Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

Set in Shelter Island, NY, this fully furnished contemporary 3-bed, 2-bath house sits just 2 minutes from Gardiners Bay Country Club. The 1,487 sqft layout features a large living room with fireplace, loft office space, and covered deck with sliders. Hardwood floors, central air, in-unit laundry, and garage parking complete the year-round rental.

A house in Shelter Island, NY, this modern 4-bed, 4-bath retreat features soaring ceilings, expansive windows, and open-concept living with seamless indoor-outdoor flow. Updated in 2024, the contemporary design includes hardwood floors, central air, in-unit laundry, and a detached garage. The landscaped property adds a heated gunite pool and outdoor spaces.

Set in Shelter Island, NY, this renovated ranch-style house offers 4 beds and 3.5 baths across 3,484 sqft on over an acre with pond views. The chef-inspired kitchen, wood-burning fireplace, and screened porch create ideal entertaining spaces, while residents enjoy private beach and tennis court access just down the block. Two-car garage and proximity to Wades Beach complete the island retreat.

Right in Shelter Island, NY, this modern 4-bed, 3-bath house comes fully furnished and recently renovated for turnkey summer living. The 2,604 sqft layout features bright interiors, multiple living spaces, central air, and a basement. A private pool and outdoor entertaining area create a resort-like backyard setting with quick access to Peconic Bay boating and Sag Harbor dining.

Set in Shelter Island, NY, this 4-bed, 2-bath cedar-shake townhouse offers 1,400 sqft with a heated Gunite pool, separate hot tub, and outdoor shower on a private 0.6-acre lot. The windowed kitchen features a Bosch dishwasher and electric range, while downstairs adds a media room with ping pong, foosball, and four bikes. Located near Sylvester Manor Farm and Hay Beach.