Bedroom count
Property type
Last updated on December 6, 2025
Average rent in
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Last updated on December 6, 2025
Last updated on December 6, 2025
Bedroom count
Property type
As of November 2025, the median rent for all bedroom counts and property types in Shelter Island Heights, NY is $26,500. This is +1273%, or $24,570, higher than the national average.
average price per square foot
Median rent
$26,500
As of November 2025, we do not have enough inventory to generate median rent for all bedroom counts and property types in Shelter Island Heights, NY. Please check back soon.
Total rentals
15
for rent on Zumper.com
As of November 2025, the median rent for all bedroom counts and property types in Shelter Island Heights, NY is $26,500. This is +1273%, or $24,570, higher than the national average.
average price per square foot
Rent ranges
Households
Median rent and rent ranges are based on Zumper inventory in the last 30 days. Household data are provided by the US Census Bureau.
Rent price trends in
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Rent price trends
Rent prices for all bedroom counts and property types in Shelter Island Heights, NY have remained the same in the last month.
Rent prices on this page are calculated on a rolling 30-day basis and updated daily.
Rent comparables in
Shelter Island Heights, NY
The monthly rent for an apartment in Shelter Island Heights, NY is $4,500. A 1-bedroom apartment in Shelter Island Heights, NY costs about $3,500 on average. Houses for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY are more expensive, with an average monthly cost of $17,000.
Comparables | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
1 bedroom | $3,000 | - | - | |
2 bedroom | $4,000 | - | - | |
3 bedroom | $10,000 | - | - | |
4 bedroom | $40,000 | No Change | - |
At this time, we don't have enough active inventory for all rentals to generate data. Please check back soon to see neighborhood rent prices in Shelter Island Heights, NY.
Comparables | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Apartments | $4,500 | - | No Change | |
Condos | $7,600 | - | - | |
Houses | $17,000 | No Change | No Change |
1 bedroom
Average rent
$3,000
2 bedroom
Average rent
$4,000
3 bedroom
Average rent
$10,000
4 bedroom
Average rent
$40,000
At this time, we don't have enough active inventory for all rentals to generate data. Please check back soon to see neighborhood rent prices in Shelter Island Heights, NY.
Apartments
Average rent
$4,500
Condos
Average rent
$7,600
Houses
Average rent
$17,000
The table above reflects average rent prices in Shelter Island Heights, NY, broken down by the number of bedrooms, neighborhoods, and property types. The availability of data for each category is dependent on market inventory and will adjust depending on your selected filters.
Compare rent prices in Shelter Island Heights, NY to other cities
Median rent prices in Shelter Island Heights, NY for all bedroom counts and property types compared to Amagansett, NY.
Shelter Island Heights
1273%higher than the national median
1195%higher than the national median
Takeaway
The median rent for all rentals in Shelter Island Heights, NY is 6% higher than the median rent in Amagansett, NY.
More data insights and reports
Are you interested in licensing our current and historical rental real estate data, or do you have custom data requests? Contact datalicensing@zumper.com.
Average rent in
Nearby cities
Explore rent trends in other markets
Amagansett
$25,000
15%Last year
East Marion
$16,000
6%Last year
Eastport
$10,000
184%Last year
Haddam
$2,542
21%Last year
Laurel
$7,000
26%Last year
Marlborough
$1,850
Last year
New Suffolk
$24,000
192%Last year
Orient
$18,000
100%Last year
Peconic
$8,250
146%Last year
Sagaponack
$37,500
27%Last year
Sprague
$1,800
Last year
Wainscott
$55,000
19%Last year
Discover rentals in Shelter Island Heights, NY
5d+ ago
House for rent in Shelter Island Heights
61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
5 beds
5 baths
$40,000
House for rent