Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

This enchanting 4-bedroom, 2-bath mid-century ranch features a new heated Gunite pool, separate hot tub, and outdoor shower, all set on a private .6-acre lot. Embrace the breezy nautical theme in the spacious kitchen, or enjoy fun-filled nights in the groovy media room. With a large record collection, ping pong, foosball, and nearby attractions like Sylvester Manor Farm and Hay Beach, this home blends relaxation and entertainment perfectly.

Experience luxury living in this beautifully renovated 4-bedroom townhouse, boasting 2,775 sq ft of space and breathtaking views of Menantic Creek. An open floor plan features a modern chef's kitchen and walls of glass doors leading to a spacious waterfront deck. The lower level offers an additional lounge, gym, and a cozy fireplace area with a pizza oven. Perfect for boating enthusiasts, this home includes its own deep-water dock and is close to charming local eateries and stunning beaches.

This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath rental features an open floor plan and a sunlit enclosed porch perfect for unwinding. Enjoy the outdoor deck overlooking a peaceful grassy yard and an outdoor shower after a day at the nearby beach. The master suite boasts a brand-new bathroom, complemented by an additional full bath and a finished basement. Flexible rental rates make this home an ideal seasonal escape.

Ideal for a summer getaway, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch is recently renovated and offers a large backyard deck perfect for outdoor dining. Located close to beautiful beaches, this rental also features an EV Level 2 charging outlet. Available for July at $15,000 and August at $16,000, it provides a perfect blend of comfort and convenience for summer fun.

This stylish 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home spans 2,604 sq ft and showcases modern design with bright, sun-filled interiors and multiple living spaces. Recently renovated and furnished, it offers an effortless flow for summer enjoyment, from morning coffee to poolside relaxation. The private backyard creates a resort-like atmosphere perfect for entertaining, while quick access to Peconic and Gardiners Bay enhances the nautical lifestyle. Experience the serene charm of Shelter Island living.

This beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers a stunning blend of mid-century style and modern comfort, spanning 2,800 sq ft. Enjoy seamless indoor-outdoor living with five sliding glass doors leading to a heated gunite pool and expansive deck. The gourmet kitchen features a granite island and Electrolux appliances, while the lower level includes a kitchenette and recreational space. Ideal for relaxation or entertaining, this retreat is just moments from beaches and local dining on Shelter Island.

This delightful 3-bedroom, 2-bath home in Hay Beach offers a perfect blend of comfort and style. A large living room with a cozy fireplace opens to an awning-covered deck, ideal for relaxation. The spacious loft provides a versatile space for an office or guest overflow, while the fully furnished interior ensures ease and convenience. Enjoy the tranquil surroundings just minutes from Gardiners Bay Country Club in this charming contemporary sanctuary, spanning 1,487 square feet.