House for rent

19 Hours Ago

42 North Menantic Road
42 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, New York 11964, United States

Monthly rent	$7,500
Beds	4
Baths	2.5
Sqft	2,800

Monthly rent	$7,500
Beds	4
Baths	2.5
Sqft	2,800

19 Hours Ago

Location

42 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, New York 11964, United States

Tour 42 North Menantic Road

Contact

Jeanmarie Bay

Town & Country Real Estate (Greenport)

(631) 477-5990

Amenities for 42 North Menantic Road

Apartment Amenities

Air Conditioning	Central Air
Central Heat	Den
Fireplace	Hardwood Floor
Radiant

Appliances

Dishwasher

In-Unit Laundry

Building

Basement

Residents Lounge

Grounds

Garage Parking

Swimming Pool

Other

Architecture Style: Contemporary	Exterior Type: Stone
Exterior Type: Wood Siding	Oil
Propane Heating	Roof Type: Asphalt
Seven Rooms

Units, floor plans, amenities, dimensions, details, availability, and prices may be approximate and subject to change. Please contact a community representative for more information.

Policies and fees

Applicants

One-time.

Contact Property

REQUIRED FEES

Security Deposit

One-time. Refundable.

Contact Property

About 42 North Menantic Road

Home

42 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, New York 11964, United States

Property Status: Active Escape to Tranquility Base, a light-filled modern retreat where timeless mid-century style meets today's elevated comforts. Thoughtfully renovated and expanded, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home is surrounded by lush, landscaped grounds and designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living-thanks to five sliding glass doors that open to a heated gunite pool and expansive entertaining deck. Enjoy the Shelter Island lifestyle at this completely renovated, Contemporary home It will serve as both your quiet sanctuary away from city life and a place to entertain. When it is time to explore, beaches, farm stands, seafood shops, and celebrated Shelter Island restaurants are all within easy reach. Savor the excellent restaurants or make your own home-cooked meals on the 5-burner Jenn-Air gas stove or outdoor gas grill. Full kitchen with all amenities including granite center island, Electrolux Icon appliances. There is a large capacity washer/dryer off kitchen. Lounge on the large, sectional sofa in the living room with gas fireplace. The house features 2 systems for central heat and A/C with Nest thermostats. The bedrooms consist of one King Bed in Primary Bedroom with en-suite Carrera marble bathroom; 2 twin beds in 2nd bedroom with full bathroom, shower and tub and 3rd bedroom with comfortable, Queen sleeper sofa. A 4th Bedroom on lower level features a Queen Bed and home office. The lower level also features a kitchenette, living area and ping pong table. A half-bath is off the main kitchen and dining room. Play your favorite songs on 2 Sonos systems in the living room and pool deck. A T-shaped driveway provides ample parking for up to 5 cars. Available Winter Rate January 1st to June 30th $7500 PER MONTH. Rental Permit 2024-L-0124. Photos coming soon. Office Phone: (631) 477-5990 Copyright © 2025 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Source: NYSMLS|MLS Listing No. 11612998

Go to property website

Address details

Zip code	11964
Type	House for rent

Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere

Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.

Rent trends in Shelter Island

4-bedroom apartments at 42 North Menantic Road cost about 75% less than the average rent price for 4-bedroom apartments in Shelter Island.

Median rents as of Oct 25 2025.

Shelter Island

A table of 4-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Shelter Island
Month	Median Rent
March 2025	$30,000
April 2025	$30,000
May 2025	$30,000
June 2025	$30,000
July 2025	$30,000
August 2025	$30,000
September 2025	$30,000
October 2025	$30,000

Affordability calculator

Can I afford to live at 42 North Menantic Road?

Bedrooms

4+ bedrooms

Rent-to-income ratio

30%

Slide to adjust the percentage of your monthly income you are willing to spend on rent.

The general rule of thumb is to spend around 30% or less of your income on rent.

Recommended income

$300,000/yr

With your selected rent-to-income ratio, you'd ideally want to make $300,000 annually to afford this 4-bedrooms monthly rent price of $7,500.

For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator.

Check availability

Full name*

Move-in date

I saw your rental listing on Zumper and would like to learn more.

Custom message

By sending this inquiry, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values. By providing my phone number, I consent (not a condition of purchase) to be called and texted by 42 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, New York 11964, United States.