Zumper

73 3rd Ave
73 3rd Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA

Apartment for rent
Monthly rent
$4,500–$7,500
Beds1–4
Baths1–2
Sqft
modified
5+ Days Ago

Highlights

  • coastal living
  • open floor plan
  • modern comfort
  • open-concept living and kitchen area
  • large living room
  • dining area

Units

73 3rd Ave Atlantic Highlands, NJ

Available

A

1 Bed

1 Bath

$7,500

Listed on 09/27/2025
Listed by Jacalyn Grieco
Days on market: 154
Property Status: Active Experience the rare opportunity to rent a truly one-of-a-kind residence in Atlantic Highlands-a once thriving church thoughtfully converted into a stunning space with a spacious loft sleeping area. This unique home features an open-concept living and kitchen area, perfect for hosting intimate dinners or special gatherings. Much of the original charm and historic character has been preserved, blending timeless details with modern comfort. Offered for the very first time as a rental, it's a distinctive space unlike anything else on the market. Just steps from town and the Seastreak Ferry, commuting to NYC for work or play has never been easier. Discover a rental that combines history, convenience, and style in one exceptional package. Can be rented furnished or unfurnished. Call Today! Office Phone: (732) 936-5248 Copyright © 2026 More MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Available

B

2 Beds

1.5 Baths

$4,500

Listed on 11/02/2025
Listed by Jacalyn Grieco
Days on market: 118
Property Status: Active A spacious 2 bedroom - 1.5 bath one-of-a-kind rental in Atlantic Highlands is ready for you. This amazing space boasts an open concept living area/dining area with a chef's kitchen, a wine refrigerator plus a center island with seating for four. Just steps away from downtown shops, restaurants, and the Seastreak Ferry, commuting to NYC for work or play has never been easier. Discover a rental that combines history, the tranquility of coastal living, convenience to Sandy Hook, Sea Bright, Red Bank, Asbury, etc in one exceptional package. Can be rented furnished or unfurnished. Call Today! Office Phone: (732) 936-5248 Copyright © 2026 More MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Available

C

4 Beds

2.5 Baths

$5,500

Listed on 11/02/2025
Listed by Jacalyn Grieco
Days on market: 118
Property Status: Active Welcome to the historic charm of this 4 bedroom - 2.5 bath rental that is part of a beautifully converted church offering a blend of historic allure and modern living. Enter this fully renovated home and be welcomed by an open floor plan offering a large living room, an open concept chef's kitchen and dining area plus a 1/2 bath. Upstairs you will find 4 spacious bedrooms complemented by 2 very large full bathrooms. Just steps away from downtown shops, restaurants, and the Seastreak Ferry, commuting to NYC for work or play has never been easier. Discover a rental that combines history, the tranquility of coastal living, and convenience to Sandy Hook, Sea Bright, Red Bank, and Asbury all in one place! Can be rented furnished or unfurnished. Call Today! Office Phone: (732) 936-5248 Copyright © 2026 More MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.