Zumper

2201 E New York St
2201 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46201, USA

Apartment for rent
Pet friendly
Monthly rent
$699–$1,379
Beds1–4
Baths1–2
Sqft750–900
modified
Updated 1 Hour Ago

Property Overview

This summary uses Zumper’s proprietary data. “Things you’ll love” and “Great for” are based on our internal analyses of market trends and renter insights.

Things you’ll love

  • Less expensive
  • Elementary school nearby
  • Middle school nearby

Great for

  • Pet owners

Highlights

  • Pet Friendly

Units

2201 E New York St Indianapolis, IN

New Listing

2201B

1 Bed

1 Bath

$699

Listed on 09/03/2026
Listed by PMI Midwest
Days on market: 12
"Accepting Section 8" Welcome to Unit 2201-B at 2201 E New York St—a bright, comfortable 2-bedroom, 1-bath home with 750 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space. The open layout, large windows, and natural light create a warm, inviting vibe that feels like home from day one. Located in a lively Indianapolis neighborhood, you'll have easy access to shopping, dining, and everyday essentials while enjoying the comfort of your own space. Whether you're moving into your first place or looking for a fresh start, this home offers the perfect balance of convenience, comfort, and style. At PMI Midwest, we strive to provide an experience that is cost-effective and convenient. That’s why we provide a Resident Benefits Package (RBP) to address common headaches for our residents and provide must-have services for our renters. The Total Monthly Price includes rent, pest control, air filter delivery, utility setup assistance, credit building and more at a rate of $41.45/month, required with the rental. Residents have the option to personalize some components during onboarding, which may increase or decrease the monthly amount. More details upon application. This home comes with high speed internet up to 1 Gig at an exclusive group rate of $65.00, and includes 24/7 premium support and setup to help get you connected at move-in. Deposit varies based on screening results. Non-Smoking Home. PMI Midwest 317.546.3482

New Listing

B

2 Beds

1 Bath

$699

Listed on 09/03/2026
Listed by PMI Midwest
Days on market: 13
"Accepting Section 8" Welcome to Unit 2201-b at 2201 E New York St—a bright, comfortable 2-bedroom, 1-bath home with 750 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space. The open layout, large windows, and natural light create a warm, inviting vibe that feels like home from day one. Located in a lively Indianapolis neighborhood, you'll have easy access to shopping, dining, and everyday essentials while enjoying the comfort of your own space. Whether you're moving into your first place or looking for a fresh start, this home offers the perfect balance of convenience, comfort, and style. At Pmi Midwest, we strive to provide an experience that is cost-effective and convenient. That’s why we provide a Resident Benefits Package (rbp) to address common headaches for our residents and provide must-have services for our renters. The Total Monthly Price includes rent, pest control, air filter delivery, utility setup assistance, credit building and more at a rate of $41.45/month, required with the rental. Residents have the option to personalize some components during onboarding, which may increase or decrease the monthly amount. More details upon application. This home comes with high speed internet up to 1 Gig at an exclusive group rate of $65.00, and includes 24/7 premium support and setup to help get you connected at move-in. Deposit varies based on screening results. Non-Smoking Home. PMI Midwest 317.546.3482 By submitting your information on this page you consent to being contacted by the Property Manager and RentEngine via SMS, phone, or email.

Available

D

3 Beds

1 Bath

$999

Listed on 08/07/2026
Listed by PMI Midwest
Days on market: 40
"Accepting Section 8" Move into a space that just feels right. Located at 2201 E New York St, Unit D, Indianapolis, In, this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offers 900 sq ft of comfortable living with an open layout that makes everyday life easy. Whether you're hosting friends, cooking dinner, or winding down after work, this home is designed to fit your lifestyle. Plus, you're close to local dining, shopping, and everything Indianapolis has to offer. Your next home starts here. At Pmi Midwest, we strive to provide an experience that is cost-effective and convenient. That’s why we provide a Resident Benefits Package (rbp) to address common headaches for our residents and provide must-have services for our renters. The Total Monthly Price of $1141.45 includes rent, pest control, air filter delivery, utility setup assistance, credit building and more at a rate of $41.45/month, required with the rental. Residents have the option to personalize some components during onboarding, which may increase or decrease the monthly amount. More details upon application. This home comes with high speed internet up to 1 Gig at an exclusive group rate of $65.00, and includes 24/7 premium support and setup to help get you connected at move-in. Deposit varies based on screening results. Non-Smoking Home. PMI Midwest 317.546.3482 By submitting your information on this page you consent to being contacted by the Property Manager and RentEngine via SMS, phone, or email.

New Listing

A

4 Beds

2 Baths

$1,379

Listed on 09/03/2026
Listed by PMI Midwest
Days on market: 13
"Accepting Section 8" Welcome to Unit A at 2201 East New York Street in Indianapolis, In. This spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom rental offers 900 sq ft of comfortable, functional living space. Enjoy an open layout, plenty of natural light, stylish full bathrooms, and a setup that works for both relaxing and entertaining. Plus, you’re close to local dining, shopping, and attractions, so everything you need is within reach. Whether you’re a family or a professional looking for a convenient place to call home, this spot delivers the perfect mix of comfort, style, and city access. At Pmi Midwest, we strive to provide an experience that is cost-effective and convenient. That’s why we provide a Resident Benefits Package (rbp) to address common headaches for our residents and provide must-have services for our renters. The Total Monthly Price includes rent, pest control, air filter delivery, utility setup assistance, credit building and more at a rate of $41.45/month, required with the rental. Residents have the option to personalize some components during onboarding, which may increase or decrease the monthly amount. More details upon application. This home comes with high speed internet up to 1 Gig at an exclusive group rate of $65.00, and includes 24/7 premium support and setup to help get you connected at move-in. Deposit varies based on screening results. Non-Smoking Home. PMI Midwest 317.546.3482 By submitting your information on this page you consent to being contacted by the Property Manager and RentEngine via SMS, phone, or email.

Occupied Units

Occupied

1 Bed, 1 Bath

1 Bed

1 Bath

$625

Listed by Danny Clune
Days on market: 2188
Come tour this one bed, one bath home today! This unit has 1008 square feet of space, with amenities including a kitchen with a refrigerator and dishwasher, washer/dryer hookups, and is freshly painted. Minutes away from I-70. Take advantage of our self-showing tour with our Rently app. Click the Schedule a Tour or Check Availability button on this page and you’ll be able to see this home ASAP. BONUS: Have peace of mind in knowing this property is professionally managed by Great Jones Property Management. With a fully staffed 24/7 tenant support hotline, all of your requests will be addressed immediately and all maintenance repairs are performed by licensed and insured vendors. Rent can be paid in cash, online through our portal system, or by check. BE AWARE: Scams are operating in this region. Email **** to contact an official Great Jones representative about this property. Great Jones will never advertise on, ask you to wire money, or ask you to keep the key to the home for move in. This property comes in as-is condition. If this property is part of a homeowner’s association, additional fees may apply. This property allows self guided viewing without an appointment. Contact for details.