Compare rent prices in
Shelter Island, NY

Rent prices in Shelter Island vary by bedroom size, rental type, and neighborhood. The average rent for an apartment in Shelter Island is $7,397, whereas a house costs $35,000. 2-bedroom apartments in Shelter Island run $7,397 on average.

Bedrooms

Neighborhoods

Property types

Bedroom counts	Average rent	Last 30 days	Last year	Listings
1 bedroom	$8,500	-	-	View
2 bedroom	$30,000	-	-	View
3 bedroom	$19,750	56%	40%	View
4 bedroom	$39,500	2%	7%	View

BedroomsNeighborhoodsProperty types

1 bedroom

Average rent

$8,500

View

2 bedroom

Average rent

$30,000

View

3 bedroom

Average rent

$19,750

Last 30 days

56%

Last year

40%

View

4 bedroom

Average rent

$39,500

Last 30 days

2%

Last year

7%

View

The table above reflects average rent prices in Shelter Island, NY, broken down by the number of bedrooms, neighborhoods, and property types. The availability of data for each category is dependent on market inventory and will adjust depending on your selected filters.

Average rent in nearby cities

Explore rent trends in neighboring markets

Amagansett

$35,000

90%

Last year

Bridgehampton

$57,500

42%

Last year

Cutchogue

$22,500

34%

Last year

East Marion

$13,000

6%

Last year

Essex

$2,475

4%

Last year

Laurel

$20,000

199%

Last year

Quogue

$33,000

3%

Last year

Remsenburg Speonk

$35,000

N/A

Last year

Sagaponack

$55,000

15%

Last year

Southold

$12,250

26%

Last year

Wainscott

$59,000

7%

Last year

Water Mill

$60,000

27%

Last year