Apartments for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY

Property Status: Active Experience the epitome of luxury living in this chic duplex builder's penthouse condominium located in the heart of Sag Harbor Village. This unique, stunning and tastefully decorated 1350 +/- sf turn-key property offers breathtaking water views over the marina and Sag Harbor Cove, providing unforgettable sunsets year-round. The entrance level is home to two beautifully appointed ensuite bedrooms. The primary suite boasts its own spacious 150 +/- sf private deck with water views, ample closet space and marble bath and 3 closets. The well-sized guest

Property Status: Active Instantly delightful, this two bedroom two bath home with 3rd bedroom flex space is accessed through a private garden off the landscaped Church Street courtyard at Watchcase. Offering a spacious greatroom with open kitchen and large center island, the oversized windows open onto the second larger garden allowing light to fill the residence. The exposed brick walls and old pine beamed 11 ft ceilings add to the architectural heritage and Watchcase spirit. The master bedroom offers a generous walk in closet and luxurious 5 fixture master bath with Watc

Property Status: Active Spend your time tucked away on this quiet street in the heart of Sag Harbor. This newly renovated three bedroom, one and a half bathroom cottage offers designer style finishes and decor. The ambiance is superb with a seamless connection between the indoor and outdoor spaces. Ideal for summer entertaining with a nice sized yard, deck and patio. Overlooks the beautiful bay views and only a stone's throw to Sag Harbor bay beaches and golf courses. Office Phone: (631) 537-7700 Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided

Property Status: Active Welcome to your perfect getaway in Sag Harbor's coveted Baypoint neighborhood! This beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 2,000 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, including a delightful separate artist studio with its own full bath and kitchenette. Nestled on a .12-acre lot, this serene property features a lush private garden and a charming patio, seamlessly connecting the main house and studio. Inside, you'll find a bright and stylish interior, complete with a cozy fireplace, the main-level features two bedrooms, a

Property Status: Active This chic Sag Harbor cottage is located just steps to Sag Harbor's spectacular Long Beach, known for its beautiful sunsets. Recently renovated, this two bedroom gem is located on a quiet street just a few miles to the center of Sag Harbor Village. Spread out over 800 square feet, this cottage offers an open floor plan with a high cathedral ceiling, a fireplace, dining area, kitchen with granite countertops, brand new stainless steel appliances, hardwood floors, and an updated bathroom. An expansive covered front porch and spacious dining/lounging ar

Property Status: Active Effortlessly stylish and hotel-level comfortable, this Sag Harbor beach house in Pine Neck checks every box. With four bedrooms, three-and-a-half baths, and a spacious lower level for entertaining, it's fully stocked and move-in ready. Decorated by a noted designer, the home features vaulted, high-gloss ceilings, skylights throughout, and a Viking kitchen with marble counters. Decking runs 50' along the back of the house flanking the heated gunite 34' long pool. Minutes from ocean beaches, a stone's throw from Circle Beach, moments from Sag Harbor V

Property Status: Active This Sag Harbor home built in the 1890's has been lovingly restored with all modern amenities by the architect and fashion designer owners, as featured in HC&G in 2021 (See attached under flip book tab). Attention to detail is evident throughout, with thoughtful finishes and impeccable woodwork. The reclaimed oak floors feature intricate herringbone and parquet de Versailles patterns. The common areas are cozy and intimate, including an inviting living room with a fireplace, a wood paneled dining room with custom bookshelves, and a sun-drenched fami

Property Status: Active Situated on an acre in Sag Harbor's exclusive Northside Hills community just off Deerfield Road is this beautifully renovated 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath home. The large living room with wood-burning fireplace has many large windows making it an open airy and light filled home. Gorgeous new kitchen has a new marble and stainless steel appliances. Also on the main level is a den for some quiet, and the primary suite, which has a sleek bath with a soaking tub and a large, glass- enclosed shower and a guest room with an ensuite bath. The remaining bedrooms are

Property Status: Active Nestled on a private pondfront acre just moments outside of Sag Harbor Village is this beautifully decorated and appointed 3 bedroom home. With 2200 sf of living space, the rooms are sizable and open and gives prospective tenants plenty of room to spread out. There is a double height great room with a full wall of windows and doors that bring the outside in, eat in kitchen, formal dining area, and large deck for entertaining. The grounds offer a free form swimming pool and beautiful gardens. Direct access to pond and nature trails/greenbelt. A truly

Property Status: Active Located in a private waterfront community, this well maintained family home is being offered for rent for the first time. Beautiful water views over Mill Creek with access to Clam Island County Park Beach and Noyac Bay. First floor offers 2 bedrooms, 1 full and 1 half bath, eat in kitchen, separate dining room opening to a large living room with fireplace, sunroom opens to a outdoor entertaining and dining deck and a beautiful yard. Second floor offers 2 additional bedrooms and a full bath. Newly listed! Office Phone: (516) 729-5595 Copyright © 2026

Property Status: Active This stunning summer getaway is situated just 1.5 miles to Sag Harbor Village and Long Beach and features two structures on one perfectly maintained property. The main house is newly built and features a brick mudroom entry with heated floors leading into the main living spaces. The kitchen is fully equipped with top-grade stainless appliances, wine fridge and bar, and formal dining area. The living room is cozy with a fireplace, and large flatscreen TV. This level also has a powder room. Upstairs, the primary suite has a walk in closet, fireplace,

Property Status: Active Exclusive, quiet waterfront community in North Haven minutes to the Village of Sag Harbor. Well furnished country home set on one and a third acres, airy and light-filled. New state of the art kitchen with open dining area. Five bedrooms with a wonderful master, wonderful details and extra's, quality bedding, all tastefully done. White detailed living room and separate den. Private beach access, leave your paddle boards and kayaks there for easy access. The best of Sag Harbor, near the ferry to Shelter Island and minutes from the ocean. A perfect re

Property Status: Active Watchcase Penthouse PH-402 | Sag Harbor Perched high above Sag Harbor Village within the iconic and historically significant Watchcase Factory, Penthouse PH-402 offers a rare opportunity to experience refined Hamptons living with sweeping water views and exceptional indoor-outdoor entertaining spaces. Spanning approximately 1937 square feet over two living levels, this elegant 3-bedroom residence features 2 full bathrooms, 2 powder rooms, and a spectacular private rooftop terrace designed for effortless luxury. The main entry level opens into a dram

Property Status: Active On the doorsteps of Sag Harbor Village, nestled between Otter Pond and Sag Harbor Cove is this completely rebuilt Seafarers Cottage by Frank Greenwald Architects. Set off Main Street by Canio's bookstore you enter the property to a generous car park for three to four vehicles in a green setting featuring reclaimed local granite curb stones set in turf, rare for the village. The front porch for sunset viewing, includes a glimpse of the cove and featuring a custom made dutch entrance door with the finest hardware. Stunning, yet quaint, the front foyer

Property Status: Active State-of-the-art and eloquently constructed by notable architect Frank Greenwald is this modern gem on Harry's Lane in Sag Harbor. Pull up to a towering wall of glass above the lower-level garage and drop your bags. The proper entry foyer with a powder room opens up to the living room with vaulted ceilings and Mill Creek Harbor water views. The three bedrooms are upstairs all with ensuites and the primary bedroom with water views. The sleek stainless kitchen overlooks the heated gunite pool with outdoor seating and al fresco dining options. Stone's

Property Status: Active Welcome to 32 Sunset Drive, nestled in the highly sought-after Bay Point community of Sag Harbor where summer memories are made. This beautifully appointed four-bedroom, three-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and effortless Hamptons living. Thoughtfully designed, the layout includes a first-floor bedroom and full bath ideal for guests or anyone preferring to avoid stairs. Sunlight fills the home, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere throughout, while the open living spaces flow seamlessly for both relaxing and entertaining.

Property Status: Active Well located on a quiet street only 3,200 feet from the center of Sag Harbor Village is this five bedroom shingled residence by developer Bruce Bronster. The front entry flows to an open kitchen and separate dining area perfect for entertaining. The great room with elevated ceilings has a brick herringbone wood burning fireplace and a row of doors leading to the large outdoor four season room (screened in the summer and glass in the off season). Here you will find an oversized dining table, enough to fit over 10 guests, as well as a living room with

Property Status: Active Traditional shingled home with stunning details, completely renovated with first level and second floor oversized bedrooms. Beautiful chef's kitchen and pantry with full laundry, vaulted light-filled family room addition leads to outdoor space for entertainment and dining al fresco. Total privacy, including a stone walled garden, fountain and mature plantings. Off-street parking for two cars on a coveted and quiet side street in the heart of Sag Harbor's historic village center. Moments to a wealth of amenities including premier shops, restaurants,

Property Status: Active Sited in the center of historic Sag Harbor Village, this new apartment offers the best of luxury living in an unmatched location. Inside, the apartment is brand new with pristine new appliances. It's easy to love this space with elegant, recessed lighting and hardwood floors. Shared spaces are filled with natural light and are perfect for relaxing and entertaining dinner parties. Redone bathrooms are pristine and boast glass-walled showers. The luxurious eat-in kitchen has high-end appliances, a large center island, and elegant lighting built into t

Property Status: Active Here is a rare opportunity to live in the very heart of Sag Harbor Village, where you can arrive at restaurants, shops, historic sites, the movie theater, Bay Street and all the other delights of this uniquely charming village...without a car! This spacious apartment has two bedrooms and two baths in 1,092+/- sq. ft. of living space. Both bedrooms have closets; one is a walk-in. A central hall brings you to the dining room, kitchen with high ceiling and including a dishwasher. A very special feature is a living room in a turret with a soaring 14-foo

Property Status: Active This newly refreshed four bedroom three full bath home is located in Sag Harbor Village. It has been professionally decorated, painted inside and out and includes new contents and furnishings. The open living areas are bright and inviting comprised of a living room and dining area as well as an updated eat-in kitchen with white cabinetry and stainless steel appliances. Two private guest bedrooms are located on the main floor as well as a full bath. Upstairs is an open loft with a daybed,TV, and a serene master suite with a vaulted ceiling and full b

Property Status: Active This lovely two bedroom apartment sits across from Otter Pond. Centrally located, it allows for easy access to Sag Harbor and Bridgehampton Villages. Long bay beaches and local restaurants located just a short distance away. Private balcony, BBQ area and private parking. Office Phone: (631) 537-5454 Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Rental Reg. # RP250266. Renovated summer cottage with hardwood floors, central air, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, enclosed sun porch, and large fenced-in yard. Clean and carefree house that is convenient to Long Beach and Sag Harbor Village. Listing ID: 743611

RP260682: 3 bedroom 2 Full bath Stylish Contemporary. Sun drenched upper level with open concept. Bedrooms and baths on main level~ Ideal Location. Exterior balcony and Pool~side retreat area is all new and quite serene. Listing ID: 861609

Be the first to experience this exceptional Hamptons rental at 31 Tredwell Lane in Sag Harbor, offered for rent for the very first time. Beautifully renovated and nestled within the coveted Northampton Colony, this waterfront community offers private access to a stunning bay beach. Set on 1.18+/- lush acres, the property perfectly balances tranquility and sophistication. The expansive grounds create a serene, park-like setting, with mature landscaping that enhances the natural beauty of the surroundings. Spanning 4,340+/- sf, this beautifully updated home features 4 bedro