Houses for Rent in New Suffolk, NY

Set in New Suffolk, NY, this 4-bed, 2.5-bath townhouse sits just three blocks from sandy beaches and historic restaurants on the North Fork. The light-filled interior features high ceilings and a renovated kitchen, while the backyard adds a dining patio, outdoor shower, and gas grill. Central air and a welcoming front porch complete the layout, with a top-rated elementary school just steps away.

In New Suffolk, NY, this 3-bed, 2-bath house sits one block from a sandy bay beach with sweeping water views from a spacious second-story deck. The 1,600 sqft layout features hardwood floors, central air, high ceilings, and a bright eat-in kitchen designed for entertaining. A renovated first-floor bedroom and secondary living room provide flexible space for guests or remote work, with waterfront dining just a block away.

Set in New Suffolk, NY, this colonial-style 4-bed, 3.5-bath house offers 1,600 sqft of waterfront community living. The gourmet kitchen flows into bright living areas with floor-to-ceiling windows, while the backyard features an in-ground heated pool and bluestone patio with pool house. Walk to local restaurants like Minnow and Peeko Oysters, with a top-rated elementary school just steps away.

Located in New Suffolk, NY, this updated 19th century 3-bed, 2-bath townhouse sits moments from one of the North Fork's best bay beaches. Original hardwood floors and antique details blend with modern touches like central air and an eat-in kitchen. The wrap-around porch and spacious backyard add outdoor appeal, with a top-rated elementary school just steps away.

House in New Suffolk, NY, this refreshed 2-bed, 2-bath ranch cottage offers 1,550 sqft of coastal charm with high ceilings and central air. The light-filled interior features an updated kitchen and flowing layout designed for relaxed living. Step outside to enjoy outdoor space in this peaceful setting, just moments from New Suffolk's sandy Sound beach and close to Legends Restaurant and local vineyards.

Right in New Suffolk, NY, this traditional 4-bed, 2-bath house offers 2,000 sqft of coastal living just moments from the beach and waterfront restaurants. Bright interiors feature comfortable living spaces, in-unit laundry, dishwasher, and a basement for extra storage. The prime location puts North Fork dining and village amenities within easy reach.

This 1,500 square-foot house in New Suffolk, NY includes 3-bed, 2-bath accommodations with water views and hardwood floors throughout. The cedar-frame house features central air, natural gas heating, and a back deck with yard space for entertaining. Located minutes from New Suffolk Beach, marina, local restaurants, wineries, and golf courses.

Located in New Suffolk, NY, this renovated 1-bed, 1-bath townhouse sits just two blocks from a sandy bay beach. The 470 sqft cottage features a completely renovated bathroom, spacious eat-in kitchen with full-size appliances, and furnished brick patio with gas grill. Available seasonally in the heart of North Fork wine country.