Zumper
modified
3 Minutes Ago

Highlights

  • Pet Friendly
  • Stainless-steel appliances
  • Hardwood flooring
  • Quaint community
  • Recently remodeled
  • Expansive green courtyards
  • Outdoor adventure

Location

35 South Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, New York 11706, United States|Bay Shore
Hi! Let’s figure out if this property is right for you.

Powered by Zumper AI

Tour Mid Island Apartments

Contact

Management

Eagle Rock Properties

Leasing office

(844) 325-9308 ext. 6982

Open 

9:00 am–5:30 pm ET

Property Overview

Mid Island Apartments excels with an impressive Zumper expert rating of 9.4, backed by perfect scores for price and amenities, indicating excellent value for residents. Its excellent location rating of 9 out of 10 ensures easy access to schools, transportation, and attractions, enhancing the overall living experience. Additionally, the property features stainless-steel appliances, hardwood flooring, and expansive green courtyards, all contributing to a welcoming and pet-friendly environment.

This summary uses Zumper’s proprietary data. “Zumper Expert Ratings,” “Things you’ll love,” and “Great for” are based on our internal analyses of market trends and renter insights.

Zumper Expert Rating

9.4
Excellent
Mid Island Apartments is an excellent find, offering residents a superior living experience with a wide range of desirable features. Residents will particularly enjoy knowing that this property rated highest in Price and Amenities, which help to make this rental a great place to call home.

Things you’ll love

  • Less expensive
  • Middle school nearby
  • Dishwasher

Great for

  • Pet owners

Floor plans

S1Studio1 bath400 sqft$1,810–$2,110 /mo2 units available
A11 bed1 bath665 sqft$2,390–$2,485 /mo4 units available
A21 bed1 bath705 sqft$2,395–$2,510 /mo6 units available
B32 bed1 bath870 sqft$2,695 /mo1 unit available
B22 bed1 bath840 sqft$2,740 /mo1 unit available
B12 bed1 bath820 sqft$2,805–$2,835 /mo2 units available

Let's explore this property.

Amenities for Mid Island Apartments

Apartment Amenities

Air ConditioningBacksplash
Hardwood FloorIn Unit Dryer
Quartz & Granite CounterWood or High-end Tile Flooring Throughout Living Spaces

Appliances

DishwasherIn Unit Washer
In-Unit LaundryRange

Tech

High-Speed Internet

Building

Cats OKDogs OK
Newly Renovated Apartment Homes (In Select Apartment Homes)Onsite Laundry
Smoke-free

Grounds

Open Lot ParkingOutdoor Space
Playground

Services

On-Site MaintenanceOn-Site Management

Other

Short Term Lease
Units, floor plans, amenities, dimensions, details, availability, and prices may be approximate and subject to change. Please contact a community representative for more information.

Policies and fees

Applicants

Application Fee

One-time. Agent application fee.

Contact Property

REQUIRED FEES

Security Deposit

One-time.

Contact Property

OPTIONAL FEES

Dog Policy

Allowed
Limit2
Breed restrictionsYes

Breed Restrictions Apply. Please visit the website to view our Pet Policy.

Cat Policy

Allowed
Limit2

Cat

Pet Rent

Monthly. 2 cats max.

$50

Pet Fee

One-time fee per pet.

$200

Pet Deposit

One-time deposit per pet.

$0

Dog

Pet Rent

Monthly. 2 dogs max.

$50

Pet Fee

One-time fee per pet.

$250

Pet Deposit

One-time deposit per pet.

$0

Questions about this property’s policies and fees?

Building details

Property details

Year built1965
Units232
Advertisement

About Mid Island Apartments

HomeApartments in Bay Shore Mid Island Apartments

Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring, and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops, and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments.


Year Built: 1965

Zumper Expert Rating

Our expert rating is based on a weighted average score of property attributes that renters care about most: price, amenities, location, quality, and trust.
9.4
/10
Excellent
Mid Island Apartments is an excellent find, offering residents a superior living experience with a wide range of desirable features. Residents will particularly enjoy knowing that this property rated highest in Price and Amenities, which help to make this rental a great place to call home.
How we rated Mid Island Apartments
Price·10A score that weighs the cost and location of the property, which we calculate by comparing rent prices of recent units to the median price of nearby rentals, adjusting for overall quality and features.
Mid Island Apartments offers an excellent balance between price and value. It's priced competitively for its amenities, location, and other key features. Compared to the median price per bedroom in the area, this property is less than, or about the same as, nearby rentals, so residents can expect great value without too many compromises on their desired standard of living.
Amenities·10A score based on the amenities offered at this property compared to other rentals in the area. We consider the quantity, quality, and popularity of features both on site and within the units.
Mid Island Apartments stands out as a premier property with an impressive array of amenities and an excellent standard of living. Residents here have access to many of the most popular and desired perks—pets allowed—making this one of the top choices for renters seeking unparalleled comfort and convenience.
Location·9A score based on proximity and ease of access to shops, restaurants, schools, and public transportation while considering the desirability of the area.
Mid Island Apartments is exceptional when it comes to location and conveniences. Communication with management or leasing staff is usually quick and easy and they often use advanced scheduling and communication tools to streamline the process. The location of this property offers easy access to popular points of interest in the area and options for getting around.
Quality·9A score based on what makes the property stand out, such as luxury features, unique offerings, age of the building, and our ability to verify the accuracy of these details.
Mid Island Apartments has a few standout characteristics that set it apart from similar properties nearby. Having both verified status and features that cater to discerning renters, this is a great option for renters looking for a specific and exceptional lifestyle.
Trustworthiness·8A score based on the accuracy, completeness, recency, and usefulness of the information provided by this property, so you can trust that what you see is what you get.
The level of transparency this property provides distinguishes it as a great rental. With a high attention to detail and desirable features, renters can be sure they will get an accurate picture of their potential new home.

Reviews from the web

Showing 8 highest rated

Recently moved in and I have no serious complaints thus far. Well kept grounds are nice and it’s a relatively quiet location even while being in close proximity to the hospital and train (obviously within reason). Rob the superintendent specifically has been a huge part of why this process has been so pleasant and has continuously gone above and beyond to make my move comfortable. He is very quick to assist with any of my needs and is always a pleasure to speak with to! Same to Analia in the leasing office!

Chloë Ambroise

Chloë Ambroise

Aug 28, 2024

Rob has been SO incredibly helpful. He is very kind and easy to work with. If you ever need anything, Rob is the one to call! We have been living here for over 5 years and we love it! 5 stars 🌟

Nanci Horrocks

Nanci Horrocks

Nov 15, 2024

We’re sharing just 8 of many, sorted highest to lowest. Visit the Google business profile to view all reviews.

Mid Island Apartments is great for:

Pet owners

  • Outdoor spaces are available at this property
  • 4 pet hospitals in the area
  • 3 pet grooming services nearby
  • 11 pet supply stores near the property

Property highlights

We compared every listing in the surrounding area to determine which amenities are most common. If a building lacks an amenity that most others in the area have, it is a con. If a building has an amenity most others in the area do not, it is a pro. Similarly, price, schools, and size are calculated relative to the size, price, and distance to schools of the other properties nearby.

How Mid Island Apartments compares to other nearby properties.

Positives

Less expensive
Studio units are cheaper than other similar listings nearby
Less expensive
The 1-bedrooms are cheaper than other similar listings nearby
Less expensive
The 2-bedrooms are cheaper than other similar listings nearby
Middle school nearby
There is a middle school 1 mile away
Dishwasher
Dishwasher available in kitchen
Images Available
There are at least 10 photos of this address
Laundry available on site
Washers and dryers are available in-building or in-unit
Outdoor space
Easy access to the outdoors
Pet friendly
This property allows pets

Considerations

Greater distance from high schools
The nearest high school is farther than 1 mile away

Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere

Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.
Email*
By clicking submit, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values.

Rent trends in Bay Shore

Studio apartments at Mid Island Apartments cost about 22% less than the average rent price for studios in Bay Shore.

1-bedroom apartments here are priced 4% lower than 1-bedrooms in Bay Shore.

If you decide to upgrade your space, you can expect 2-bedrooms at Mid Island Apartments to be 1% less than the average for similarly sized apartments in Bay Shore.

Median rents as of Nov 15 2025.
Bay Shore
Bay Shore
A table of studio rental data trends in Bay Shore
MonthMedian Rent
December 2023$2,300
January 2024$2,419
February 2024$2,325
March 2024$2,337
April 2024$2,419
May 2024$2,400
June 2024$2,400
July 2024$2,327
August 2024$2,254
September 2024$2,320
October 2024$2,255
November 2024$2,250
December 2024$2,319
January 2025$2,272
February 2025$2,316
March 2025$2,239
April 2025$2,257
May 2025$2,320
June 2025$2,250
July 2025$2,290
August 2025$2,258
September 2025$2,290
October 2025$2,262
November 2025$2,112
A table of studio rental data trends in Bay Shore
MonthMedian Rent
December 2023$2,300
January 2024$2,419
February 2024$2,325
March 2024$2,337
April 2024$2,419
May 2024$2,400
June 2024$2,400
July 2024$2,327
August 2024$2,254
September 2024$2,320
October 2024$2,255
November 2024$2,250
December 2024$2,319
January 2025$2,272
February 2025$2,316
March 2025$2,239
April 2025$2,257
May 2025$2,320
June 2025$2,250
July 2025$2,290
September 2025$2,308

Affordability calculator

Can I afford to live at 35 South Penataquit Avenue?

Bedrooms

Rent-to-income ratio

30%

Slide to adjust the percentage of your monthly income you are willing to spend on rent.
The general rule of thumb is to spend around 30% or less of your income on rent.
Recommended income

$72,400/yr

With your selected rent-to-income ratio, you'd ideally want to make $72,400 annually to afford this studio monthly rent price of $1,810.
For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator.

Schools near Mid Island Apartments

Brook Avenue Elementary School

45 brook ave

bay shore, NY, 11706

K-2Public
A

South Country School

885 hampshire rd

bay shore, NY, 11706

3-5Public
B
Powered byniche.com
Advertisement

Internet available near Mid Island Apartments

Getting around Bay Shore near 35 South Penataquit Avenue

Walking

6/10
Grab your reusable bags–many shops and stores are within walking distance.

Driving

6/10
This area is close to freeways and has adequate parking options.

Transit

3/10
There are a few mass transit options within the area.

Points of interest for 35 South Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore

Groceries

7/10
At least one grocery store within a 15-minute walk

Shopping

6/10
Variety of shops within walking distance

Cafes

4/10
Few or no cafés within walking distance

Restaurants

5/10
Some restaurants within walking distance

Primary schools

7/10
At least one elementary school within a 20-minute walk

High schools

3/10
No high schools within a 30-minute walk

Nightlife

3/10
Few or no bars within walking distance

Explore the area around 35 South Penataquit Avenue

Stop & Shop Supermarket
533 E Main St
ALDI
1851 Sunrise Hwy
ShopRite of Bay Shore
1905 Sunrise Hwy
Frank & Marie Itialian Market
10 W Main St
Lins Food Court
1701 Sunrise Hwy

Compare similar properties nearby

featured image of 156 E Pulaski Rd

Eagle Rock Apartments at Huntington Station

Our team has verified this company

Huntington Station • 156 E Pulaski Rd

2–3 Beds

$2,685–$3,080

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 1710 Devonshire Rd

Renaissance Hills

Our team has verified this company

Hauppauge • 1710 Devonshire Rd

1–3 Beds

$2,550–$3,950

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
No
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 725 Eastview Dr

The Villas on Eastview

Central Islip • 725 Eastview Dr

2 Beds

$3,300–$3,700

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 1700 E 5th St

Avalon Huntington Station

Our team has verified this company

Huntington Station • 1700 E 5th St

1–2 Beds

$3,090–$3,707

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 100 Court North Dr

Avalon Melville

Our team has verified this company

Melville • 100 Court North Dr

1–2 Beds

$3,390–$3,860

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 313 Avalon Cir

Avalon Commons

Our team has verified this company

Nesconset • 313 Avalon Cir

1–2 Beds

$3,090–$3,900

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of Fulton St

Fulton St, West Babylon, NY, 11704

Our team has verified this company

West Babylon • Fulton St

1 Bed

$3,085

dogs and cats ok
No
in-unit laundry
No
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 90 Chapel Hill Drive

90 Chapel Hill Drive, Brentwood, NY, 11717

Brentwood • 90 Chapel Hill Drive

3 Beds

$3,100

dogs and cats ok
No
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 156 E Pulaski Rd

Eagle Rock Apartments at Huntington Station

Our team has verified this company

Huntington Station • 156 E Pulaski Rd

2–3 Beds

$2,685–$3,080

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 1710 Devonshire Rd

Renaissance Hills

Our team has verified this company

Hauppauge • 1710 Devonshire Rd

1–3 Beds

$2,550–$3,950

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
No
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 725 Eastview Dr

The Villas on Eastview

Central Islip • 725 Eastview Dr

2 Beds

$3,300–$3,700

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 1700 E 5th St

Avalon Huntington Station

Our team has verified this company

Huntington Station • 1700 E 5th St

1–2 Beds

$3,090–$3,707

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 100 Court North Dr

Avalon Melville

Our team has verified this company

Melville • 100 Court North Dr

1–2 Beds

$3,390–$3,860

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 313 Avalon Cir

Avalon Commons

Our team has verified this company

Nesconset • 313 Avalon Cir

1–2 Beds

$3,090–$3,900

dogs and cats ok
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of Fulton St

Fulton St, West Babylon, NY, 11704

Our team has verified this company

West Babylon • Fulton St

1 Bed

$3,085

dogs and cats ok
No
in-unit laundry
No
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 90 Chapel Hill Drive

90 Chapel Hill Drive, Brentwood, NY, 11717

Brentwood • 90 Chapel Hill Drive

3 Beds

$3,100

dogs and cats ok
No
in-unit laundry
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes

Check availability

Full name*
Move-in date
Floor plan
By sending this inquiry, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values. By providing my phone number, I consent (not a condition of purchase) to be called and texted by Mid Island Apartments.