Houses for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY

This stunning new construction offers an exceptional 7,985 sq. ft. of living space on a serene 1.60+- acre lot. Featuring 7 bedrooms and 9.2 bathrooms, the home boasts a double-height foyer, expansive great room, and a grand primary suite with fireplace and spa-like bath. Enjoy outdoor living with a heated gunite pool, spa, and extensive decking. Complete with a 2-car garage and wellness spa, this modern traditional style townhouse is perfect for elegant entertaining and relaxation.

This stylish 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath townhouse built in 2012 features an open floor plan with a spacious kitchen, dining area, and living room. Enjoy the master suite with its own deck and bay views, plus access to a summer-ready patio with a gas grill. A convenient washer and dryer on the main floor enhances comfort. With a serene setting just outside Sag Harbor Village, this 2,000 sq ft home is perfect for those seeking a relaxing getaway.

Nestled in Sag Harbor's Redwood waterfront neighborhood, this exquisite 5-bed, 6-bath townhouse boasts a white castle-like facade and modern elegance. Enjoy a chef's kitchen with Sub Zero and Wolf appliances, a finished lower level for fitness, and a backyard oasis with a heated gunite pool and outdoor kitchen. Perfect for water sports enthusiasts, it's minutes from Sag Harbor Village's lively marinas, restaurants, and shops.

This stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath waterfront townhouse offers elegant furnishings, high ceilings, and floor-to-ceiling glass doors leading to a private deck with water views. The chef's kitchen features top-of-the-line Thermador appliances, while the primary suite includes a deck and luxury bathroom. Enjoy the community's amenities, including a pool, tennis, and a serene beach for kayaking. With smart home technology throughout, this property perfectly blends relaxation and sophistication.

This beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 3-bath townhouse offers the perfect Hamptons retreat in Bay Point. Enjoy an open-concept living space with cathedral ceilings, a gourmet kitchen, and a main-level primary suite. The lower level features a media lounge and wet bar for entertaining. Outside, the landscaped yard boasts a heated in-ground pool and outdoor shower, making it an ideal spot for summer enjoyment. Just minutes from Sag Harbor Village and Foster Memorial Beach.

This delightful 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath townhouse offers an inviting open living space and a cozy fireplace, perfect for relaxing after beach days. Enjoy morning laps in the 18 x 45 ft pool, or unwind in the beautifully fenced backyard featuring a fire pit and two dining patios. The lower level includes laundry and a fitness area. Ideal for summer living, with convenient bike access to Sag Harbor Village and nearby beaches. Experience the best of coastal living!

Enjoy tranquil waterfront living in this charming 2-bed, 2-bath cottage featuring stunning sunsets from your porch and patio. With a private dock for kayaking and boating, this cozy retreat offers an eat-in kitchen, spacious living room, and bonus office space. Just minutes from Sag Harbor Village, relish in the perfect blend of relaxation and summer fun by the water.

A beautifully renovated four-level townhouse features 5 bedrooms and 6.5 baths, blending historic charm with modern elegance. Enjoy a stylish layout including twin parlors and a large kitchen, plus a luxurious third-floor suite. The outdoor oasis boasts a heated gunite swimming pool, hot tub, and an elaborate terrace with barbecue and dining areas, perfect for entertaining. Experience the exceptional design in the heart of Sag Harbor Village!

This stunning 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home offers an ideal summer getaway, featuring an open floor plan and a private backyard with a heated in-ground pool. The spacious primary en-suite bedroom is conveniently located on the first floor. Perfect for entertaining, this 2,400 sq. ft. residence serves as a fantastic launch pad for exploring the beautiful beaches and vibrant dining options of The Hamptons. Enjoy an unforgettable stay and make lasting memories during the 2026 Shinnecock Hills US Open.

Indulge in a private spa experience at this stunning 2-bed, 2-bath home featuring a gunite pool, yoga deck, and sauna. Enjoy vaulted ceilings and stylish finishes in the primary suite. The fully fenced yard is ideal for pets and kids, while nearby beaches and shops offer convenience. Optional on-site services, including heated pool access and wellness therapies, elevate your Hamptons getaway. Experience ultimate relaxation just minutes from downtown Sag Harbor!

Experience total tranquility in this beautifully designed 3-bed, 3-bath Hamptons home set on 3.6 acres. The sun-filled interior features soaring ceilings and hardwood floors, flowing seamlessly to outdoor spaces perfect for entertaining. Enjoy your private pool and park-like lawn just minutes from Sag Harbor’s vibrant village and beaches. This turnkey escape is ideal for luxurious summer living, ensuring relaxation and fun in a serene setting.

This stunning expanded ranch blends modern elegance with Hamptons charm. Enjoy the spacious first-floor primary suite and bright eat-in kitchen with marble counters. A new heated gunite pool and access to a private beach association enhance outdoor living. The finished basement offers additional bedrooms and living space, making this 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home perfect for relaxation. Set on .43 acres, it features a beautiful backyard patio and a 2-car garage.

This stunning traditional-style home features approximately 5,500 SF of elegant living space, including 6 bedrooms and 6.5 baths. Enjoy a light-filled open layout with a cozy fireplace, a gourmet eat-in kitchen, and multiple en-suite bedrooms. The finished lower level boasts a media lounge and gym, while the beautifully landscaped yard features a heated gunite pool with a spa and outdoor lounge. Just a mile from Sag Harbor Village and the beach, this residence offers an ideal blend of luxury and convenience.

Experience an exquisite summer retreat in this newly furnished Cape Cod home featuring 4 spacious bedrooms, including 3 king suites with TVs. The main level boasts a stylish bar, cozy den, and modern kitchen, while the expansive backyard is perfect for relaxation with a heated pool and outdoor dining. Ideally located near Sag Harbor's shops and beaches, this pristine 2,323 sq ft residence offers effortless elegance and comfort for your unforgettable getaway.

Experience the charm of Sag Harbor in this spacious 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom home. Offering a generous layout and a prime location just moments from Main Street and waterfronts, this residence ensures the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Enjoy relaxing in the airy living room or the charming backyard, surrounded by mature landscaping. This home is a fantastic opportunity to embrace the vibrant local lifestyle year-round.

Experience the charm of Sag Harbor in this beautifully designed 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom home, offering 1,848 sq. ft. of modern elegance. Features include an expansive back deck for al fresco dining and a serene koi pond for relaxation. Gather around the fire pit for memorable summer nights. Just moments from stunning beaches and vibrant cultural hotspots, this property is the perfect setting for a luxurious summer getaway.

Experience coastal living in this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath beach cottage. Featuring an open floor plan filled with natural light, this 1,040 sq ft home seamlessly connects to a spacious deck and lush backyard, ideal for relaxation and entertaining. Nestled on a peaceful cul-de-sac, enjoy convenient access to bay beaches, community tennis courts, and playgrounds. Available for winter rental, this property offers the perfect blend of tranquility and prime location in scenic Sag Harbor.

This meticulously renovated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home spans 2,000 sq ft, embodying modern luxury and timeless elegance. A sunlit living area features a central fireplace and grand piano, inviting relaxation and entertainment. Step outside to manicured grounds with a shimmering heated pool, perfect for summer gatherings. Ideally located in the desirable Noyac area, this property blends a tranquil atmosphere with convenient access to Sag Harbor, Bridgehampton, and Southampton.

This stunning 4-bedroom, 3-bath home in the exclusive Bay Haven community offers 115 feet of private water frontage, complete with a dock for easy access to Sag Harbor Bay. An open-concept main floor welcomes natural light, showcasing breathtaking vistas from the living area and chef's kitchen. Unwind on the expansive deck or cozy fire pit area, and enjoy community amenities like a private beach and tennis courts, all just moments from Sag Harbor Village's vibrant charm.