Houses for Rent in Cutchogue, NY

This move-in-ready, fully furnished 3-bedroom, 1-bath home features a bright and clean interior, perfect for easy living. Nestled conveniently on Main Road, it offers close proximity to all the North Fork delights. This well-kept residence is ideal for anyone looking for a simple yet comfortable lifestyle in a desirable hamlet setting. Enjoy the charm and convenience of year-round living in this cozy rental, complete with thoughtful amenities.

Enjoy a private 4-bedroom, 2-bath contemporary home set on over an acre of lush land with elegant interiors and a warm ambiance. Features include a sleek main floor with a fireplace, a bright kitchen, and a furnished 2-level deck. The lower level boasts a fun entertaining area with air hockey and a large TV. Outdoor delights include a heated saltwater pool, jacuzzi spa, and an outdoor BBQ pavilion. Perfect for those seeking a serene getaway just steps from the beach and local attractions.

This bright and airy contemporary farmhouse features 2+ bedrooms and 2.5 baths across 1,850 sq ft. Enjoy an open floor plan with a large living room, eat-in kitchen, and bonus room. The upstairs owner's suite offers privacy with its own bath, complemented by an additional bedroom and loft. Outside, entertain under the pergola in a spacious yard, all just steps from the charming village and nearby beaches. Unfurnished and ready for your personal touch!

This charming 1,600 sq ft waterfront cottage offers a gourmet chef's kitchen, open-plan living, and built-in closets in all 3 bedrooms plus a studio/extra bedroom. A new pool liner and Anderson windows enhance this serene retreat. Enjoy an in-ground pool, wood-burning stove, and access to a canoe and BBQ. Nestled near iconic beaches, Michelin-star restaurants, and award-winning vineyards—welcome to North Fork relaxation!

Embrace peaceful living in this charming one-bedroom waterfront cottage, featuring breathtaking views of the North Fork. Launch your kayak right from the backyard or stroll to the nearby sandy association beach. Enjoy the cozy cottage atmosphere enhanced by modern comforts, perfect for quiet getaways or memorable summer days by the water. This delightful retreat is a rare find, blending relaxation with scenic beauty.

This year-round, fully furnished designer home offers 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms within a spacious 2,000 sq ft layout. The open-concept design features high-end furnishings and large windows, bringing in natural light and beauty from the surrounding arboretum-like setting. Enjoy a modern kitchen, cozy living spaces, and an owner's suite with an en-suite bath. Conveniently located near North Fork's wineries, beaches, farms, and shops, this retreat combines style and comfort in a sought-after community.

This charming 3-bedroom, 3-bath home offers a serene year-round rental experience overlooking Wunneweta Pond. Set on a private 1.3-acre lot, it provides tranquility and natural beauty throughout the seasons. Enjoy dock space for your boat or kayak, plus exclusive association beach rights for swimming and sunset strolls along the shore. Ideal for those seeking peace and privacy in one of Long Island's most picturesque locations.

Experience unparalleled privacy in this beautifully reimagined modern ranch, featuring 4 bedrooms and 4 baths across 2,400 sq ft. Enjoy gourmet cooking with high-end appliances in a bright, airy kitchen, relax by the fireplace, or venture outside to expansive gardens and a heated pool. Ideal for entertaining, the finished basement, large screened porch, and fire pit create perfect spaces for family gatherings. Located near local attractions, including beaches and wineries, this home is a true haven.

Enjoy the perfect summer escape in this charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home featuring an in-ground pool and hardwood floors across 1,800 sq ft. Located close to the beach, vibrant business district, picturesque vineyards, and top-notch dining, this property offers everything for a relaxing getaway. Minimum two-week stay required.

Experience serene living in this 2,200 sq. ft. mid-century modern home situated on 1.3 acres in Nassau Point. Boasting ample natural light, an EIK, and a wraparound deck, this property is perfect for relaxation and entertaining. It features a spacious family room, three bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and exclusive access to Nassau Point beach. Enjoy luxurious privacy with convenient amenities on the scenic North Fork. Available for summer rentals.

Experience the best of North Fork living in this beautifully renovated 5-bed, 4-bath colonial home featuring a stunning great room, gourmet chef’s kitchen, and spacious primary suite with bay views. Unwind outdoors with a heated pool, hot tub, and stone fireplace. With game and playrooms, elegant spaces, and access to private association beaches, this home promises unforgettable summer moments. Available July 7-August 10.

This perfectly situated summer cottage offers easy access to the serene Pequash Beach and two additional bay beaches within walking distance. Nestled in the quiet Fleet's Neck area, this well-maintained 2-bed, 2-bath Ranch-style home provides a tranquil retreat for your summer or short-term off-season getaway. Enjoy air-conditioned comfort and flexible rental terms throughout your stay.