Zumper
modified
5+ Days Ago

Highlights

  • Reading nook
  • Fire pit
  • Amtrak
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Heat
  • Modern comforts

Location

43 Pennywise Lane, Old Saybrook, Connecticut 06475, United States

Tour 43 Pennywise Lane

Contact

Phoebe Finch

William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty

(844) 329-2781 ext. 3535

Amenities for 43 Pennywise Lane

Apartment Amenities

Fireplace

Appliances

In-Unit Laundry

Building

BasementResidents Lounge

Grounds

Outdoor Space

Other

Architecture Style: ColonialHot Water Heating
None (Cooling)Oil
Units, floor plans, amenities, dimensions, details, availability, and prices may be approximate and subject to change. Please contact a community representative for more information.

Policies and fees

Dog Policy

Not allowed

Cat Policy

Not allowed

No pets allowed.

Questions about this property’s policies and fees?

Advertisement

About 43 Pennywise Lane

HomeHouses in Old Saybrook 43 Pennywise Lane, Old Saybrook, Connecticut 06475, United States

Property Status: Active Step into this delightful and charming fisherman's cottage in the heart of downtown Old Saybrook. Built in 1800, 43 Pennywise Lane blends warm and cozy character with surprising spaciousness. The owner has preserved this home's historical integrity while adding in modern comforts. The first floor features an oversized primary suite with full bath, office space and reading nook. The eat-in kitchen is highlighted by gleaming wood counters and a beautiful decorative fireplace. Rounding out the first floor, you'll find the sun filled napping corner, a tucked away charming TV area and a second full bath. You'll also appreciate the mini-mudroom drop zone perfect for your bags, boots and hats! Upstairs you'll find an additional bedroom and a second media or lounge area. This space is ideal for guests or a quiet place to unwind. Enjoy the convenience of an outdoor shower, grill, fire pit and the nicely sized, partially fenced in yard. Fancy a stroll to town? It's just down the block with terrific shopping and dining. Enjoy all the amenities that make this shoreline town so popular and accessible, including access to Amtrak and the Shoreline East Train. Tenant: renters insurance, heat, electric, water and a one time end of lease cleaning. Landlord: all other utilities. No pets or smoking. A truly special place to "hang your hat" and unplug for the season! Available Dec 15, 2025 - May 31, 2026. Office Phone: (203) 245-6700 Copyright © 2025 SmartMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.


Source: CTMLS|MLS Listing No. 24141368

Go to property website

Address details

Zip code06475
TypeHouse for rent

Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere

Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.
Email*
By clicking submit, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values.

Rent trends in Old Saybrook

2-bedroom apartments at 43 Pennywise Lane cost about 2% more than the average rent price for 2-bedroom apartments in Old Saybrook.

Median rents as of Nov 22 2025.
Old Saybrook
A table of 2-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Old Saybrook
MonthMedian Rent
December 2023$2,922
January 2024$2,922
February 2024$3,474
March 2024$3,288
April 2024$3,366
May 2024$3,250
June 2024$3,175
July 2024$3,295
October 2024$2,930
November 2024$2,748
December 2024$3,295
January 2025$3,295
February 2025$3,295
May 2025$3,450
June 2025$3,362
July 2025$3,363
August 2025$3,047
September 2025$2,938
October 2025$2,864
November 2025$2,864

Affordability calculator

Can I afford to live at 43 Pennywise Lane?

Bedrooms

2 bedrooms

Rent-to-income ratio

30%

Slide to adjust the percentage of your monthly income you are willing to spend on rent.
The general rule of thumb is to spend around 30% or less of your income on rent.
Recommended income

$120,000/yr

With your selected rent-to-income ratio, you'd ideally want to make $120,000 annually to afford this 2-bedrooms monthly rent price of $3,000.
For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator.

Schools near 43 Pennywise Lane

Kathleen E. Goodwin School

80 old boston post rd

old saybrook, CT, 6475

PK, K-4Public
A-
Powered byniche.com
Advertisement

Internet available near 43 Pennywise Lane

Getting around Old Saybrook near 43 Pennywise Lane

Walking

4/10
Some shops and stores are within a few minutes.

Driving

10/10
Commuting is easy with multiple accessible routes and plenty of parking.

Cycling

5/10
More spots are within biking distance and some roads are cyclist-friendly.

Transit

3/10
There are a few mass transit options within the area.

Points of interest for 43 Pennywise Lane, Old Saybrook

Groceries

7/10
At least one supermarket within a 15-minute walk

Shopping

5/10
Several shops within walking distance

Cafes

5/10
Some cafés within a few minutes’ walk

Restaurants

4/10
Some restaurants within a few minutes’ walk

Primary schools

10/10
At least one elementary school within a 5-minute walk

High schools

8/10
At least one high school within a 15-minute walk

Nightlife

3/10
Some bars within walking distance

Explore the area around 43 Pennywise Lane

Tissas Country Market & Cafe
855 Boston Post Rd
Stop & Shop
665 Boston Post Rd
Stop & Shop Supermarket
665 Boston Post Rd
Big Y
22 Spencer Plain Rd
Big Y
90 Halls Rd

Compare similar properties nearby

featured image of 27 Plains Road

Essex Holdings, LLC

27 Plains Road

2 Beds

$2,450

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
No
in-unit laundry
No
hardwood floor
No
featured image of 159 Main Street #E

159 Main Street #E, Chester, CT, 06412

159 Main Street #E

2 Beds

$2,100

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of Marina Point Dr

Marina Point Villas (MPC)

Marina Point Dr

2 Beds

$3,595

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
No
hardwood floor
No
featured image of 14 High Street

14 High Street, Niantic, CT, 06357

14 High Street

3 Beds

$2,100

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of 36 Center Beach Ave #NA

36 Center Beach Ave #NA, Old Lyme, CT, 06371

36 Center Beach Ave #NA

3 Beds

$2,400

The price shown is for a 12-month lease and includes base rent plus any required monthly fees listed by the property.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of 3 Vincent Ave #NA

3 Vincent Ave #NA, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

3 Vincent Ave #NA

3 Beds

$3,900

The price shown is for a 12-month lease and includes base rent plus any required monthly fees listed by the property.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
No
featured image of 293 Hamburg Road

293 Hamburg Road, Lyme, CT, 06371

293 Hamburg Road

3 Beds

$2,800

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of 49 Cottage Rd

49 Cottage Rd, Madison, CT, 06443

49 Cottage Rd

1 Bed

$2,500

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
No
in-unit laundry
No
hardwood floor
No
featured image of 27 Plains Road

Essex Holdings, LLC

27 Plains Road

2 Beds

$2,450

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
No
in-unit laundry
No
hardwood floor
No
featured image of 159 Main Street #E

159 Main Street #E, Chester, CT, 06412

159 Main Street #E

2 Beds

$2,100

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of Marina Point Dr

Marina Point Villas (MPC)

Marina Point Dr

2 Beds

$3,595

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
No
hardwood floor
No
featured image of 14 High Street

14 High Street, Niantic, CT, 06357

14 High Street

3 Beds

$2,100

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of 36 Center Beach Ave #NA

36 Center Beach Ave #NA, Old Lyme, CT, 06371

36 Center Beach Ave #NA

3 Beds

$2,400

The price shown is for a 12-month lease and includes base rent plus any required monthly fees listed by the property.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of 3 Vincent Ave #NA

3 Vincent Ave #NA, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

3 Vincent Ave #NA

3 Beds

$3,900

The price shown is for a 12-month lease and includes base rent plus any required monthly fees listed by the property.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
No
featured image of 293 Hamburg Road

293 Hamburg Road, Lyme, CT, 06371

293 Hamburg Road

3 Beds

$2,800

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
Yes
in-unit laundry
Yes
hardwood floor
Yes
featured image of 49 Cottage Rd

49 Cottage Rd, Madison, CT, 06443

49 Cottage Rd

1 Bed

$2,500

The price shown is for a 12-month lease. Fees may apply.
dishwasher
No
in-unit laundry
No
hardwood floor
No

Check availability

Full name*
Move-in date
By sending this inquiry, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values. By providing my phone number, I consent (not a condition of purchase) to be called and texted by 43 Pennywise Lane, Old Saybrook, Connecticut 06475, United States.