Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Located in Bay Shore, Mid Island Apartments offers remodeled homes with stainless-steel appliances and hardwood floors. This pet-friendly community features expansive green courtyards and is close to outdoor adventures, dining, and schools. Perfect for those seeking charm and convenience in a traditional setting.

Residents appreciate Mid Island Apartments for its attentive maintenance team, especially the superintendent Rob, who is praised for his reliability and helpfulness. The community is well-maintained, with efficient service from staff like Analia and Dennis. Opinions are mostly positive, highlighting the smooth living experience and convenient location, though individual preferences may vary.

Greenview Square offers affordable apartments designed for comfort and convenience. Each unit includes in-unit laundry with a washer and dryer, along with modern appliances like a dishwasher and refrigerator. Open parking makes access easy, providing a stress-free living experience. With an annual income requirement between $83,385 and $105,500, this community is perfect for those seeking budget-friendly options without compromising on essentials.

Located in Bay Shore, this community offers workforce housing ideal for households earning between $73,539 and $92,350. Enjoy essential on-site amenities like laundry facilities and assigned parking, ensuring comfort and convenience for residents. Each apartment features modern appliances, including a range, refrigerator, and microwave. Embrace a supportive living environment with easy access to essential services!

Residents of North District Lofts enjoy affordable housing with a prime focus on community living. Featuring attractive units on multiple floors with patios, this property provides essential amenities while ensuring a vibrant neighborhood atmosphere. With an income requirement ranging from $78,057 to $129,262, it offers an excellent opportunity for those seeking a home that balances affordability and accessibility.

Residents appreciate the cleanliness and responsive management at North District Lofts, particularly praising the maintenance staff. The small building atmosphere and available parking are also highlights. However, some feel the rent is too high compared to nearby suburbs and express frustration over parking challenges. A few have had negative experiences related to rental eligibility based on their profession.

Residents of Chelsea Place enjoy a lifestyle of comfort and convenience in Bay Shore. These thoughtfully designed apartments feature modern appliances like dishwashers, microwaves, and in-unit laundry for effortless living. With assigned parking and easy access to local amenities, this community offers a friendly atmosphere perfect for a relaxed yet vibrant lifestyle.

Nestled in Bay Shore, this upcoming luxury one-bedroom apartment offers the perfect blend of style and convenience. Residents will enjoy modern amenities including a fitness center, lounge, and yoga studio, all just steps away from vibrant restaurants, shops, and multiple transport options like ferry and train. With move-in availability starting May 1st, this apartment is a fantastic choice for those seeking a vibrant community atmosphere!

This beautifully renovated 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment boasts oversized rooms and modern finishes in a thoughtful layout. With 1,500 sq ft of comfortable living space, it's ideally located near the Bay Shore train station and local amenities. Enjoy features like high ceilings and a move-in ready vibe, plus included sewer, water, landscaping, and snow removal. Perfect for those seeking style, convenience, and a welcoming community atmosphere.

Experience serene waterfront living in this meticulously maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bath ranch style home. Spanning 1,445 square feet, it features an open layout, custom kitchen with new appliances, and expansive water views. Enjoy year-round comfort with central AC, a cozy fireplace, and modern updates throughout. With thoughtful design elements like an office/den, solar power, and a generator hookup, this property is ideal for relaxation or investment, combining coastal charm with contemporary convenience.

This cozy 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers 550 sq ft of comfortable living just a stone's throw from Bay Shore marina. Pet-friendly and featuring charming Colonial architecture, this unit is ideal for those seeking a peaceful retreat with convenience. Enjoy the vibrant neighborhood while living in a well-maintained space complete with essential amenities. Perfect for marine enthusiasts or anyone seeking a tranquil lifestyle!

This charming 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment features a unique loft-like oversized bedroom and a versatile layout. Nestled on a peaceful dead-end street, it's just minutes from shops and public transportation, blending convenience with tranquility. Spacious and inviting, this home offers a cozy escape in a desirable location.

This charming first-floor apartment boasts generous living space, adaptable as a one or two-bedroom unit. Enjoy a modern bathroom featuring a walk-in shower. With heat and water included, convenience is key. A large off-street parking lot is available exclusively for residents. Located close to public transport, shopping, and Fire Island ferries, this apartment provides easy access to all local amenities in a vibrant Bay Shore neighborhood.

Experience the convenience of downtown living in this luxurious 1-bedroom apartment at Chelsea Commons. Spanning 671 sq. ft., it features in-unit washer/dryer, P-Tac heating and cooling, and an elevator for easy access. Enjoy quick access to shops, restaurants, and beaches, plus parking and on-site amenities. Landlord covers water and garbage, making life a breeze in this contemporary retreat.

Experience stylish living in this elegant 1-bedroom apartment at Chelsea Commons. Spanning 662 sq ft, the unit features convenient amenities like an elevator, in-unit washer/dryer, and energy-efficient heating/cooling. Located steps from shops, restaurants, and beautiful beaches, this pet-friendly rental is perfect for anyone seeking a vibrant lifestyle. Utilities like water and garbage are included, ensuring a hassle-free experience in this desirable location.

This stylish studio apartment offers contemporary living in the heart of Bay Shore, featuring 650 sq ft of well-designed space. Enjoy the convenience of an elevator and in-unit washer/dryer. Just steps from shops, restaurants, and the Fire Island Ferry. Parking is available, and the landlord covers water, sewer, garbage, and snow removal. Pet-friendly for an additional fee, making it a comfortable and vibrant choice for city living.

Enjoy luxury living in this stunning studio apartment located in the sought-after Chelsea Commons. Spanning 622 sq. ft., it features an elevator for easy access and includes essential amenities such as in-unit washer/dryer and individual heating and cooling units. Perfectly located, it's just minutes from shopping, dining, and the beach, with convenient access to highways and the Fire Island Ferry. Pet-friendly with a nominal fee, this unit is ideal for a vibrant lifestyle.

Experience upscale living in this stylish 1-bedroom apartment at Chelsea Commons. Spanning 635 sq. ft., it features in-unit washer/dryer, P-Tac heating and cooling, and convenient elevator access. Located in vibrant Bay Shore, enjoy nearby shopping, dining, and quick access to the Fire Island Ferry. Landlord covers water, sewer, garbage, and snow removal. Pet-friendly with a small monthly fee! Ideal for those seeking comfort and convenience in a prime location.

Experience vibrant living in this brand-new luxury studio in Chelsea Commons. Spanning 738 sq ft, this apartment features convenient amenities including an elevator and in-unit washer/dryer. Located just minutes from local shops, restaurants, and the Fire Island Ferry, this home offers both comfort and accessibility. Enjoy included water, sewer, and garbage services, with electric and cable as tenant responsibilities. Live close to everything Bay Shore has to offer!

This roomy 3-bedroom, 2-bath apartment boasts an updated kitchen and fresh paint, creating a welcoming space. One bathroom is newly renovated. Enjoy the convenience of in-unit laundry, garage access, and a large driveway. With a generous yard and a central location close to the southern state parkway and LIRR stations, this apartment combines comfort and accessibility. Small pets are considered, and it's available for occupancy at the start of 2026.

Nestled in the serene Summer Club community, this expansive 5-bedroom, 3-bath ranch offers an open-concept living space and a large deck perfect for entertaining. With air conditioning throughout, room for a pool on a double lot, and access to private beaches, this home is a delightful retreat. Residents can enjoy a clubhouse, gym, and tennis courts for an active lifestyle by the bay. Ideal for those seeking comfort and tranquility near Ocean Beach.

A charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath home featuring a brand new kitchen with stylish quartz countertops. This Bay Shore rental offers efficient wall/window air conditioning, hardwood floors, and driveway parking. Located just minutes away from downtown amenities, schools, and parks, this inviting space is perfect for those seeking comfort and convenience in a vibrant community. Enjoy the spacious layout and modern upgrades in this lovely Colonial-style residence.

This bright and airy second-floor apartment features one bedroom, offering ample storage with many closets. Freshly painted and boasting high ceilings, it includes additional basement storage and shared laundry facilities. Located close to trendy restaurants, shops, and the Bay Shore marina, this apartment combines comfort with convenience, making it an ideal place to call home. Enjoy easy access to everything the vibrant Bay Shore area has to offer!

This inviting 2nd-floor 1-bedroom apartment features 800 sq ft of comfortable living space. Enjoy the convenience of in-unit laundry and central air. The tenant is responsible for electric, cable, and internet. Perfect for those seeking a cozy retreat in a welcoming community.

Enjoy comfortable living in this 800 sq. ft. 1-bedroom apartment featuring a bright layout. Convenient in-unit washer and dryer, natural gas heating, and central air ensure modern comfort. Located on the second floor, this apartment offers a cozy space perfect for anyone looking for simplicity and convenience. Tenant responsibilities include electric, cable, and internet.

A beautifully maintained Colonial home featuring 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths creates a comfortable living space spread over 1,900 square feet. Nestled in a convenient location, enjoy easy access to major amenities while being within the Bay Shore School District. The property boasts a large, fully fenced yard and includes private parking along with a detached 2-car garage. Ideal for families, this home offers both space and convenience in a desirable setting.

Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, this inviting 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers a spacious 650 sq ft layout filled with natural light. Enjoy a generous living area and large bedroom, all within close proximity to shops, dining, and waterfront attractions. With a convenient floor plan and prime location, this apartment is perfect for those seeking comfort and accessibility. Ideal for October 1st occupancy!

This inviting 4-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers a generous 1,000 sq ft of living space, filled with natural light. Enjoy a bright living area, large bedrooms, and a convenient location near shops, dining, and waterfront attractions. Perfect for those seeking comfort and easy access to Bay Shore's amenities. Whether you’re commuting or relaxing, this spacious home fits all lifestyles. Available for October 1st occupancy.

This charming 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom Cape Cod home offers modern comfort with renovated interiors. Enjoy a large dining/living area adorned with hardwood floors, an in-unit washer and dryer, and off-street parking. The inviting backyard is ideal for BBQs and entertaining. With 1,062 square feet of living space, this residence perfectly blends cozy living with functional design, creating a delightful home for relaxation and gatherings.

This charming 1-bed, 1-bath apartment is perfect for those seeking a vibrant community in Bay Shore. With 600 sq. ft. of cozy living space, all utilities are included, plus free Wi-Fi! Enjoy the convenience of assigned parking and a welcoming courtyard. Experience comfort with heat and air conditioning, making this your ideal haven.

Experience unparalleled beach living in this brand-new, custom-designed retreat, ideal for hosting up to 16 guests across 8 bedrooms and 4 baths. Enjoy breathtaking views of the Great South Bay and iconic landmarks from expansive living areas and sunlit decks. With room for unforgettable gatherings and modern touches throughout, this Fire Island property is the ultimate escape, just steps from the ferry and beach.

Experience tranquility in this charming cottage, perfect for a weekly rental at $5,000. With magnificent sunset views, this home is an ideal getaway for watersports and fishing enthusiasts. Features include separate entrances and amenities like beach chairs and umbrellas, making it a perfect escape for relaxation and adventure. Enjoy the natural beauty and serenity of this idyllic environment.

This spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bath apartment ensures comfort with included utilities. Located in the vibrant heart of Bay Shore, it offers easy access to the LIRR, shopping, and medical facilities. Ideal for those seeking convenience and a welcoming community. Experience modern living in a classic Colonial-style setting!