Nearby rentals
Renter hub
Property management
Filters
Popular filters
Pets
Deals
Lifestyle
Zumper Expert Rating
Lease length
Price category
Specialty housing
Laundry
Amenities
Listing features
Square feet
Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY
The average rent in Shelter Island Heights, as of June 2026, is flat compared to last month but down 51.1% year-over-year.
Average rent
51%Track prices
Rent calculator
What can I afford?
Average rent
51%Track prices
Rent calculator
What can I afford?
All rentals
2d ago
Verified
4 beds
3 baths
$12,938
$12,780
Price drop
Apartment for rent
1d ago
House for rent in Sag Harbor
18 S Harbor Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
In-unit laundry | Furnished | Air conditioning
3 beds
3 baths
$35,000
House for rent
4d ago
House for rent in Shelter Island
56 N Menantic Rd #B, Shelter Island, NY 11964
In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Swimming pool
4 beds
4 baths
$40,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Shelter Island
23 Osprey Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
In-unit laundry | Garage parking | On-site laundry
4 beds
3.5 baths
$86,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Orient
420 Old Farm Rd, Orient, NY 11957
In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Swimming pool
4 beds
3.5 baths
$16,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Greenport
744 Main St #1, Greenport, NY 11944
In-unit laundry | Furnished | High ceilings
3 beds
2 baths
$8,000
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Greenport
1 bed
1 bath
$2,000
Apartment for rent
5d+ ago
Apartment for rent in Southold
55075 Route 25, Southold, NY 11971
In-unit laundry | Hardwood floor | Storage
1 bed
1 bath
$2,600
Apartment for rent
Be the first to hear about new listings matching your search.
5d+ ago
House for rent in East Marion
380 The Greenway, East Marion, NY 11939
In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Fireplace
3 beds
2 baths
$20,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Greenport
145 Sterling St, Greenport, NY 11944
In-unit laundry | Ceiling fan | Dishwasher
3 beds
4 baths
$5,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Shelter Island
6 Community Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
In-unit laundry | Furnished | Balcony
3 beds
1 bath
$12,000
House for rent
Available Jul 1
4d ago
House for rent in Sag Harbor
91 Sunset Beach Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Furnished | Swimming pool | Fireplace
4 beds
3 baths
$50,000
$25,000
Price drop
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Southold
2 beds
1 bath
$3,200
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Orient
W Bay Ave, Orient, NY 11957
In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Swimming pool
4 beds
3.5 baths
$25,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Greenport
56765 Route 48, Greenport, NY 11944
In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Swimming pool
3 beds
2 baths
$100,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in East Marion
11003 Main Rd, East Marion, NY 11939
Swimming pool | Hardwood floor | High ceilings
3 beds
2 baths
$15,000
House for rent
Find sweet deals near Shelter Island Heights
These rentals are 10%-30% cheaper than the local average price for similar rentals.
5d+ ago
Townhouse for rent in Shelter Island
4 beds
4 baths
$45,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Shelter Island
24 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
In-unit laundry | Balcony | Hardwood floor
3 beds
2 baths
$15,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Southold
3 beds
2 baths
$10,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
Condo for rent in Greenport
40 Stirling Cv, Greenport, NY 11944
In-unit laundry | Swimming pool | Hardwood floor
2 beds
3 baths
$23,500
Condo for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Shelter Island
4 Glynn Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Furnished | Swimming pool | Outdoor space
4 beds
3 baths
$12,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Greenport
237 6th St, Greenport, NY 11944
In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Hardwood floor
2 beds
2.5 baths
$14,000
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Southold
3825 S Harbor Rd, Southold, NY 11971
In-unit laundry | Furnished | Hardwood floor
2 beds
1 bath
$3,500
House for rent
5d+ ago
House for rent in Southold
16125 Soundview Ave, Southold, NY 11971
In-unit laundry | Garage parking | Swimming pool
4 beds
3.5 baths
$12,500
House for rent
4d ago
House for rent in Southold
2 beds
1.5 baths
$5,500
House for rent
Are you a rental professional?
Browse rentals in Shelter Island Heights by popular searches
We've got Homes and Apartments for Rent in Popular Cities.
13 rentals
71 rentals
11 rentals
17 rentals
9 rentals
11 rentals
21 rentals
10 rentals
63 rentals
29 rentals
6 rentals
5 rentals
88 rentals
4 rentals
17 rentals
6 rentals
11 rentals
7 rentals
Learn more about renting in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Methodology: How we got this data
Zumper’s proprietary rental data fuels our analysis. Rent and market trends, availability, neighborhood popularity, and lifestyle scores are all calculated using real-time and 2026 rental inventory and prices.
Our Lifestyle Categories ("great for eco-living," "great for social life," "great for pet owners," etc.) are determined by set criteria, against which we score each listing and its available features. At the neighborhood level, we calculate the listing count for each category to determine which lifestyles best fit each area.
Zumper, founded in 2012, is North America’s largest privately-owned rental platform, offering over 1 million listings across the U.S. and Canada. Stay informed on the latest trends and shifts in the rental market with our monthly National Rent Report, your go-to resource for key insights into the evolving rental landscape.
Apartment rentals Shelter Island Heights, NY FAQ
What is the average size of an apartment in Shelter Island Heights, NY?
The average size of a 2 bedroom apartment rental in Shelter Island Heights is 681 square feet. The average size of a 3 bedroom apartment rental in Shelter Island Heights is 2235 square feet.
Can I afford an apartment for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY?
To help you better understand how much rent you can afford, check out Zumper's rent calculator. Our rent calculator can help you learn more about Shelter Island Heights average rent prices.
Looking for apartments in Shelter Island Heights, NY near you?
| 🔑Available apartment rentals | 25 |
|---|---|
| 💰Best rent deal | 1000 9th St #D37 |
| ✨Popular amenities | , , |
| 🧦In-unit laundry | |
| 🍽With dishwasher | |
| 🏠With photos |