House for rent

Updated 3 Days Ago

19 Peconic Ave
19 Peconic Ave, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA

Monthly rent	$18,000
Beds	3
Baths	3
Sqft	1,431

Monthly rent	$18,000
Beds	3
Baths	3
Sqft	1,431

Updated 3 Days Ago

Highlights

Private en-suite bathroom
Outdoor dining
Three spacious bedrooms
Peaceful location
Grill
Volleyball

Location

19 Peconic Ave, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA

Tour 19 Peconic Ave

Contact

Melissa Gonzalez

Serhant LLC

(646) 480-7665

Amenities for 19 Peconic Ave

Grounds

Outdoor Space

Units, floor plans, amenities, dimensions, details, availability, and prices may be approximate and subject to change. Please contact a community representative for more information.

Policies and fees

Applicants

One-time.

Contact Property

REQUIRED FEES

Security Deposit

One-time. Refundable.

Contact Property

About 19 Peconic Ave

Home

19 Peconic Ave, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA

Property Status: Active Escape to the peaceful charm of Shelter Island, where quiet mornings, fresh coastal air, and a slower pace create the perfect setting to relax, reconnect, and recharge. Nestled on nearly 0.8 acres in the desirable Shell Beach neighborhood, this inviting home offers four liveable spaces, three spacious bedrooms and three full bathrooms, den with queen pull out couch, making it ideal for families, couples, or friends seeking an unforgettable island getaway. The primary suite features a king-size bed with a private en-suite bathroom. A second bedroom offers a queen-size bed with a full bath nearby, while the third bedroom comfortably accommodates additional guests with two queen-size beds and an adjacent full bathroom. For added flexibility, the lower-level living room includes a queen-size sleeper sofa, allowing the home to comfortably accommodate larger groups. Step onto the spacious back deck to enjoy your morning coffee, fire up the grill for an al fresco dinner, or unwind after a day of exploring the island. Surrounded by peaceful natural beauty, it's the perfect place to gather with family and friends, enjoy long summer evenings, and embrace the relaxed pace of Shelter Island. Nearby is the private Shell beach and bird sanctuary, where guests can enjoy swimming, kayaking, paddle boarding, or simply relaxing by the water. The property also offers subtle seasonal water views through the neighboring waterfront homes, adding to the home's tranquil coastal setting. To make your stay even more enjoyable, the home includes kayaks, bicycles, volleyball, and board games, 75" TV - everything you need to experience the best of island living. For those looking to enjoy Shelter Island's vibrant social scene, you're just six minutes from the iconic Sunset Beach, known for its waterfront dining, cocktails, and lively atmosphere. You're also just minutes from the beautifully restored The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages, one of the island's premier destinations for fine dining, sunset cocktails, and timeless Hamptons-style elegance. Whether you're planning a family vacation, romantic escape, or simply looking for a place to unplug, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, recreation, and the laid-back luxury that makes Shelter Island such a sought-after destination. Property Highlights - 3 Bedrooms | 3 Full Bathrooms Full Den - Queen size pull out couch - Primary suite with king bed and private en-suite bath - Second bedroom with queen bed - Third bedroom with two queen beds - Queen-size sleeper sofa in the lower-level living room - Nearly 0.8 acres of private property - Spacious back deck with outdoor dining and grill - Short walk to the private Shell Beach Association beach and kayak launch - Seasonal water views - Kayaks, bicycles, volleyball, and board games included - Approximately 6 minutes to Sunset Beach and The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages - Peaceful location near a protected bird sanctuary Office Phone: (631) 500-8800 Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Go to property website

Property highlights

How 19 Peconic Ave compares to other nearby properties.

Positives

Less expensive: The 3-bedrooms are cheaper than other similar listings nearby
Images Available: There are at least 10 photos of this address

Considerations

Greater distance from grade schools: The nearest elementary school is farther than 5 miles away
Greater distance from middle schools: The nearest middle school is farther than 4 miles away

Address details

Zip code	11963
Type	House for rent

Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere

Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.

Rent trends in Sag Harbor

3-bedroom apartments at 19 Peconic Ave cost about 36% less than the average rent price for 3-bedroom apartments in Sag Harbor.

Median rents as of Aug 29 2026.

Sag Harbor

A table of 3-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Sag Harbor
Month	Median Rent
September 2024	$21,666
October 2024	$28,125
November 2024	$27,500
December 2024	$24,500
January 2025	$22,375
February 2025	$26,875
March 2025	$42,000
April 2025	$41,875
May 2025	$26,500
June 2025	$33,060
July 2025	$30,000
August 2025	$25,000
September 2025	$30,000
October 2025	$25,000
November 2025	$25,000
December 2025	$27,500
January 2026	$29,642
February 2026	$30,000
March 2026	$30,000
April 2026	$35,000
May 2026	$40,000
June 2026	$37,500
July 2026	$30,000
August 2026	$29,400