Houses for Rent in Monticello, IN

Experience lakeside living in this beautifully crafted 3-bedroom wood home on Lake Shafer, perfect for a short-term stay. At 1,284 square feet, this fully furnished rental includes utilities and everything needed for waterfront enjoyment. A serene getaway with no pets or smoking allowed, ensuring a cozy and clean environment for your temporary retreat.

Experience serene living in this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home on a peaceful pond in Monticello. Spanning 1,064 square feet, it features a bright layout, a cozy fireplace, and ample room for gatherings. The basement offers valuable storage, while the attached garage adds convenience. Enjoy tranquil mornings by the water in your private outdoor space, perfectly blending comfort and tranquility for your growing family.

Experience lakeside living in this charming 2-bedroom cottage on Lake Shafer, featuring stunning views and a covered porch. The open-concept layout includes a modern kitchen and dining gazebo, perfect for gatherings. Enjoy comfort with a queen Sleep Number bed, fast fiber internet, and a fully furnished interior. Outdoor fun awaits with a swimming dock and ample parking, including 50 amp EV charging. Just a short drive to downtown Monticello and Indiana Beach. All utilities included!