Quick Answer: To make a landlord choose you, arrive first, bring complete documentation, offer to sign a longer lease or pay rent upfront, get strong references from previous landlords, and address any credit concerns proactively.
So, you’ve found the perfect apartment. You’ve even verified that the landlord exhibits all the qualities of being a great landlord. Now, the only thing left to worry about is competing against other interested renters.
How will you ensure that the landlord chooses you over the other competition? Having a strong credit score and a solid rental history is the easiest way to convince landlords that you’re the best applicant. But what if you have bad credit or an imperfect rental history? We’ll break down what you can do to make up for those points and get yourself to the top of the list.
Why do property owners pass on certain applicants?
Property owners will often pass on rental applications that include red flags such as inconsistent employment, past evictions, income that is well below, or incomplete paperwork. Knowing these pitfalls lets you address weak spots head-on and present yourself as a low-risk, reliable tenant from the start.
How do you stand out as the best tenant candidate?
Competition in the rental market can make or break your search experience. Follow these steps to stand out from other applicants and ensure your landlord chooses you.
- Offer to sign a longer lease than a year.
- Improve your credit score, or show that you’re working to improve it.
- Bring in references, especially if your credit score or financial situation is less than ideal, and be ready to provide an explanation.
- Schedule viewings right away, and be early. Show you are ready to move quickly.
- Have all your paperwork organized, on hand, and ready to go as soon as you view the apartment.
- Make sure you have a plan to meet the minimum income requirement, if you don’t already.
- Bring your A-game to the viewing—first impressions matter.
Below, we’ll go into common questions for each, and why they matter.
What are the benefits of offering a longer lease?
Offering to sign a longer lease can show the landlord you’re willing to pay rent consistently for an extended period, so they will likely experience less turnover. It shows you’re serious about the apartment.
Another powerful strategy is offering advance rent payments. When you can financially swing it, propose paying two or three months upfront. Doing so demonstrates financial stability and removes cash flow concerns. Property managers face fewer risks when they know rent is already secured, giving them a significant edge over other candidates who meet only basic requirements.
How can you boost your credit profile fast?
Begin by obtaining a copy of your credit report from all three major credit bureaus: TransUnion, Experian, and Equifax. Review it for any errors, discrepancies, or fraudulent activity. Disputing and rectifying inaccuracies can quickly boost your score.
Payment punctuality matters more than anything else on your credit file. Configure automated payments for every recurring bill—rent, utilities, credit cards, loans—so you never accidentally miss deadlines. Even one or two on-time payments before applying can start shifting your score upward.
A lower ratio between your credit card balance and your credit limit (meaning, you have a high balance that comes close to your limit) can negatively impact your credit score. A good rule of thumb is to keep your credit balance below 30% of your limit. Pay down outstanding balances, starting with high-interest cards first. If you have outstanding debts that have gone to collections, work on settling or negotiating payment plans with creditors. A paid collection is better for your credit than an unpaid one.
What screening processes should you prepare for?
Property owners run several verification checks before finalizing any lease agreement. Expect them to examine your rental background check, credit history, and employment details with proof of income documentation.
One way to help you pass a rental background check is to get references from past landlords. It can be beneficial if you’ve ever dealt with an eviction before. Having one previous landlord vouch for you can make a big difference.
If your credit score isn’t great or your rental history isn’t spotless, proactively explaining why and emphasizing the steps you’ve taken to improve or stabilize your situation can help you communicate trustworthiness. Honest communication often outweighs a mediocre number, especially when paired with strong references and steady income proof. Remember, even if you have a low credit score, there are other strategies you can employ before you search for no-credit-check apartments.
For self-employed individuals or those juggling multiple income streams, gather detailed documentation. Provide contact information for all clients or employers who can verify your work. If your income seems borderline for the property’s requirements, bringing in a financially qualified co-signer—whether a parent, trusted friend, or family member—can seal the deal.
Why does timing matter in apartment applications?
Speed wins in competitive rental markets. The moment a desirable unit hits the market, qualified applicants flood in. Scheduling viewings immediately after listings go live puts you ahead of the pack.
Arriving early to scheduled tours signals professionalism and genuine interest. Property managers notice applicants who treat viewings like business meetings. This small gesture separates serious renters from casual browsers, often influencing final selection when multiple qualified candidates compete for the same space.
What paperwork should you bring to apartment viewings?
Bring all the application paperwork you might need to your apartment viewing. If the property management company sent you the application or other required forms beforehand, or posted them on their website, print them and fill them out before the viewing. It can also help to bring your rental references, recommendations from previous landlords, employers, or anyone who can speak to your reliability. Your pay stubs or a letter from your employer can also go a long way toward proving employment. Using this sample rental reference template makes the process easier for your references while ensuring landlords receive comprehensive endorsements.
Many apartments require you to apply online now, so it can also be helpful to keep all of this in a Google Drive you can use to apply immediately upon viewing.
How do you calculate realistic rental budgets?
To calculate how much you can afford on rent, start with the 30% rule: no more than 30% of your pre-tax monthly income should be spent on rent. If you make $5,000 per month, your monthly rental budget is $1,500.
This is a good starting point, but you should also factor in utilities, debt, and other expenses, and other savings goals. Use our rent calculator to help you determine your realistic rental budget.
That way, if the landlord asks about your budget, you’ll have an answer. If you’re planning to split rent and live with a roommate, make sure your future landlord knows—two incomes are better than one.
Why do manners influence landlord decisions?
First impressions matter. Being late to an apartment showing can be a turn-off for a potential landlord. Always remember to be punctual and thank the landlord for taking time out of their day to show the unit. Property managers want to rent to responsible renters, so coming prepared with questions, paperwork, and a good attitude can help them feel confident in you as a great potential tenant.
What happens after your application gets accepted?
Securing approval feels fantastic, but don’t rush into signing anything immediately. Take time to review lease terms and ask critical questions thoroughly. Don’t forget to ask the important questions.
Finding your ideal rental takes patience. Rejection happens even to well-qualified applicants in hot markets. Stay persistent, maintain your professional approach at every viewing, and keep all documentation up to date and ready. When you discover the right unit at the right price, you’ll be positioned to move quickly and secure it.
You should also look for landlords who answer your questions transparently throughout the application process. If they can do so, they’re likely easier to work with during your time as a tenant. If a property owner dodges inquiries or seems evasive about building conditions, policies, or lease details, trust your instincts. Walking away from questionable situations protects you from future headaches. Plenty of legitimate properties exist with responsive, honest management—hold out for the right match rather than settling for red flags.
What should you do if your rental application gets rejected?
Rejection stings, but it’s rarely personal, and it doesn’t mean your apartment search is over.
The first step is understanding why you didn’t get selected. Reach out to the landlord or property management to politely ask for their feedback. Oftentimes, they’ll share whether they passed on your application because of credit or income concerns, incomplete documentation, or simply because another applicant offered better terms. This information is invaluable for strengthening your next application.
If credit was the issue, focus on the improvement strategies mentioned earlier: dispute errors, pay down balances, and set up automatic payments. Even minor improvements over 30-60 days can make a difference in your next application.
If income is the concern, consider expanding your search to lower-priced units, finding a roommate to split costs, or securing a co-signer who meets the income requirements.
Documentation problems are the easiest to fix. Create a comprehensive application packet that includes recent pay stubs, bank statements, employer contact information, previous landlord references, and government-issued ID. Keep digital and physical copies organized so you can submit complete applications immediately when you find properties you love.
Sometimes you’ll lose out simply because someone else moved faster, offered more money upfront, or had a stronger application. Don’t take it personally.
If you’re getting rejected over and over, try expanding your search. Look at different neighborhoods, consider slightly different amenities, or adjust your move-in timeline. Stay persistent, keep your application materials up to date, and maintain a positive attitude.
Frequently asked questions about winning competitive rental applications
How competitive is the rental market?
Rental market competitiveness depends on the market and sometimes on the time of year. For example, New York City is an extremely competitive rental market. It’s common for an available unit to be rented within the same day it’s listed, with multiple applications on the table. Other, less saturated markets will have a grace period to get in the door. If you are in the market for a new apartment, staying up to date on the latest trends in your area can help you establish a timeline for when to begin your search.
Do personal references help when renting?
Absolutely. Providing personal references for an apartment can speak to your value and responsibility as a renter. If there are multiple applicants, an excellent recommendation can put your application at the top of the list. If you have a previous employer or past landlord who can vouch for your character and responsibility, potential landlords will take notice.
How long does it take to hear back after submitting a rental application?
Waiting is the hardest part. Typically, you should hear back from a potential landlord or property manager within 24-72 hours of submitting your application. If it’s been 3 days and you still haven’t heard back, a courteous follow-up email is encouraged.
How do you write a strong rental application cover letter?
A compelling rental cover letter shows the person behind the numbers. It humanizes you to the landlord or property management company.
Start with a brief, friendly greeting, then explain why you’re interested in their property. Highlight any stable employment, reliable income, and positive rental history. If you have any credit concerns or gaps in your rental history, address them honestly and briefly explain the circumstances and how you’ve resolved them. Mention your moving-in timeline and emphasize your qualities as a responsible, respectful tenant. Keep it to one page and proofread carefully. A well-written cover letter can help a landlord when choosing between candidates with similar financials.
What income-to-rent ratio do most landlords require?
Most landlords follow the standard requirement that your gross monthly income (pre-tax) should be at least three times the cost of rent each month. Meaning, if you apply for an apartment that costs $1,500 per month, you’ll need to show that you make at least $4,500 per month, or $54,000 annually. Some competitive markets or luxury properties may require even higher ratios, such as 3.5 or 4 times the rent.
If you make less than 3x the income, you have options: provide a co-signer who meets the income requirements, offer a larger security deposit, prepay several months of rent, or provide additional proof of assets like savings accounts. Landlords implement these ratios to ensure tenants can comfortably afford rent while covering other living expenses, reducing the risk of late payments or defaults.
Ready to make your move? Check out thousands of apartments for rent on Zumper and find the one that works for you.
Related content
