Houses for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY

Sitting in Sag Harbor, NY, this 5-bed, 3.5-bath waterfront townhouse offers breathtaking views of Shelter Island and Sound in North Haven Shores community. Two living areas include one with panoramic water views, plus a private beach, dock, har-tru tennis court, and expansive deck for sunsets. Easy ferry access to Shelter Island.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this 2-bed, 2-bath waterfront townhouse offers direct water access with a private dock for kayaking and boating. The 1,092 sqft layout includes an eat-in kitchen, spacious living room, and covered porch for sunset dining. Rental includes 2 paddle boards and a kayak, with garage parking and minutes to Sag Harbor Village shops and dining.

Set in Sag Harbor, this 2-bed, 1.5-bath townhouse sits on a lush half-acre with a swimming pool and private gate access to Mashashimuet Park's tennis courts and trails. The 1,600 sqft post-and-beam layout features exposed wood beams, open-concept living with sliding doors to a rear deck, and a sleeping loft. Less than a mile from Main Street's shops and dining.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this fully furnished 3-bed, 2.5-bath waterfront townhouse offers 1,740 sqft with floor-to-ceiling French doors opening to a private water view deck. The chef's kitchen features Thermador appliances and wine cooler, while the primary suite includes its own deck overlooking Sag Harbor Cove. Smart home tech, pool, tennis court, and private beach access complete the package.

House with 3 beds in Sag Harbor, NY, this furnished coastal retreat offers water views and a heated saltwater pool with jacuzzi spa. The 1,625 sqft layout includes 3 full baths, high ceilings, a dedicated office, and finished basement entertainment area. Central air, outdoor BBQ space, and mature landscaping complete the setup, with kayaking and beaches nearby.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this thoughtfully designed 3-bed, 3-bath house blends modern style with classic Hamptons charm across 1,848 sqft. The layout features central air, an expansive back deck for al fresco dining, and a tranquil koi pond with fire pit area. Minutes from world-class dining, art galleries, and beautiful beaches.

House in Sag Harbor, NY, this 3-bed, 1-bath cottage sits on a quiet cul-de-sac with an open floor plan and hardwood floors throughout the 1,040 sqft layout. The spacious deck flows to a level backyard, while in-unit laundry and dishwasher add convenience. Steps from bay beaches, community tennis courts, and playground, with a grocery store just minutes away.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this 4-bed, 3-bath house sits in the waterfront Bay Point community just moments from Foster Memorial Beach. The 1,360 sqft layout features cathedral ceilings, a chef's kitchen with Bertazzoni range and quartz countertops, plus a heated in-ground pool and outdoor shower for entertaining.

This 6-bed, 3.5-bath Georgian house in Sag Harbor spans 3,509 sqft with restored hardwood floors and original millwork. The historic residence features a music room, two living salons, grand dining room, and primary suite with fireplace and soaking tub. A mahogany deck overlooks landscaped gardens with heated pool and BBQ station, steps from the marina and village dining.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this 5-bed, 4.5-bath townhouse sits in the gated West Banks community with private sandy beach access and deep water dock. The 5,600 sqft layout features a 2-story great room, chef's kitchen, primary suite with private balcony, and heated pool with jacuzzi. Lower level adds a theater, game room with billiards and ping pong - a fit for pet owners with 1.4 acres of outdoor space.

In Sag Harbor, NY, this furnished 4-bed, 3.5-bath townhouse sits on a private 1-acre cul-de-sac property. The 2,557 sqft layout features two primary suites on the first floor, a chef's kitchen with Sub-Zero appliances and Italian marble, plus a sunroom overlooking the heated gunite pool. A two-car heated garage and fire pit complete the setup.

3-bed townhouse in Sag Harbor, NY, sits waterfront on a quiet cul-de-sac with private dock and heated pool. The 1,567 sqft layout features water views from most rooms, open-concept living with fireplace, eat-in kitchen, and 2.5 baths. Enjoy evening sunsets from the expanded deck, plus paddleboard access and proximity to Morton National Wildlife Sanctuary and Long Beach.

A townhouse in Sag Harbor, NY, this 4-bed, 2.5-bath property sits less than half a mile from Long Beach. The 2,500 sqft layout features a chef's kitchen, formal dining area, living room with fireplace, and finished basement playroom. Central air and a heated gunite pool with expansive decking make it ideal for entertaining, with easy access to Sag Harbor Village dining and shops.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this 6-bed, 6.5-bath townhouse offers endless waterfront vistas and iconic sunsets over Peconic Bay. The 5,000 sqft layout features an open-concept main floor with oversized eat-in kitchen, sunken living room, and extra-large primary suite. A second primary suite with private deck, heated gunite pool, and private boat launch complete the waterfront lifestyle.

Townhouse with 4 beds in Sag Harbor, NY, offering 90+ feet of water frontage on a quiet cul-de-sac. This 3,500 sqft retreat features maple floors, custom built-ins, and a complete sound system across light-filled spaces including a living room with fireplace and eat-in kitchen overlooking the cove. A heated gunite pool with waterfall and expansive decking complete the waterfront setting.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this contemporary 4-bed, 5.5-bath house sits on 0.70 acres with a 50-foot heated saltwater pool and expansive outdoor entertaining spaces. The three-level layout features hardwood floors, a wood-burning fireplace, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow to dining terraces. Six parking spaces and top-rated schools within 0.3 miles complete the package.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this colonial-style 4-bed, 4-bath house sits on a quiet cul-de-sac just 2 miles from Sag Harbor Village. The 2,828 sqft layout features a chef's kitchen with Viking appliances, primary suite with office and balcony, plus a finished basement den with Peloton. The private fenced yard includes a heated pool, sunken hot tub, fire pit, and Ipe wood deck.

Sitting in Sag Harbor, NY, this 4-bed, 3-bath house offers 2,400 sqft with an open floor plan and primary suite on the first floor. The heated in-ground pool and private backyard create an ideal entertaining space, while hardwood floors, central air, and in-unit laundry add comfort. Perfect launch pad for exploring Southampton, Bridgehampton, and Hamptons beaches and dining.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this modern 2-bed, 2-bath house offers a private spa experience with gunite pool, yoga deck, and sauna in a fully fenced backyard. The 2,197 sqft layout features vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors, and a primary suite with steam shower. Less than a mile from Noyac Bay beach access and under 2 miles to Foster Memorial Beach.

Set in Sag Harbor, NY, this furnished 3-bed, 3-bath house sits on a private gated 3.6-acre estate with resort-style pool and outdoor entertaining spaces. The 1,904 sqft layout features soaring ceilings, hardwood floors, and French doors opening to expansive grounds with mature trees and park-like lawns. A finished basement adds extra living space, while the tranquil setting offers complete privacy just minutes from Sag Harbor Village marinas, beaches, and dining.

4-bed house in Sag Harbor, NY, this Cape Cod-style home offers 2,323 sqft with a heated pool and private backyard. The furnished layout includes 3 baths, a modern kitchen, formal dining room, and primary suite with soaking tub. Available for 2-week rentals, it sits minutes from Sag Harbor Village shops and beaches.

A house in Sag Harbor, NY, this recently renovated 3-bed, 2.5-bath property sits on a quiet lane in the Noyac area between Sag Harbor, Bridgehampton, and Southampton. The 2,000 sqft layout features hardwood floors, high ceilings, central fireplace, and in-unit laundry. A heated pool and manicured grounds create an ideal outdoor space, with a grocery store just 0.1 miles away.