3 Bedroom Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

RP# R-2024-0042 Just moments to historic downtown Sag Harbor Village and killer sunsets at Long Beach and Sunset Beach in North Haven. This three bedroom two and half bath home has everything you are looking for in a summer stay. Open living and kitchen area, fireplace, vaulted dining area, first floor primary and two cottage style bedrooms on the second floor. Beautiful fenced in back yard offers a fire pit, outdoor shower for post beach days, two patio areas for evening dining and poolside entertaining. The 18 x45ft pool is perfect for morning laps and built in sundeck f

Property Status: Active Southold Village Rental Charming and well-located, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath residence offers easy North Fork living just moments from the heart of Southold. A short distance to Southold Town, local shops, dining, and the waterfront, as well as close proximity to Founders Beach for swimming, sunsets, and seaside relaxation. The home features a comfortable layout with light-filled living spaces, making it ideal for a monthly or seasonal rental. A wonderful opportunity to enjoy the best of village life and beach access in one of the North Fork's most des

Property Status: Active Enjoy a few months nestled in the heart of Greenport in a stunning, gated waterfront condo that offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle. With 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 and a half bathrooms, this 2-story furnished abode will make you feel like you are on vacation everyday. Feel the strain of the day melt away as you take in the breathtaking water views of the Peconic Bay and Shelter Island from the comfort of your living/dining room combination, complete with a cozy fireplace. The primary bedroom, boasting an en suite bathroom, a fireplac

Property Status: Active This Freshly Renovated Apartment is centrally located in Southold Village. The Two Family Home is in proximity to everything the North Fork has to offer. Three upstairs Bedrooms are comfortably separated from a large kitchen and entertainment area. The move-in ready apartment is located within Southold School District, and provides for the perfect year round home or North Fork Retreat. Additional information: Lease Term:12 Months,Over 12 Months Office Phone: (631) 655-7999 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by

Property Status: Active Located in Hay Beach, this year round furnished rental is available and fully furnished. 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths is located in the beautiful area of Hay Beach, just 2 minutes from Gardiners Bay Country Club. Large living room with fireplace and sliders out to the large awning covered deck. Large loft area off the living room could serve as an office area of for overflow guests. Office Phone: (631) 848-7730 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guarante

Property Status: Active Stylish and comfortable home with plenty of space to relax indoors and out, featuring a covered porch, a sunny deck and a large yard. Just a short distance to a Long Island Sound beach. Summer 2026 - Memorial Day to Labor Day $52,000, Memorial Day thru June $14,000, July $18,000 (or $4,500 Per Week with Two Week Minimum); August to Labor Day $22,000 (or $4,500 Per Week with Two Minimum). Office Phone: (631) 553-5255 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not gu

Property Status: Active So Very Close to a Beautiful Bay Beach! 3 Bedrooms/2 Baths. Central Air Conditioning. 2 Large Decks. Nice Yard! FALL 2025 - November 2025 to April 2026 -$4,000 Per Month for Single or Multiple Months. SUMMER 2026 - Memorial Day to Labor Day $29,000; June $8,000; July $10,000; August to Labor Day $12,500. Permit #0497., Office Phone: (631) 477-2220 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Property Status: Active 3 Bedroom/2 Bath Home with Heated Inground Pool and Several Beaches Nearby. Open Floor Plan and Vaulted Ceilings. Enjoy the Days of Summer on the Back Deck, Fenced Lawn and Pool. Several Nearby Beaches Too! Winter Rental (November 2025 to April 2026) Single or Multiple Months Considered at $5,000 Per Month. Summer 2026 - Memorial Day to Labor Day $45,000; June $12,000; July $16,000; August to Labor Day $20,000; Weekly $4,000 Per Week with Two Week Minimum. Permit #0586. Office Phone: (631) 553-5255 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. A

Property Status: Active Amazing Winter Rental with a Perfect Location in Sag Harbor Welcome to your new Sag Harbor lifestyle! Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac, this home is the perfect blend of peaceful living and prime location, just moments from everything you love about the Hamptons. The moment you step inside this charming beach cottage, you're greeted by an open floor plan bathed in natural light, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere. The design is all about effortless coastal living, with a seamless flow that leads you out to a spacious deck and a lush, level b

Property Status: Active one of a most desirable spot at Greenport - Super Spacious !. This charming home offers generous rooms, ample storage, and a detached 2-car garage with a full-size loft—perfect for a studio or extra storage. Located in the heart of Greenport, a quaint, short distance to seaside village filled with shops, galleries, quiet rustic storefronts, and picturesque harbor scenes. Enjoy true beach community living in a serene coastal setting. Rental permit # 0745 expire : July 30 2027. Office Phone: (631) 354-8100 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reser

Property Status: Active Beautiful North Fork home within walking distance to the beach, as well as numerous vineyards, restaurants, and local shops. Upon entering this home, you will enjoy spacious living quarters full of natural light and comfortable furnishings. The perfect mix of modern comfort, the gourmet kitchen boasts stainless steel appliances, gleaming countertops, and a large center island with a breakfast bar. When you aren't hanging out in the living room, tuned into your favorite show in front of the heat of the fireplace, check out the equally plush bedrooms.

Property Status: Active East Marion Rental! This immaculate high ranch home has a deeded private beach located less than 400 ft. away. It features an updated eat-in kitchen, separate dining room, three spacious bedrooms, three full baths and two living rooms - one on the main level and the other located on the lower walk-out level. The expansive rear yard is ideal for entertaining and enjoying summer bbq's and those crisp fall evenings. Gleaming hardwood floors and central air complete this comfortable home. Convenient to all! Enjoy all the North Fork is so well know for a

Property Status: Active FULLY TURNKEY from furnishings, bedding / linens, towels, to all kitchen ware, 100K artwork Maintenance team including house cleaner, pool care and landscaper are at your disposal. 2 minute walk into town - best location in Greenport, across from LIRR train and Hampton Jitney. Must honor all current Airbnb and VRBO bookings. MAIN HOUSE GROUND LEVEL: Living room with wood burning fireplace, XXXL Sectional Sofa. Captains chair, Cinema Style 92" Flatscreen with Dolby 9.1 Surround Sound. Full kitchen with stainless steel appliances an

Property Status: Active Like-new Greenport beauty with every amenity including a saltwater pool. Room for all indoors with a living room, reading room and large media room and outdoors with a dining area and lounging area poolside. Located in a lovely, quiet neighborhood just a few minutes to a gorgeous, sandy Bay beach, a beautiful Sound beach and Greenport's vibrant downtown with its waterfront park, cafes & restaurants, boutiques. Wineries, farm stands & fresh fish markets all nearby. Farm to table heaven in a fabulous vacation location. Appearance - mint. Rental Per

Property Status: Active Experience the ultimate in tranquility and luxury at this secluded oasis, where every moment is a picturesque escape. Discover breathtaking panoramic water views and soak in the mesmerizing sunrise & sunsets over Gardiner's Bay from just about every room in the house. Boasting an impressive layout featuring an open plan den/media room, dining room, and chef's kitchen-all thoughtfully designed to immerse you in the beauty of the surrounding waters. Expansive waterfront decks filer out of every room. A guest bedroom and a full bath finish off the grou

Property Status: Active $6,000.00 for March, $7,000.00 for April, $10,000.00 for May, $15,000.00 for June, $15,000.00 for July, $15,000.00 for August. FUN IN THE SUN! Come spend your summer at one of the best beach communities in East Marion on the North Fork. Nestled in a peaceful community, with sunsets on the beach and a pool in your private backyard. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, full finished basement and an outdoor shower. You will never want to leave. Surrounded by North Fork renowned farm stands, restaurants, beaches, marinas, boating, award winning wineries and great shopp

Property Status: Active Tucked Away Along Sterling Harbor in Greenport's Historic District On the Village's Most Desired Street. This Lovely 3 BR, 2 BA Cottage Is Only A Block From the Maritime Village With Its Many Restaurants, Cafes, Shops, Mitchell Park & Carousel. Enjoy Your Morning Coffee & Evening Cocktails On The Waterview Deck. Close to All Transportation, Beaches & Wineries., Additional information: Appearance: EXCELLENT, Lease Term: August-Labor Day, July, July-August Office Phone: (631) 765-5815 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information p

Property Status: Active Impeccable, like new ranch for rent with quality features throughout in Harbor Lights with a deeded beach and park at the end of the street. There are three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, open floor plan from kitchen through the dining area into the vaulted ceiling living room, Enjoy the beautiful screened in porch which overlooks the private back yard with slate patio, grass lawn, and outdoor shower. Prime location for easy access to numerous beaches, wineries and town shops, restaurants and transportation. Available off season months. Southo

Property Status: Active Located in the heart of Greenport Village, this charming home offers an open concept first level and has a first floor bedroom, half bathroom with washer and dryer and an expansive rear deck, covered by canvas for shade, overlooking a manicured and private rear yard. The second floor has two spacious bedrooms with a walk in closet and a full bathroom with a separate shower and large bathtub. Located just a quarter of a mile from Mitchel Park and Marina, this home is within close proximity to everything that Greenport Village and the North Fork hav

Property Status: Active With the addition of a new 20' x 40' heated, salt water in-ground pool in private yard, this fully renovated Greenport home has been stylishly decorated and features a large, eat-in kitchen, expansive living room, 3 bedrooms with two ensuite full bathrooms and a third full standalone bathroom. The residence has a large side yard and patio on a 1/3 of an acre and is third of a mile to the heart of Greenport Village as well as nearby beaches, marinas, parks, wineries and restaurants. Rental Permit # 0200, Additional information: Appearance:Mint Office

Property Status: Active Beautifully Renovated in 2023. 3 Bedrooms/2 Bathroom. One Floor Living with Deck and Nice Yard. Fully Furnished. Off Season - November 2025 to May 2026 $3,000. Year Round $4,200. Rental Permit #0946. Office Phone: (631) 553-5255 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Property Status: Active Private, peaceful home on a serene acre of property. Just renovated, featuring open modern Kitchen/Dining combo for casual entertaining. Separate family room across open foyer with fireplace and loads of puzzles & games. Charming covered front porch looks out onto front yard. Back deck with grill overlooks pool and backyard. Three bedrooms: 1 Queen, 2 full beds and primary with king bed and en-suite bathroom with large shower. Hall bathroom with tub. Laundry in basement. Tasteful furnishings, all the basics & wifi together make this an easy place to

Property Status: Active Permit #: 0160. This Superb 3-Bedroom, 2-Bathroom Ranch Home Showcases Gorgeous Water Views And Is Strategically Located Near Goose Creek Beach And The Pulsating Heart Of Southold, Allowing You To Enjoy The Best Of Both Worlds. The Interior Is Beautifully Designed With A Minimalist Aesthetic, Offering A Serene Retreat From The Every Day Hustle And Bustle. The Open Layout Allows For Easy Movement And A Seamless Blend Of Indoor And Outdoor Living Spaces. Its Picturesque Waterfront Setting Serving As A Constant Reminder Of The Beauty That Surrounds Yo