5+ Days Ago
Highlights
- Central location
- Walk-in closet
- Sunroom
- Two car garage
- Open plan living room
Location
5 Bay Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
Tour 5 Bay Rd
Contact
Nearby rentals
Renter hub
Property management
Apartments for rent East HamptonApartments for rent SouthamptonApartments for rent Sag HarborApartments for rent AmagansettApartments for rent New HavenApartments for rent Westhampton BeachApartments for rent West HavenApartments for rent BridgehamptonApartments for rent Water MillApartments for rent WaterburyApartments for rent Hampton BaysApartments for rent East QuogueApartments for rent WaterfordApartments for rent Fair Haven HeightsApartments for rent SagaponackApartments Near Me
Houses for rent Westhampton BeachHouses for rent SeymourHouses for rent Hampton BaysHouses for rent East HavenHouses for rent East HamptonHouses for rent New HavenHouses for rent WaterburyHouses for rent New LondonHouses for rent StratfordHouses for rent Milford cityHouses for rent RidgeHouses for rent WoodmontHouses for rent BranfordHouses for rent Beaver HillsHouses for rent NorwichHouses for rent near me
Property Overview
Featuring a central location and open plan living, this property offers notable amenities like a sunroom, walk-in closet, and two-car garage. With excellent value per square foot, it stands out in the market, while its proximity to local event hubs and transit options enhances its appeal for an active social life. The abundance of photos provides a comprehensive view, assisting prospective renters in their decision-making process.
This summary uses Zumper’s proprietary data. “Things you’ll love” and “Great for” are based on our internal analyses of market trends and renter insights.
Things you’ll love
More space- Images Available
Great for
Social life
Amenities for 5 Bay Rd
Apartment Amenities
| Baseboard | Central Air |
| Deck | Walk-in Closet |
Appliances
| Dishwasher | In-Unit Laundry |
Building
| Basement |
Grounds
| Garage Parking | Swimming Pool |
Other
| Architecture Style: Ranch | Nine Rooms |
Units, floor plans, amenities, dimensions, details, availability, and prices may be approximate and subject to change. Please contact a community representative for more information.
Policies and fees
Contact for more information on pet policy.
Advertisement
About 5 Bay Rd
Property Status: Active Open plan beach house with superb water views located in the highly sought after Montclair Colony. Centrally located near markets and many conveniences, there is much to adore in this home. Open plan living room with sunroom, dining and eat in kitchen. This home offers two bedrooms with two full baths and another bedroom with a full bath over the two car garage. In addition the master bedroom has a walk-in closet. Come see the private large deck, enclosed sunporch and gunite pool. Convenient to town beaches and other popular destinations. There is water access at the end of the street. August $25K September $13K Yr - $7K per month ($84K annual) Office Phone: (631) 725-0200 Copyright © 2025 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Property highlights
We compared every listing in the surrounding area to determine which amenities are most common. If a building lacks an amenity that most others in the area have, it is a con. If a building has an amenity most others in the area do not, it is a pro. Similarly, price, schools, and size are calculated relative to the size, price, and distance to schools of the other properties nearby.How 5 Bay Rd compares to other nearby properties.
Positives
- More space
- The 3-bedroom is 662 sqft larger than other listings nearby
- Images Available
- There are at least 10 photos of this address
Considerations
- Greater distance from grade schools
- The nearest elementary school is farther than 1 mile away
- Greater distance from high schools
- The nearest high school is farther than 4 miles away
Address details
| Zip code | 11964 |
|---|---|
| Type | House for rent |
Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere
Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.
Rent trends in Shelter Island
3-bedroom apartments at 5 Bay Rd cost about 50% less than the average rent price for 3-bedroom apartments in Shelter Island.
Median rents as of Jun 7 2025.
Shelter Island
| Month | Median Rent |
|---|---|
| June 2024 | $50,000 |
| February 2025 | $50,000 |
| March 2025 | $50,000 |
| April 2025 | $50,000 |
| May 2025 | $50,000 |
| June 2025 | $50,000 |
Affordability calculator
Can I afford to live at 5 Bay Rd?
Bedrooms
3 bedroomsRent-to-income ratio
30%
Slide to adjust the percentage of your monthly income you are willing to spend on rent.
The general rule of thumb is to spend around 30% or less of your income on rent.
Recommended income
$1,000,000/yr
With your selected rent-to-income ratio, you'd ideally want to make $1,000,000 annually to afford this 3-bedrooms monthly rent price of $25,000.
For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator.
Rent history
The increase or decrease in monthly rent compared to the previous listing price.| 6 months ago | $18,000 |
Schools near 5 Bay Rd
Shelter Island School
33 n ferry rd
shelter island, NY, 11964
PK, K-12Public
B+
Advertisement
Internet available near 5 Bay Rd
Neighborhood
NEIGHBORHOOD VIBE
Peaceful and quiet
Noise-canceling headphones not required in this mostly noise free area.
Getting around Shelter Island near 5 Bay Rd
Walking
2/10
You’ll need another mode of transportation for getting around. Scooter, anyone?
Driving
9/10
Commuting is easy with multiple accessible routes and plenty of parking.
Cycling
5/10
More spots are within biking distance and some roads are cyclist-friendly.
Points of interest for 5 Bay Rd, Shelter Island
Groceries
0/10
No grocery stores within walking distance
Shopping
2/10
Few or no shops within walking distance
Cafes
0/10
Few or no cafés within walking distance
Restaurants
2/10
Few or no restaurants within walking distance
Primary schools
1/10
No elementary schools within a 30-minute walk
High schools
1/10
No high schools within a 30-minute walk
Nightlife
1/10
Few or no bars within walking distance
Compare similar properties nearby
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
128 Water Mill Towd Rd, Southampton, NY, 11968
Our team has verified this company128 Water Mill Towd Rd
3 Beds
$17,500
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
22 Huckleberry Ln, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Our team has verified this company22 Huckleberry Ln
4 Beds
$30,000
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
22 Montauk Ave, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Our team has verified this company22 Montauk Ave
3 Beds
$17,500
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
128 Water Mill Towd Rd, Southampton, NY, 11968
Our team has verified this company128 Water Mill Towd Rd
3 Beds
$17,500
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
22 Huckleberry Ln, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Our team has verified this company22 Huckleberry Ln
4 Beds
$30,000
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
22 Montauk Ave, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Our team has verified this company22 Montauk Ave
3 Beds
$17,500
- swimming pool
- garage parking
- dogs and cats ok
Check availability
Advertisement