out the past listing prices for monthly rent at 72 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY.
1 year ago$3,200

Schools near 72 5th Ave ##2f

Fifth Avenue School

217 5th ave

bay shore, NY, 11706

K-2Public
A-

Fire Island School (Woodhull School)

750 surf road

corneille estates, NY, 11770

PK, K-6Public

South Country School

885 hampshire rd

bay shore, NY, 11706

3-5Public
B

Western Suffolk BOCES

507 deer park rd

dix hills, NY, 11746

K-12Public

P.S. 256Q

525 convent rd

syosset, NY, 11791

PK, K-12Public
Powered byniche.com
Advertisement

Internet available near 72 5th Ave ##2f

Getting around Bay Shore near 72 5th Ave #2f

Walking

6/10
Grab your reusable bags–many shops and stores are within walking distance.

Driving

6/10
This area is close to freeways and has adequate parking options.

Cycling

5/10
More spots are within biking distance and some roads are cyclist-friendly.

Transit

6/10
Popular public transit options are just a short walk from this location.

Points of interest for 72 5th Ave #2f, Bay Shore

Groceries

7/10
At least one grocery store within a 15-minute walk

Shopping

6/10
Variety of shops within walking distance

Cafes

5/10
Some cafés within walking distance

Restaurants

6/10
Some restaurants within walking distance

Primary schools

9/10
At least one elementary school within a 10-minute walk

High schools

5/10
At least one high school within a 30-minute walk

Nightlife

3/10
Few or no bars within walking distance

Notify me

We’ll let you know when this property is available and send you similar listings.

Full name*
Move-in date*
By sending this inquiry, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values. By providing my phone number, I consent (not a condition of purchase) to be called and texted by 72 5th Ave #2f, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA.

166 Higbie Ln, West Islip, NY 11795, USA
Advertisement