Zumper
modified
4 Days Ago

Location

23 Old West Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

Tour 23 Old West Lake Dr

Contact

Ash Keyser

Compass

(212) 913-9058

Amenities for 23 Old West Lake Dr

Features

2 FloorsAir Conditioning
FireplaceForced Air
Hardwood FloorWalk-in Closet

Community

Exterior Type: BrickExterior Type: Shake Siding
Fitness CenterOnsite Laundry
Residents LoungeRoof Deck

Grounds

Outdoor SpaceSwimming Pool

Other

Propane HeatingRoof Type: Asphalt
View Type: Lake
Units, floor plans, amenities, dimensions, details, availability, and prices may be approximate and subject to change. Please contact a community representative for more information.

Policies and fees

Applicants

Applicants

One-time.

Contact Property

REQUIRED FEES

Security Deposit

One-time. Refundable.

Contact Property
Advertisement

About 23 Old West Lake Dr

Home 23 Old West Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

Property Status: Active Nestled on a quiet hill in the heart of Montauk, just a few doors down from the iconic Crows Nest Restaurant and Inn, moments from downtown Montauk, and less than a mile from the world-renowned Ditch Plains Beach, this fully renovated 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of luxury, excitement, and tranquility. Boasting breathtaking views of Lake Montauk from the expansive rooftop deck, along with central AC and solar panels, this residence merges modern amenities with timeless Montauk charm. The open-concept main floor features a junior en suite (queen bed), two guest rooms (queen bed and 2 twins/combined for king bed), and a spacious kitchen with stainless steel appliances and an eat-in bar. The welcoming living room with gas fireplace, formal dining room, and mudroom with laundry provides seamless access to the outdoor stone patio and pool. Upstairs, the private primary suite is a relaxing oasis, with a walk-in closet, two balconies, a home office, a sitting area, and serene views. The finished lower level adds to the home's appeal, offering a media room for relaxation, pool table and table shuffleboard for competition, and a fully-equipped gym and sauna for ultimate comfort and wellness. The outdoor space is an entertainer's dream, complete with a heated saltwater pool, hot tub, fire pit, Cambridge bluestone patio, outdoor shower, dining table, and covered lounge area. Experience the very best of Montauk living at 23 Old West Lake Drive. Office Phone: (631) 537-7700 Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.


Go to property website

Property highlights

We compared every listing in the surrounding area to determine which amenities are most common. If a building lacks an amenity that most others in the area have, it is a con. If a building has an amenity most others in the area do not, it is a pro. Similarly, price, schools, and size are calculated relative to the size, price, and distance to schools of the other properties nearby.

How 23 Old West Lake Dr compares to other nearby properties.

Positives

More space
The 4-bedroom is 963 sqft larger than other listings nearby
Fireplace
Upgraded in-unit features available
Images available
There are at least 10 photos of this address
Laundry available on site
Washers and dryers are available in-building or in-unit
Roof deck
Access to public roof space
Walk-in closet
Rentals here may include more closet space than average

Considerations

Greater distance from grade schools
The nearest elementary school is farther than 2 miles away

Address details

Zip code11954
TypeHouse for rent

Get the latest listings anytime, anywhere

Receive similar listings in the area, download our app, and more.
Email*
By clicking submit, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values.

Rent trends in Montauk

4-bedroom apartments at 23 Old West Lake Dr cost about 50% more than the average rent price for 4-bedroom apartments in Montauk.

Median rents as of Jul 4 2026.
Montauk
A table of 4-bedroom apartment rental data trends in Montauk
MonthMedian Rent
March 2026$30,000
April 2026$30,000
May 2026$30,000
June 2026$30,000
July 2026$40,000

Affordability calculator

Can I afford to live at 23 Old West Lake Dr?

Bedrooms

4+ bedrooms

Rent-to-income ratio

30%

Slide to adjust the percentage of your monthly income you are willing to spend on rent.
The general rule of thumb is to spend around 30% or less of your income on rent.
Recommended income

$2,400,000/yr

With your selected rent-to-income ratio, you'd ideally want to make $2,400,000 annually to afford this 4-bedrooms monthly rent price of $60,000.
For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator.

Schools near 23 Old West Lake Dr

Montauk School

50 s dorset dr

montauk, NY, 11954

PK, K-8Public
A

Amagansett School

320 main street

amagansett, NY, 11930

PK, K-6Public

Springs School

48 school st

east hampton, NY, 11937

PK, K-8Public
B
Powered byniche.com
Advertisement

Internet available near 23 Old West Lake Dr

Neighborhood

NEIGHBORHOOD VIBE
Peaceful and quiet
Noise-canceling headphones not required in this mostly noise free area.

Getting around Montauk near 23 Old West Lake Dr

Walking

2/10
You’ll need another mode of transportation for getting around. Scooter, anyone?

Driving

8/10
Commuting is easy with multiple accessible routes and plenty of parking.

Cycling

3/10
This is semi-bikeable, but you’ll need another way of getting around.

Transit

0/10
FYI, there are little to no public transit options within walking distance.

Points of interest for 23 Old West Lake Dr, Montauk

Groceries

3/10
Some groceries within a short drive

Shopping

2/10
Few or no shops within a short drive

Cafes

2/10
Few or no cafés within a short drive

Restaurants

5/10
Variety of restaurants within a short drive

Primary schools

0/10
Closest elementary school further than a 30-minute walk

High schools

0/10
Closest high school further than a 30-minute walk

Nightlife

2/10
Some bars within a short drive

Explore the area around 23 Old West Lake Dr

Gaviola's Montauk Market
W Lake Dr & Wells Ave
Montauk IGA-Adam's Hometown Markets
654 Montauk Hwy
Gosman's Retail Fish Market
484 W Lake Dr

Compare similar properties nearby

featured image of 23 Wood Dr

23 Wood Dr

4 Beds

$45,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
No
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 5 Mitchell Dunes Ln

5 Mitchell Dunes Ln

4 Beds

$55,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 617 Old Montauk Hwy

617 Old Montauk Hwy

4 Beds

$60,000

hardwood floor
No
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 34 Fairlawn Dr

34 Fairlawn Dr

4 Beds

$75,000

hardwood floor
No
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 4 Bayberry Rd

4 Bayberry Rd

6 Beds

$60,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 56 Seaview Ave

56 Seaview Ave

3 Beds

$75,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 419 E Lake Dr

419 E Lake Dr

3 Beds

$64,615

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
No
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 6 Gannet Dr

6 Gannet Dr

4 Beds

$45,000

hardwood floor
No
swimming pool
No
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 23 Wood Dr

23 Wood Dr

4 Beds

$45,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
No
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 5 Mitchell Dunes Ln

5 Mitchell Dunes Ln

4 Beds

$55,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 617 Old Montauk Hwy

617 Old Montauk Hwy

4 Beds

$60,000

hardwood floor
No
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 34 Fairlawn Dr

34 Fairlawn Dr

4 Beds

$75,000

hardwood floor
No
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 4 Bayberry Rd

4 Bayberry Rd

6 Beds

$60,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
Yes
featured image of 56 Seaview Ave

56 Seaview Ave

3 Beds

$75,000

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
Yes
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 419 E Lake Dr

419 E Lake Dr

3 Beds

$64,615

hardwood floor
Yes
swimming pool
No
on-site laundry
No
featured image of 6 Gannet Dr

6 Gannet Dr

4 Beds

$45,000

hardwood floor
No
swimming pool
No
on-site laundry
Yes

Check availability

Full name*
Move-in date
By sending this inquiry, I accept Zumper's Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Values. By providing my phone number, I consent (not a condition of purchase) to be called and texted by 23 Old West Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, USA.

1 Shadbush Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
103 Second House Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
109 Deforest Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
139 Madison Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
144 S Essex St, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
15 Maple St, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
15 S Forest St, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
155 Essex St, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
16 Roosevelt Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
16 Wills Point Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
Advertisement