Skip to navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
Zumper

Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Average rent

$13,000
decreased by47%

Track prices

Rent calculator

What can I afford?

All rentals

4 Summerfield Pl - Photo 1 of 1

4d ago

House for rent in Shelter Island Heights

5BR, 4BA Waterfront Victorian

4 Summerfield Pl, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

In-unit laundry | Balcony | Hardwood floor

5 beds

4 baths

$9,000

House for rent

Available Jun 1

Charming Victorian Retreat with Scenic Views

Embrace a serene summer retreat in this beautifully preserved Victorian home from 1872, featuring 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. Enjoy peaceful moments on the spacious covered deck while watching boats sail by and taking in breathtaking sunsets. Conveniently located near the North Ferry and close to local shops and dining, this exclusive property also offers access to a private beach club and tennis courts, making it the perfect getaway spot for relaxation and summer fun.

1345 Long Creek Dr - Photo 1 of 1

3h ago

Our team has verified this company

Verified

1345 Long Creek Dr, Southold, NY 11971

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Air conditioning

4 beds

3 baths

$16,274

Apartment for rent

56765 Route 48 - Photo 1 of 1

9h ago

House for rent in Greenport

56765 Route 48, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Swimming pool

3 beds

2 baths

$100,000

House for rent

11003 Main Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in East Marion

SINGLE_FAMILY - Modern - East Marion, NY

11003 Main Rd, East Marion, NY 11939

Swimming pool | Hardwood floor | High ceilings

3 beds

2 baths

$15,000

House for rent

420 Old Farm Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Orient

SINGLE_FAMILY - Modern - Orient, NY

420 Old Farm Rd, Orient, NY 11957

In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Swimming pool

4 beds

3.5 baths

$32,000

House for rent

24 S Midway Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Townhouse for rent in Shelter Island

24 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Garage parking | Fitness center | Fireplace

4 beds

4 baths

$45,000

House for rent

1875 Bayview Ave - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Southold

SINGLE_FAMILY - Cottage - Southold, NY

1875 Bayview Ave, Southold, NY 11971

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Garage parking

3 beds

2 baths

$4,000

House for rent

24 Worthy Way - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Shelter Island-Neat, Clean and close to beaches

24 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964

In-unit laundry | Balcony | Hardwood floor

3 beds

2 baths

$15,000

House for rent

The best of Zumper, delivered

Be the first to hear about new listings matching your search.

Email
By clicking submit, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values.
6 Crab Creek Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

Shelter Island-Silver Beach Community

6 Crab Creek Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Balcony

3 beds

2 baths

$10,000

House for rent

Available Jun 1

1050 Pine Ave - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Southold

SINGLE_FAMILY - Cottage - Southold, NY

1050 Pine Ave, Southold, NY 11971

Outdoor space

3 beds

2 baths

$10,000

House for rent

Advertisement
695 Rogers Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Southold

SINGLE_FAMILY - Other - Southold, NY

695 Rogers Rd, Southold, NY 11971

In-unit laundry | Carpet | Dishwasher

5 beds

2 baths

$12,000

House for rent

40 Stirling Cv - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

Condo for rent in Greenport

CONDOS - Greenport, NY

40 Stirling Cv, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor

2 beds

3 baths

$27,500

Condo for rent

4 Glynn Dr - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Shelter Island

SINGLE_FAMILY - Modern - Shelter Island, NY

4 Glynn Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Furnished | Swimming pool | Outdoor space

4 beds

3 baths

$30,000

House for rent

744 Main St #2 - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

Residential Rental, Traditional - Greenport, NY

744 Main St #2, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Hardwood floor

2 beds

2 baths

$3,400

House for rent

237 6th St - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

SINGLE_FAMILY - Other - Greenport, NY

237 6th St, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Hardwood floor

2 beds

2.5 baths

$16,000

House for rent

2905 Private Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in East Marion

SINGLE_FAMILY - Ranch - East Marion, NY

2905 Private Rd, East Marion, NY 11939

In-unit laundry | Air conditioning | Garage parking

4 beds

2.5 baths

$15,000

House for rent

Find sweet deals near Shelter Island Heights

These rentals are 10%-30% cheaper than the local average price for similar rentals.

$10,000

Southold

$9,500

Southold

$7,000

East Marion

$5,000

Greenport

3045 Rocky Point Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in East Marion

SINGLE_FAMILY - Ranch - East Marion, NY

3045 Rocky Point Rd, East Marion, NY 11939

In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor

3 beds

2 baths

$12,000

House for rent

165 Marine Pl - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

SINGLE_FAMILY - Modern - Greenport, NY

165 Marine Pl, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor

4 beds

4.5 baths

$20,000

House for rent

Advertisement
300 Fiddler Ln - Photo 1 of 1

23h ago

House for rent in Greenport

SINGLE_FAMILY - Colonial - Greenport, NY

300 Fiddler Ln, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | On-site laundry | Balcony

3 beds

4 baths

$16,000

House for rent

57305 Route 48 - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

SINGLE_FAMILY - Contemporary - Greenport, NY

57305 Route 48, Greenport, NY 11944

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Balcony

6 beds

5.5 baths

$39,000

House for rent

460 Bay Ave - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in East Marion

SINGLE_FAMILY - Craftsman - East Marion, NY

460 Bay Ave, East Marion, NY 11939

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Hardwood floor

3 beds

1.5 baths

$8,000

House for rent

1510 Maple Ln - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Greenport

SINGLE_FAMILY - Colonial - Greenport, NY

1510 Maple Ln, Greenport, NY 11944

Dishwasher

4 beds

3.5 baths

$16,000

House for rent

845 Budds Pond Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Southold

SINGLE_FAMILY - Contemporary - Southold, NY

845 Budds Pond Rd, Southold, NY 11971

In-unit laundry | High ceilings | Dishwasher

3 beds

2.5 baths

$5,900

House for rent

Listings within 10 miles
3825 S Harbor Rd - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Southold

SINGLE_FAMILY - Ranch - Southold, NY

3825 S Harbor Rd, Southold, NY 11971

In-unit laundry | Furnished | Hardwood floor

2 beds

1 bath

$3,500

House for rent

205 Pine Ave - Photo 1 of 1

5d+ ago

House for rent in Southold

SINGLE_FAMILY - Other - Southold, NY

205 Pine Ave, Southold, NY 11971

In-unit laundry | Garage parking | On-site laundry

3 beds

3 baths

$9,500

House for rent

Showing 1 - 25 of 25 results
Home > Apartments in Shelter Island Heights
Updated: April 30, 2026

Are you a rental professional?

Try our tenant screening, or post rental listings to Zumper, Craigslist Shelter Island Heights, and more.

Short-term rentals in Shelter Island Heights
Atlanta ApartmentsAustin ApartmentsBaltimore ApartmentsBoston ApartmentsCharlotte ApartmentsChicago ApartmentsDallas ApartmentsDenver ApartmentsDetroit ApartmentsHouston ApartmentsLas Vegas ApartmentsLos Angeles ApartmentsMiami ApartmentsMinneapolis ApartmentsNew York ApartmentsPhiladelphia ApartmentsPhoenix ApartmentsPittsburgh ApartmentsPortland ApartmentsSan Antonio ApartmentsSan Diego ApartmentsSan Francisco ApartmentsSeattle ApartmentsTampa ApartmentsWashington DC Apartments

Learn more about renting in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Methodology: How we got this data

Zumper’s proprietary rental data fuels our analysis. Rent and market trends, availability, neighborhood popularity, and lifestyle scores are all calculated using real-time and 2024 rental inventory and prices.

Our Lifestyle Categories ("great for eco-living," "great for social life," "great for pet owners," etc.) are determined by set criteria, against which we score each listing and its available features. At the neighborhood level, we calculate the listing count for each category to determine which lifestyles best fit each area.

Zumper, founded in 2012, is North America’s largest privately-owned rental platform, offering over 1 million listings across the U.S. and Canada. Stay informed on the latest trends and shifts in the rental market with our monthly National Rent Report, your go-to resource for key insights into the evolving rental landscape.

Apartment rentals Shelter Island Heights, NY FAQ

What is the average size of an apartment in Shelter Island Heights, NY?

The average size of a 1 bedroom apartment rental in Shelter Island Heights is 514 square feet. The average size of a 3 bedroom apartment rental in Shelter Island Heights is 2117 square feet.

Can I afford an apartment for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY?

To help you better understand how much rent you can afford, check out Zumper's rent calculator. Our rent calculator can help you learn more about Shelter Island Heights average rent prices.

Looking for apartments in Shelter Island Heights, NY near you?

🔑Available apartment rentals25
💰Best rent deal744 Main St #2
✨Popular amenities, ,
🧦In-unit laundry
🍽With dishwasher
🏠With photos
View full rental guide