Skip to navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
Zumper

Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

All rentals

141A North Ferry Road - Photo 1 of 1
New construction

4d ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Residential Lease, Shelter Island, NY

141A North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Garage parking | Swimming pool | Fireplace

3 beds

3.5 baths

$12,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
31 Saint Marys Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Residential, Shelter Island, NY

31 Saint Marys Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Furnished | Garage parking | Hardwood floor

2 beds

1.5 baths

$20,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
27 Brander Pkwy - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Residential, Shelter Island, NY

27 Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Hardwood floor | Walk-in closets | Fireplace

4 beds

3 baths

$16,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
9 Locust Woods Dr - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Residential Lease, Shelter Island, NY

9 Locust Woods Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

In-unit laundry | Dishwasher

4 beds

3.5 baths

$21,500

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
56 N Menantic Rd #B - Photo 1 of 1
New construction

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Residential, Shelter Island, NY

56 N Menantic Rd #B, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Garage parking | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor

4 beds

4 baths

$40,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
23 Osprey Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Residential Lease, Shelter Island, NY

23 Osprey Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

In-unit laundry | Garage parking | On-site laundry

4 beds

3.5 baths

$86,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
9 Johnston Road - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Townhouse for rent in Shelter Island

9 Johnston Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Dishwasher

4 beds

2 baths

$20,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
33 Atlantic Ave - Photo 1 of 1

4d ago

House for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

33 Atlantic Ave, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Fireplace

3 beds

2 baths

$22,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
The best of Zumper, delivered

Be the first to hear about new listings matching your search.

Email
By clicking submit, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values.
15 Church St #W204 - Photo 1 of 1

4d ago

Apartment for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

15 Church St #W204, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Balcony | Swimming pool | Fitness center

2 beds

2 baths

$64,999

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
26 Payne Ave - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

26 Payne Ave, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Hardwood floor

2 beds

1 bath

$13,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
11 Rogers St - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

11 Rogers St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Swimming pool | Hardwood floor | Walk-in closets

2 beds

2 baths

$32,673

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.

Find rentals with popular amenities

Garage Parking

Outdoor Space

Hardwood Floor

High Ceilings

42 Stirling Cv #A - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Condo for rent in Greenport

42 Stirling Cv #A, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor

2 beds

2 baths

$49,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
83 Hempstead St - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

83 Hempstead St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Swimming pool | Hardwood floor | Walk-in closets

4 beds

3 baths

$64,999

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
40 Stirling Cv - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Condo for rent in Greenport

Residential Lease, Greenport, NY

40 Stirling Cv, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor

2 beds

3 baths

$20,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
618 Carpenter St #2 - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Townhouse for rent in Greenport

3 Bedroom Winter Oasis

618 Carpenter St #2, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Balcony

3 beds

2 baths

$3,500

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
618 Carpenter St - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

Large Greenport Winter Oasis

618 Carpenter St, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Furnished | On-site laundry

6 beds

3 baths

$6,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
618 Carpenter St #1 - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Townhouse for rent in Greenport

3 Bedroom Winter Oasis

618 Carpenter St #1, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Balcony

3 beds

1 bath

$3,500

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.

Find sweet deals near Shelter Island

These rentals are 10%-30% cheaper than the local average price for similar rentals.

$25,000

Sag Harbor

$25,000

Sag Harbor

$50,000

Sag Harbor

$50,000

Sag Harbor

300 Fiddler Ln - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

Residential Lease, Greenport, NY

300 Fiddler Ln, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Furnished | On-site laundry

3 beds

4 baths

$4,900

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
25 Henry St - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

25 Henry St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Garage parking | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor

4 beds

4 baths

$68,316

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
15 Cuffee Dr - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

15 Cuffee Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Furnished | On-site laundry | Swimming pool

4 beds

3 baths

$78,358

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
15 Church St #14 - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Apartment for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

15 Church St #14, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Swimming pool | Fitness center | Hardwood floor

1 bed

1 bath

$30,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
1100 7th St - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

Residential Lease, Greenport, NY

1100 7th St, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | High ceilings | Dishwasher

1 bed

1 bath

$3,100

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

1000 9th St ## G59, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Outdoor space

2 beds

1 bath

$2,600

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
93 Redwood Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Sag Harbor

Residential, Sag Harbor, NY

93 Redwood Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Garage parking | Swimming pool | Fitness center

5 beds

5.5 baths

$100,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
Listings within 10 miles
23 Powder Hill Ln - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in East Hampton

Residential, East Hampton, NY

23 Powder Hill Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937

Swimming pool | Controlled access

6 beds

7.5 baths

$95,000

Fees may apply. The price shown reflects base rent. Complete fee information is not available from the property, so additional fees may increase the total monthly cost.
Showing 1 - 25 of 25 results
Home > Apartments in Shelter Island
Updated: October 26, 2026

Are you a rental professional?

Try our tenant screening, or post rental listings to Zumper, Craigslist Shelter Island, and more.
Atlanta ApartmentsAustin ApartmentsBaltimore ApartmentsBoston ApartmentsCharlotte ApartmentsChicago ApartmentsDallas ApartmentsDenver ApartmentsDetroit ApartmentsHouston ApartmentsLas Vegas ApartmentsLos Angeles ApartmentsMiami ApartmentsMinneapolis ApartmentsNew York ApartmentsPhiladelphia ApartmentsPhoenix ApartmentsPittsburgh ApartmentsPortland ApartmentsSan Antonio ApartmentsSan Diego ApartmentsSan Francisco ApartmentsSeattle ApartmentsTampa ApartmentsWashington DC Apartments

Shelter Island, NY apartments for rent

Renting in Shelter Island, NY at a glance

As of today, Shelter Island's average rent price is $23,250 per month. See the Shelter Island rent report.

Average rent

$23,250

Rentals, last 30 days

20

Rent by unit type
SizeValueYoY
All bedrooms$23,250N/A
2 bedroom$25,000N/A
Not sure what you can afford? Try our rent calculator

What kinds of apartments are available to rent in Shelter Island, NY?

Shelter Island is a small but active rental market with an average of 7 listings per month. The inventory consists entirely of 3-bedroom apartments, which make up 100% of available rentals. Studios, 1-bedroom, and 2-bedroom units are relatively scarce, accounting for 0% of the monthly inventory.

Shelter Island apartments cater to renters seeking spacious accommodations with resort-style amenities. Pool access leads the amenity offerings, available in 86% of listings. In-unit laundry and dishwashers are equally common, each found in 71% of available apartments, providing the convenience that larger households typically require. These figures are based on historical data, but they should give you a sense of what to expect in the current market.

Frequently asked questions

What is the average rent in Shelter Island, NY?

The average rent in Shelter Island, NY is $23,250 a month. 2-bedrooms average $25,000, based on rentals listed on Zumper in the last 30 days. See the Shelter Island rent report.

How much rent can I afford in Shelter Island, NY?

Use the rent calculator to see what you can afford in Shelter Island, NY.

How can I find cheap apartments in Shelter Island, NY?

Use the cheap apartments filter to see the lowest-priced rentals in and around Shelter Island, NY.

How can I find pet-friendly apartments in Shelter Island, NY?

Use the pet-friendly filter to find apartments in and around Shelter Island, NY that allow pets.

How can I find furnished apartments in Shelter Island, NY?

Use the furnished filter to see furnished rentals in and around Shelter Island, NY.

How can I find apartments with move-in specials in Shelter Island, NY?

Use the move-in specials filter to find apartments in and around Shelter Island, NY with a current move-in deal.

Methodology: How we got this data

Zumper’s proprietary rental data fuels our analysis. Rent and market trends, availability, neighborhood popularity, and lifestyle scores are all calculated using real-time and 2026 rental inventory and prices.

Our Lifestyle Categories ("great for eco-living," "great for social life," "great for pet owners," etc.) are determined by set criteria, against which we score each listing and its available features. At the neighborhood level, we calculate the listing count for each category to determine which lifestyles best fit each area.

Zumper, founded in 2012, is North America’s largest privately-owned rental platform, offering over 1 million listings across the U.S. and Canada. Stay informed on the latest trends and shifts in the rental market with our monthly National Rent Report, your go-to resource for key insights into the evolving rental landscape.

Looking for apartments in Shelter Island, NY near you?

Shelter Island, NY rental availability
🔑Available apartment rentals25
💰Best rent deal1000 9th St ## G59
✨Popular amenities, ,
🧦In-unit laundry
🍽With dishwasher
🏠With photos